Why try squares?
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
I was raised to use a combination square, but have somehow gathered a range of try squares. Those of you who use try squares in your work: what benefit do you find for them over combination squares?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Why try squares?
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
I was raised to use a combination square, but have somehow gathered a range of try squares. Those of you who use try squares in your work: what benefit do you find for them over combination squares?
Re: Why try squares?
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Hi Bill
It's quite simple really - just drop your combination square on the ground (a wooden floor is satisfactory), and then do the same with a good quality try square. Now check which has retained its accuracy.
The best try square are machinist squares - metal on metal, and one piece construction. Try squares connected with rivets or screws are vulnerable to movement. A combination square relies on the the accuracy of the groove-to-pin connection, which will wear over time, and is vulnerable to damage in an impact.
My favourite square is this 4" by Chris Vesper ...

Regards from Perth
Derek
No awl to lose
Re: Why try squares?
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
One thing I like about a fixed square is that it's easy to test inside square, or test vertical by sitting it on its stock. You can do those things after a fashion with a combination square, but it requires a close adjustment, and it's about to lose it's grip on the blade. The try square fits into the rhythm of the work.
Wiley
Good one!
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
I've taken care of that on some of my combination squares by losing it promptly; then I don't have to worry.
Why not both?
Bob Hackett
There are tasks that each excels at that the other can`t accomplish near as well without modification.
Re: Why try squares?
Jack Guzman from Maine
The only time a try square is not better than a combination square is when the leg gets in the way by being too long. With a combination square you adjust it to fit the job.Otherwise I always prefer it.---Jack
Re: Why try squares?
TomD
There is this thing where there are all purpose tools, or specific purpose tools. Often in the marketplace the all purpose tool seems better, but it may only be better in being all purpose, which isn't always an advantage. Allpurposeness is a winner at the point of sale, because the "features" can be appealing in a gadgety way, and they can reduce the difficulty of making up one's mind when the AP tool seems to be able to do everything.
For trying edges, or drawing perp lines, I use whichever square comes to hand first. Machinist's squares are great for their accuracy, and their cost. I also like wooden squares, they are probably the least likely to go out of square, they are very easy to return to square (if you have another reference to square). They are warm, don't rust, and aren't likely to damage wood.
Thanks, all! Some good information here
Swiss Army knives are all purpose tools
Bruce McCrory
I just haven't figured out how to use the knife blade....
For cutting Swiss cheese
Re: Why try squares?
Bob Lang
I have a Stanley all-metal try square that has a scale marked in 1/8" increments. I like to use it for layout work as it registers the distance from the end of the work and I don't have all those little-bitty lines getting in the way.
Bob Lang
Re: Why try squares?
Curt Putnam
+1
All those litty-bitty lines just add blur - and in the handtool world, how often does one actually measure?
Re: Swiss Army knives are all purpose tools
TomD
I have one somewhere that I used to like quite a bit. But while it had maybe a dozen tools, the two I used were the scissors, and the can opener. I do a lot of bike touring, and a question that comes up a lot is what tool kit should I buy, the answer (given that bikes are rather simple), is to look at every socket, nut, screw, or bolt on the bike, and carry all the tools that fit those parts. Reduce this list by stuff you don't know how to tinker with, and stuff you don't think is at all likely to need fixing. But most people want an answer about what multi tool they should bring even though many times half the stuff does not fit anything on their bike.
Re: Why try squares?
Tony - Memphis
I like the typical wide blade of a try square. It makes the tool more stable and a bit easier to fanagle. I use a combo square a lot though. Sometimes, it is really a matter of which one I grab. The graudations on the combo are good in some cases for marking and such. Also, Santa brought me a Vesper try square and it is just so darn pretty! And, I love the little piece that swivels out to hold the fence up level.
Oh, I really like the small combo squares for marking small parts or ends of boards.
Tony
Re: Why combination squares?
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Bill and all,
They're really distinct tools, though they both check outside square similarly.
The try square (in my hands, anyway) excels in checking inside square or vertical.
But the combination square is wonderful for checking length (as opposed to square). It's a 'try length' maybe
, or a sliding hook rule. I like to set them up for drawer heights, say, and keep the setting til the drawers are all assembled and fit. Also useful for laying off panel widths--slide the square along and mark holding the pencil against the end. Some square blades are incised at the end to facilitate this. I wish they would put an end-reading scale on them, because I never have my end-reading rule when I want it.
Wiley