New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

PEC Double Square Review

Posts

PEC Double Square Review

#1

PEC Double Square Review

William Duffield

Late last summer, we had a discussion here on machinist's squares, with some recommendations on the squares made by PEC.

www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/handtools.pl/pro/search/pmd/sread/srchid/2359A4YQYZ546xPzwhf1395098658/spage/1/sanc/469691/sbid/3000/md/read/id/469681/sbj/6-double-square-satin/

Last week, Alan Turner, of the Philadelphia Furniture Workshop, gave a very useful presentation on measuring and marking at the meeting of the CJWA.�

As most of the CJWA members know, I carry a 4" double square in my shirt pocket everywhere I go,� as I find it to be about the most used and versatile tool for woodworking that I own. I used to carry Starrett brand squares, but as you are probably are aware, they are very expensive. After� having dropped more than one into my garden, I am now very careful to choose shirts with secure pockets.�

I was asked to recommend a for high quality, inexpensive source for a viable alternative to the Starrett double squares, and thus wrote this review and distributed it to the CJWA membership.

I get mine from Harry J. Epstein Co. www.harryepstein.com. These squares are made in the USA by Products Engineering Company (PEC). I believe PEC manufactures the "Made in USA"� squares offered by Lee Valley and Woodcraft.�

For a wide variety of PEC squares: http://store.harryepstein.com/c/ProductsEngineering.html

The hardened blades have a satin finish and 4R graduations (8ths, 16ths, 32nds and 64ths of an inch). The heads however, are not hardened.�

Some advantages and disadvantages of the PEC vs. the Starrett squares:

The PECs are substantially more economical that the equivalent Starrett squares. Harry Epstein currently sells the 4" double squares for $15 and the 6" double squares for $17.50.� Compare to the Amazon prices of $62.75 and $78, respectively, for the Starrett equivalents. I can detect no difference in their accuracy, with the exception of one I bought from Lee Valley� several years ago. Lee Valley, of course, took it back and refunded my money without question.�

These rules are "Blems". That means they have one or more cosmetic defects. These defects do not affect the functionality of the squares. They are not marked with the manufacturer's� logo.�

Once the PEC blade is removed from the head, the screw clamp assembly can easily fall out and roll off your bench. The Starrett screw clamp assemblies must be disassembled to remove� them from the heads.�

The hook on the end of the PEC screw clamp does not slide as easily into the groove in the blade, making blade reversal a bit more tedious. This can easily be remedied with judicious� application of 600 grit sandpaper to soften the edges of the clamp. (Or, you can buy two, at less than half the price of a Starrett, so you don't ever need to reverse the blade. :^)

The heads and blades of the PEC 6" and 4" squares are interchangeable; the Starretts are not.�

The Starrett 6" double square head has a level, while the PEC 6" head does not. I've never seen a hardened Starrett 4" double square head, and I don't think they make one.�

Note that, as Alan pointed out, if you do buy a Starrett, make sure you get one with a satin finish blade. I find that the less expensive, polished finish Starrett blades are very difficult to read,� and in some lighting conditions almost impossible.

While a 6" double square is not conveniently carried in a shirt pocket, I find it to also be very useful in the shop.�

The heads of the PEC squares are exactly 1" wide; the Starretts are not. This is convenient when doing inside measurements, as you can set the end of the blade flush with the edge of the� head (by feel) and use the rules on the blade directly for inside measurements.

Re: PEC Double Square Review

#2

Starrett 6" double with satin?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Sir Wm. and all,

I bought the PEC blem 6" double square (from Harry Epstein) rather than a Starrett, specifically because Starrett did not make a satin finish blade for the 6" double square, though they did at that time for the 6" combination square and for the 4" double square.

Per Alan Turner's comments that you referenced, does Starrett now make a 6" satin finish blade for the double square?

Thanks,

Wiley.... who likes the PEC blem just fine

Re: PEC Double Square Review

#3

Re: Starrett 6" double with satin?

William Duffield

I'm afraid I'm not going to be much help. Alan didn't bring a 6" double square with him to the meeting. I do not own a 6" Starrett double square. My latest Starrett catalog is dated 1998, but I suspect that with the decline of US industry, Starrett is not adding to their line of traditional tools. That catalog does not provide enough dimensions for me to answer your question. I don't know whether the 6" 4R blade that fits their 6" combination square also fits their 6" double square. I suspect not. IIRC, the width and thickness of the blade for their 6" double square is the same as their 12, 16 and 24" combo square blades, that is approximately 1" x 3/32". But don't trust my recollections, as such a blade, in either regular or satin chrome, is not listed in their table of individual blades.

Since I have both 4" double squares and 4" combination squares from Starrett, I can tell you that they both take the same size blades, approximately 19/32" x 1/16". These blades were available individually in 1998 in 4R graduations in either regular or satin chrome or in 16R in satin chrome only.

