New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Centre of Effort - Part II

Posts

Centre of Effort - Part II

#1

Centre of Effort - Part II

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

This is part of my effort to understand aspects of hand plane design. So, a little theorising put to the test with the re-handling of a plane.

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Commentary/CentreOfEffortPart2.html

Your thoughts and ideas very welcome.

If you have not read the first article, Part I is here: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Commentary/CentreofEffortinaPlane.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Centre of Effort - Part II

#2

Re: Centre of Effort - Part II

chuck

Thanks Derek. I appreciate the time and thought you expend in writing about the details of your tools and projects.

Re: Centre of Effort - Part II

#4

Re: Centre of Effort - Part II

chuck

Derek,

Ahha yourself. My thoughts are that I appreciate your efforts. My own efforts are too feeble to mention.

But to provide you with a perspective I'll mention them anyway.

My first attempt at plane making resulted in a laminated smooth plane that became a scrub plane when I opened up the mouth unsuccessfully trying to reduce the massive tear out on the sole. I have no idea where this lump of wood is. I have not seen it this century. My second attempt was a skew plane with a piece of lawn mower blade for an iron. It never progressed enough to try on wood. That second attempt has been converted into a huge mallet and the mallet doesn't work very well either.

So my thoughts and ideas are limited to gratefulness for the information that you and others write about the craft.

Most Sincerely and Respectfully,

chuck

Re: Centre of Effort - Part II

#5

Re: Centre of Effort - Part II

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks Chuck. Ignore the planes you have made or tried to make. What about your experiences with the planes you have used?

Go and push your Stanley #4 on a piece of soft wood and take a light cut. Then set ut for a deep cut and push again. Where does your hand go? Where do you feel the pressure? Does your grip change? Try this again with a jointer. If you have a BU plane, compare this with a BD plane that is similar - same areas outlined earlier.

Others try it too, and share your observations.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Centre of Effort - Part II

#6

Re: Centre of Effort - Part II

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Derek and all,

In looking over your excellent pictorial essay on the vertical (western) tote, three things stand out for me, and in this priority:

1-the height of the mechanic

2-the height of the work

3-the angle of the tote which will keep the mechanic's wrist straight, given 1 and 2--straight line from elbow to knuckle.

Thus, the most comfortable angle for the tote depends entirely on items 1 and 2. We might liken the situation to the hang of a western saw handle. Note that the pull plane and the Chinese-Indonesian cross-handle plane avoid these problems.

In the photo of yourself edge-planing the wide board, the work is happening at about your chest height. An upright tote or no tote is going to be best there--or just pull the plane. A Stanley angle tote would require a painfully depressed hand position (below the wrist). On the other hand, at low planing heights (relative to the mechanic's own height)--and we used to hear about 20-something inch planing benches--an upright tote would elevate the hand above the wrist painfully.

I would suggest that items 1 and 2 are dominant considerations for another reason. They have everything to do with preserving the mechanic's back, and creating an efficient line of force from the mechanic's muscles to the cutting angle.

2 cents.

Wiley

Re: Centre of Effort - Part II

#7

Trying plane

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have a beech trying plane that I have used on almost every board for 35 years. It is 22 inches long, the mouth is 7 inches from the front and the angle of the tote is somewhere around 65 degrees. I think it is a good design. I would say that you want a fluid wrist rather than a rigid wrist; the wrist angle changes as the stroke progresses. I think that for the least stress on the joints they all should be fluid, not trying to hold something rigid throughout the stroke.

The new design looks awkward to me. If someone had a large body of work with a traditional design then tried something new for a few years and liked it, it would be worth noting. However using an altered design for a very short period of time does not give much information.

Re: Centre of Effort - Part II

#8

craigd

Re: Centre of Effort - Part II

craigd

For my work and work height (between waist and belly button height), I prefer a much more relaxed tote angle compared to Stanley. My Stanley's are around 60° (by my measurements), whereas my planes are around 45°. I actually don't like my wrist square to my [fore] arm, I like to lead with my thumb, so my planes handle like clothes irons. I'm probably pushing a lot with the web of my thumb and finger.

I do like the way the [untoted] Gordon's handle, there a lot of comfortable ways to use them (and at different heights; I would use my HTG trying plane over a #7 for chest height plane-ing and pull it although I have used the #7 with my elbow basically resting on the wood and it wasn't bad).

