We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
Was sharpening two carving gouges the other day. One was a WARD, CAST STEEL and the other a W. BUTCHER CAST STEEL. Both roughly the same size. Did the Ward first. I used my Tormek to do the ~25 degree bevel and rounded off the rest of the bevel (they are carving gouges). Cleaned up the bevel rounding and the edge with a 600 grit diamond stone and honed with the Tormek leather wheel. The Ward sharpened up nicely as a test cut in sassafras demonstrated. Then worked on the W. Butcher gouge the same way, same bevels, etc. The test cut in sassafras made the edge crumble. So I increased the bevel angle a bit, honed again, and still crumbled. No matter what I did, the edge crumbled. I got the total bevel angle to upwards of 40 degrees and still the steel was too hard. I have seen this occasionally on other BUTCHER edge tools, i.e. plane blades.
Question 1) - Has anyone else observed this?
Question 2) - Should I simply anneal the blade to remove this extreme hardness and make the tool usable? Lets face it, BUTCHER tools are pretty common here in the east, so unless my annealing experiment really gets screwed up, I would be making a beautiful, yet unusable tool work. I can't say "usable again" because I truly doubt this gouge was ever used - probably no one else in it's long history could get it to hold an edge either.
Can you sharpen the butcher gouge on something that would confirm that it's softer than the ward (e.g., on a natural oilstone where the difference in hardness is shown by how little swarf appears on the stone?).
It hasn't been my experience that butcher tools are generally hard (in relative terms), though that one could be an oddball, but I'd want to know for sure that it was hard before I did anything.
If it is definitely hard, I would remove it from its handle and put it in the oven at 300 degrees for half an hour or so and then try it, incrementing up 25 degrees at a time until I had a temper I could live with.
You could just do that, anyway, and if it doesn't solve the problem, you'll know that it isn't hardness that's the issue, but some other defect.
Had a similar problem several years ago with a practically new English plane iron in a practically unused wooden smoother. I put it in the oven at 350 or 400 (really can't remember which) for about an hour (like a light to medium straw color) ground it back about 1/32" and it's now a wonderful iron. It can't hurt it to throw it in the oven for an hour to re temper it.
You make me cringe, John. I can't believe someone would be so brutal with a delicate little carving gouge. It is possible that once your edge failed there were fractures back into what you thought was good steel. I have had good luck with Butcher tools.
If you think the steel is too hard, I would temper it rather than anneal it. If you anneal it you have to harden it all over again. I tempered a carving gouge to straw color in a wood stove last week. Since they are so delicate, they heat up quickly and you have to be careful not to overdo it. David's method is safer.
I'd agree with warren that working a vintage carving tool edge on a 600 grit diamond, one that's a very plain carbon steel and hardened properly - is pretty harsh.
Still, putting it in the oven at low temperature shouldn't harm anything, but I'd forgo the diamond plate. I can't find too much out there on microfratcuring that's targeted toward woodworkers, but I've never read anything good about deep cutting diamonds on simple steels.
I don't have an Butcher tools but I have a couple of DR Barton slicks and a plane iron (don't remember maker) that do the same thing. If I power grind (eg to establish the bevel), I'll get no end of grief in use due to crumbling.
Maybe I'll draw the temper a bit to see if that helps, they aren't usable [to me] as is.
Thanks for the suggestions and clarifications. I sort of assumed that "annealed" and "tempered" were the same process. In my mind, they always were.
BTW, I always enjoy reading your postings since I usually learn something that is well founded on history and actual practice.
Sorry to make you cringe! I use curved India and Arkansas slip stones and wet/or/dry paper around a dowel to do the inner gouge curvatures. I used the diamond "stone" to shape the rounded heel of the bevel more than actually sharpening the edge. The Tormek process I use starts with a 25 degree bevel, and then grinds a series of maybe 6 or 8 more obtuse bevels to form the rounded heel blending into the back (bottom) of the gouge. I just pull back the tool rest about 1/4" for each step. This usually is enough to make a nice rounding. The diamond stone then smooths off these beveled arrises to form a nice rounded heel. I do this rounding by hand and by eye, but start with the 25 degree bevel using the Tormek angle measuring gauge. The final bevel edge is shaped using a flat soft Arkansas stone, again by eye. I then hone the heel and inner edge on the Tormek leather strops. I've sharpened dozens of carving tools this way, and although I'm really not much of a carver (but I'm willing to learn) this process has worked for me. In fact, I've even modified the v-tool grind that came with Pfiel brand Woodcraft tools as they did not sharpen the tool with this rounded heel. I think the tool guides better with that rounded heel. It just takes more handwork to get this shape and I doubt that commercially is is worth it.
On the subject of the carving gouges themselves, maybe you can illuminate me as to what these really are. They are not "delicate" as the photo shows clearly. The Butcher and New Haven gouges are both ~1-1/2" wide and around an 8 sweep. I was mistaken, it wasn't a Ward gouge, but one by "New Haven". Are these really carving gouges? They are not turning gouges, nor timberframing gouges as those usually have socketed handles. I assumed they are simply very large carving tools. They are the largest gouges I own. Will I use them? - I don't know...
Annealing is heating the steel to critical temperature and very slowly cooling it. The object is that the crystals grow as large as possible and the steel is in its softest state for easy working. To temper steel, we heat to critical temperature and quench it to harden it (small crystals), then we heat it to an intermediate temperature aiming for a specific hardness.
Your gouges are firmer gouges. We generally think of them for rough excavations like roughing out a moulding, starting a hole, or rough shaping. Carving gouges are usually tapered at the back end with no sharp corners. Turning gouges usually have no bolster. I have two Butcher firmer gouges that I sharpen at 30 degrees and have good edge quality.