Re: PEC Double Square Review

#4

Re: Starrett 6" double with satin?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Sir Wm.,

What i really meant to say is, 'GREAT REVIEW!' and very helpful for maybe the most-used tool in many shops. Your review brings out comparisons which are significant, but which are rarely or never seen in print.

On the detail I brought up, i certainly agree with Alan that you want the satin chrome blade. My brief googling this morning indicates that Starrett still does not make a satin chrome blade for the 6" double square, though it does for the 6" combination square and the 4" double square. Go figure. Satin chrome bladed 6" double squares can be gotten via the PEC brand, Mitutoyo, Lee Valley's own-marked brand, among others. They're not hard to find.

The price points for the 6" double squares that I find are as you noted: roughly $77-78 for the Starrett; $38-39 for a first-quality PEC or for Lee Valley's equivalent 'precision double square'; $17.50 for PEC blem through Harry Epstein. I wouldn't have known my PEC blem was a blem, except that it was advertised as such by Epstein and came marked as a second and without PEC's engraving. There was a slight clouding in small areas of the blade finish, was all I could guess. But I would never notice it. The square is on the money for ruling and squareness, and a pleasure to use.

Thanks for the great review!

Wiley

Re: PEC Double Square Review

#5

Re: PEC Double Square Review

David Churnega

I own a Starrett #13 6" Satin blade in a no-name (Starrett blem) and would carry it with me if I could. Lost the 4" blade some time back.

Re: PEC Double Square Review

#6

Re: Starrett 6" double with satin?

ian in Sydney

I don't know whether the 6" 4R blade that fits their 6" combination square also fits their 6" double square. I suspect not.

I have both the Starrett 6" combo and 6" double square

the combo square has a 3/4" wide blade, the double square a 1" wide blade

re an earlier post on blade width -- I think some Starrett squares have 25mm wide blades -- 1" = 25.4mm

Re: PEC Double Square Review

#7

Re: Starrett 6" double

William Duffield

That's useful data, Ian, and confirms some of my suspicions. First: it means that the Starrett 6" double square head should fit the blades (12", 16", 24", 36") from Starrett's full size combo squares. Second, it means that the Starrett 6" double square is probably too big to fit comfortably in most shirt pockets. (The PEC 6" double square does fit in shirt pockets, even though the blade is a bit longer than most pens and mechanical pencils.)

This also means that you could probably with some difficulty make a 6" blade for the Starrett double square head by cutting down a spare 12" blade. :\

Re: PEC Double Square Review

#8

Re: Starrett 6" double

ian in Sydney

That's useful data, Ian, and confirms some of my suspicions. First: it means that the Starrett 6" double square head should fit the blades (12", 16", 24", 36") from Starrett's full size combo squares.

snip

This also means that you could probably with some difficulty make a 6" blade for the Starrett double square head by cutting down a spare 12" blade.

I've just tried this.

the #13M blade from the 6" double square will fit in the combo head, but the #35 GRAD blade from the 12" combo is too thick to fit the double square. Same story with the Combo square's #4R GRAD blade.

I've got imperial and metric blades for both the 12" combo and 6" double square

Second, it means that the Starrett 6" double square is probably too big to fit comfortably in most shirt pockets.

that's my reckoning -- the stock on the 6" double square is too long

sorry I can't post some pics -- but it's getting on to midnight here

Re: PEC Double Square Review

#9

Re: Starrett 6" double

William Duffield

Thanks, Ian. I'll file that info. I think that's bad news for Wiley. It looks like the Starrett 6" double square is the "odd man out," with a head that will only fit one blade, and no option for a satin chrome blade.

Re: PEC Double Square Review

#10

Cutting down a rule

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

The biggest issue with the idea of cutting down a 12" Starrett rule to 6" is that the numbers run in opposing directions on opposite edges of the rule, something that's true on both faces. So, for instance on a No. 4 or 4R rule, the numbers for 1/8" run from left to right (if you've got the 1/8" increments at the bottom edge of the rule), and the numbers for 1/16" run, upside down, from right to left. When you cut the rule down to 6", half your number sequences will start at 7.

One of my bench rules used to be a 48" Lufkin rule, cut down by a previous owner to 14" and a fraction (I take it because it got bent at 15"). I like it because it's a "blind man's rule" format, and I'm rapidly approaching that state :D . Fortunately, the side that's corroded and hard to read is the side that reads from 34 to 48 inches; the 1-14" side is pretty clean.

Re: PEC Double Square Review

#11

Re: Cutting down a rule

William Duffield

I was being facetious, of course. If you've ever priced a 24" rule for a combo square (new or old), you should realize you can buy a lot of 6" rules for the price of a 24". I think I paid more for my old two foot rule, even though it was "just" a Lufkin, than I paid for my old three head, 12" Starrett combo square. I think I paid more for it than I paid for my Stanley #95 four fold, 4 foot rule.

To be precise, no they don't start at 7, they start at 6. Just as properly numbered rules start at 0, not 1. ;) Maybe, someone at the factory cut off the "0" and the eighth inch or so of steel that was needed to etch the numeral? :D