Re: Centre of Effort - Part II

#9

Re: Trying plane

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I have a beech trying plane that I have used on almost every board for 35 years. It is 22 inches long, the mouth is 7 inches from the front and the angle of the tote is somewhere around 65 degrees. I think it is a good design. I would say that you want a fluid wrist rather than a rigid wrist; the wrist angle changes as the stroke progresses. I think that for the least stress on the joints they all should be fluid, not trying to hold something rigid throughout the stroke.

The new design looks awkward to me. If someone had a large body of work with a traditional design then tried something new for a few years and liked it, it would be worth noting. However using an altered design for a very short period of time does not give much information.

Hi Warren

Reading your post set off a light bulb. I compiled a set of measurements about several planes, and these are meaningful to me. Hopefully also to others. While I do not mean to suggest that they should create rules for the design of a plane handle - since I do agree with you that the wrist changes as it pushes a plane ... and that it changes (or needs to change) position and angle as the conditions change - there is a pattern that is recognisable.

I'll start with a comment about the new handle for the Trying Plane. It may look awkward, but it works. The question is "why does it work when the previous handle - so close in angle to the one you like (above) - did not work at all?".

One answer to this is simply that the handle angles work for the respective plane designs. Your plane has a handle of around 65 degrees (which is the same as Stanley), while the Trying Plane handle is similar to a Veritas at about 75 degrees. Your trying plane's toe/mouth is 32% of the length of the plane.

Here are measurements of other planes I have:


The first statistic of relevance is that, with the exception of the Trying Plane and Jointer, all planes have a mouth/toe percentage around the 35% mark, which is similar to yours.

The exceptions here are the HNTG Trying Plane and the Jointer, are similar in having a significantly higher percentage (the mouth is relatively further back), with the Trying Plane even further back than the Jointer.

Inference: the longer the toe/mouth percentage, the more the plane will benefit from a horizontal vector, and the shorter the toe/mouth percentage, the more the plane will benefit for down force when planing.

The second statistic is the height where the handle is held relative to the length of the body. The lower planes (Jack, Jointer, Trying Plane) all have a low centre of gravity. They appear to work more efficiently with a low centre of effort (forward vector). The relatively higher planes require more down force. Note that the Krenov smoother (made by JK) has a 45 degree bed, while the lower coffin (shopmade) has a 55 degree bed. It requires significantly more downforce to push than the Krenov. A higher body (3" is common) would be expected to require even more downforce.

My thought at this stage is that Stanley make a handle that has the best of both worlds. It can be held at the upper end, where it imparts downforce. It may also be pushed by the heel of the hand when the vector is horizontal. Some planes, however, may benefit from one extreme or the other (in some cases substitute the hand for a handle). That is for discussion.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Centre of Effort - Part II

#10

Re: Centre of Effort - Part II

James Wateiss

This is more of a visceral response than a reasoned one...

It seems to me that the basic 'control surface' is just in front of the blade, and that I find myself generally pushing towards that point on the sole, and mainly pushing the back end down to maintain engagement/ stability... Regardless of whether I'm pushing a Stanley, or pulling a Dai. And I could see how it would feel wonky if your forward force vector came down behind the blade.

I'd be curious to see where your favorite handles 'point' when you hold them: whereabouts on the sole, with regard to the mouth of the plane. And, where on the sole is the direction of your downward force going, in relation to the mouth of the plane.

Re: Centre of Effort - Part II

#11

Re: Centre of Effort - Part II

Chris

Hi Derek,

love the effort! Combining two entirely difference disciplines (i.e. the mechanics of sails and mechanics of planes). That's how great minds think, that's how creativity happens, that's what progress is made of!

Had to Google Center of Effort (CE). My understanding is that this is a very specific term related to the mechanics of sails and combines aerodynamics with classical mechanics. If you take all the wind forces and add them all up, the action of this is is equivalent to a single force that pushes the sale at one single point, the Center of Effort. The same idea as the center of gravity (CG): take all the gravitational forces add them all up. This is equivalent to a single force that pulls down on an object acting at the center of gravity. Because there is not an awful lot of aerodynamics going on when planing a board, the more traditional concept of center or pressure might be more appropriate than the concept of center of effort. When you use a plane you exert pressure on the handles. Add up all the hand pressure per area, the resulting force is equivalent to a force that acts on the center of pressure. Center of effort, center of pressure, does not really matter, just a different term for pretty much the same overarching idea.

My naive take on this topic is that you want to have as much force that you generate with your hands (ams, legs, etc.) to contribute to the cutting action and as little as possible to generate a moment around the pitch axis (call it y-axis if you want). With this in mid, it appears to me as if out of all the plane designs, the Chinese style plane is the most efficient plane of all.