New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

***SAW DICTIONARY is Now on Sale*** *LINK*

Posts

***SAW DICTIONARY is Now on Sale*** *LINK*

#1

Ellis Walentine

***SAW DICTIONARY is Now on Sale*** *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

Forgive the promotional hoopla. This is the book that Dan and I resurrected almost six years ago and it's finally seeing the light of day. With a new introduction by Don McConnell, this tiny (60 pp including covers) volume is a treasure trove of timeless saw sharpening specifications and techniques -- not the easiest information to grok at first glance, but exactly replicated from the original 1907-1909 edition, thanks to Dan's intrepid photography and my Photoshop work. We could only lay our hands on parts of three existing copies of the original booklet, from libraries in three states, and they were yellowed and torn.

In the book, Johnson discusses hand saws and how to select them for task and quality and sharpen them for optimum performance. He shows you the tools used for setting and filing, and gives directions for building your own saw clamp, a floor-model stand depicted in one of the sample pages below.

Here are a few page views so you can get an idea of what you're in for...








WoodCentral Store

Re: ***SAW DICTIONARY is Now on Sale*** *LINK*

#2

Definitely on my list, Ellis

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

The page view you didn't include, but had included in an earlier thread, is the letter of recommendation from one of my great-uncles, speaking highly of the skills of the book's author. So I'll get a two-fer: interesting information on saw maintenance and some family history.

Maybe my brother needs one of these, too...

Re: ***SAW DICTIONARY is Now on Sale*** *LINK*

#3

Re: ***SAW DICTIONARY is Now on Sale***

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Ellis,

Would this book be recommended for a person who has never sharpened a saw before and wants to learn how? Would it be good for a complete beginner.

The timing of this is perfect. I have been looking into this and thinking about going down that road...

I have an old Disston backsaw that was my dad's. I'd like to make a rip saw out of it if that's possible (it's crosscut now).

Thanks.

Re: ***SAW DICTIONARY is Now on Sale*** *LINK*

#4

Ellis Walentine

Absolutely

Ellis Walentine

This book doesn't assume you're already an able sharpener. Once you figure out the graphics and parse his words, all the essential considerations are there -- the various angles for different types of saws and tasks, the principles of holding the saw properly in the saw clamp for sharpening, the tools they used to joint and file and set saws -- which havent changed much, by the way -- along with some good awarenesses of the range of saws and possibilities.

Back at the turn of the last century, skilsaws didn't exist, and pretty much every homeowner was his own carpenter, with quite a collection of saws and chisels and planes. The variety of new saws available for purchase was much greater then, but the majority of those saws have survived pretty well, give or take corrosion and wear, so if you prowl the flea markets and yard sales, you can still find a lot of the sizes and types of saws that Johnson mentions in his book. He was particularly fond of Atkins saws, apparently. I don't know if he might have had a little sweetheart relationship with that company, but I'm going to keep my eyes open for that brand in the future.

Suit yourself.

Ellis

Re: ***SAW DICTIONARY is Now on Sale*** *LINK*

#5

Re: ***SAW DICTIONARY is Now on Sale***

Marv

Hi Joe,

If you decide to use the book to learn how to file handsaws, please report back as to how easy it was to follow and learn all the details involved in filing handsaws, including backsaws.

Thanks, :)

Marv

Re: ***SAW DICTIONARY is Now on Sale*** *LINK*

#6

Ellis Walentine

Handsaws

Ellis Walentine

Marv, if you've read Johnson's book, you know that the handsaws he discusses and illustrates filing patterns for are full-size rip and crosscut saws, up to 12-points per inch -- carpenter's tools primarily. It is not about backsaws, except to the extent that his general principles, filing angles and techniques can be generalized to extremely fine rip and crosscut saws. He makes no specific claims about that.

Ellis

Re: ***SAW DICTIONARY is Now on Sale*** *LINK*

#7

This book is unique

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi All,

Just ordered a copy. I was fortunate to see an early draft as Ellis and Dan were doing the research. Now I want to see Don McConnell's Introduction!

This book is eye-opening. It reawakens us to a time when hand sawing and sharpening skills were in market demand. The level of discussion is about fleam, number of teeth, saw length, and rake for performing specific sawing operations--cut off, short miter, long miter, plus coarse and fine for all the above. He gets into combination saw filing and the use of rakers, and specifically how to file them. I don't see this book as a beginner's 'how to' on filing, but rather as an advanced text on adjusting fleam and rake to achieve specific goals. It's mind-expanding compared to the straight rip vs. crosscut paradigm.

The book will appeal to the mathematically or engineeringly inclined, but it is not scholarly. Charles Johnson, the author, is a very detailed, and very opinionated, practitioner. (He is also very partial to Atkins saws and Taintor saw sets).

I think once this book gets around, it will stir plenty of discussion and argument. For example, the author is dead set against side-filing the set. He wants the set even to begin with, and relatively light, and then leave it as-filed. His argument: side-filing reduces the saw's tooth clearance and leads to the saw being captured by the work ('timber bound'). No doubt he will get argument on that point, but his unhedged opinions are refreshing, or at least they are to me! He doesn't think any mechanic should want a rip saw coarser than 5 point or crosscut coarser than 7 point. There are many other specifics in the same vein, such as his take on 'sway-back' saws.

Two thumbs up! Unbeatable deal for $10. If you have a tool library, this book belongs in it.

Wiley

Re: ***SAW DICTIONARY is Now on Sale*** *LINK*

#8

P. S.  The book is rare to extinct in the wild

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

I recall Ellis and Dan Donaldson scouring the entire country to find one whole, clean copy. It's gone in the wild, but brought back alive.

Wiley

Re: ***SAW DICTIONARY is Now on Sale*** *LINK*

#9

Re: Handsaws

Marv

Hi Ellis, :)

I mentioned backsaws so as to raise the question for the benefit of beginner filers who have never filed a saw. Most woodworkers of today who use primarily hand tools might wonder if Johnson's treatise instructs how to file a backsaw with teeth smaller than 12 points. As you said, his instructions can be used for all push saws even though he doesn't specifically focus on that family of saws but does mention miter saws that do have a back.

I first learned to file regular size handsaws and found that transitioning to backsaws was no problem... just smaller teeth and smaller files. Same basic principles are followed.

I might point out that Johnson refers to "rake" as "pitch" and fleam as "bevel". Rake or "pitch" angles are used on both rip and crosscut teeth while fleam or "bevel" is normally used only on crosscut teeth, with some exceptions. Some filers are using a few degrees of fleam on their rip teeth. I file my rip teeth with zero fleam or "bevel".

Thanks, :)

Marv

Re: ***SAW DICTIONARY is Now on Sale*** *LINK*

#11

Re: ***SAW DICTIONARY is Now on Sale***

Ron Bontz

So where does one obtain a copy of said book?

Re: ***SAW DICTIONARY is Now on Sale*** *LINK*

#12

Ellis Walentine

The WoodCentral Store  *LINK*


The WoodCentral Store

Re: ***SAW DICTIONARY is Now on Sale*** *LINK*

#13

Re: ***SAW DICTIONARY is Now on Sale***

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Marv,

I just ordered it.

I'm a slow learner, so.... it may take a while.

Joe