We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
Warren told us in a previous posting that gouges with "corners" near the tang are referred to as firmer gouges and gouges that taper towards the handle are carving gouges. My question: why did these evolve to be different shapes? Was it that the tapering carving gouges are more comfortable to hold with no corners getting in the way? Why did manufacturers make the differing shape? Why are carving gouges tapered? Better to have side clearance while working? I'm curious why, when and how historically the distinction might have occurred.
For the simple surface carving I've been trying, both type gouges seem suitable. My set of tools is a mix of both types. I purchased them with regards to the width and sweep shapes with total disregard for the true type of gouge I was buying. Live and learn!
I've got several firmer gouges, and I notice they're also a lot heavier in section than my carving gouges. It's been my understanding that they were carpenter's tools, probably mainly for hogging out material; but my understanding here is limited. Looking forward to hearing from Warren and others with more knowledge.
Interesting questions, John. As Bill suggests, a big difference is the thickness of the tools. The firmer gouges tend to be 50% or more thicker. Also the edges of firmer gouges tend to be a lot less delicate. Carving gouges tend to be thin at the edges and we often thin the corners down even more for better access. I think back corners would be awkward on carving gouges, which we often use with both hands on the tool. Firmer gouges are probably much more often struck. Here are some firmer gouges from the Sheffield list.
And some carving gouges form Sheffield:
Here is a gouge from Felibien 1667 next to a mortise chisel in the menuisier section. It appears to be too robust for a carving gouge.
We also have today sculpture gouges. They tend to be larger and heavier than carving gouges and often taper the whole length of the tool so that the width decreases as it is sharpened. You can use all these for carving if you have nothing else.