New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

#7 vs #8 jointer plane

Posts

#7 vs #8 jointer plane

#1

#7 vs #8 jointer plane

Simon St.Laurent - Dryden, NY

I've reached the point - large enough projects, and a workbench top to flatten - where I think a jointer plane is a good idea.

The only one I've actually used was a #8, and it was wonderful. (Well, actually I got to use Scott Meeks' monster wooden jointer at Handworks, and that was amazing, but more challenging both to store and to pay for. I might make one like that someday, and a jointer plane would help...)

The #7 seems more common, and slightly less beast-like than the #8. However, given the tasks, the #8's extra length seems to make more sense.

Any thoughts on which is a better choice?

Thanks!

Re: #7 vs #8 jointer plane

#2

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: #7 vs #8 jointer plane

Jack Guzman from Maine

I had a #8 but since I got my #7 I have never picked it up again. I use it mostly to joint edges for glue-ups. Either one will do fine but the #7 is smaller and easier to handle. So that is my opinion. I'm sure others think differently. It really is a personal preference thing I think. Get both,then you can decide for yourself.---Jack

Re: #7 vs #8 jointer plane

#3

Re: #7 vs #8 jointer plane

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I have both a 7 & 8. The 8 gets used for joint long stuff for long edge joints where closeness of fit really counts. The 7 gets used for everything else. Actually, I think the extra 2" of the #8 doesn't matter that much. It could be that the difference in weight makes a difference in my willingness to use the 7. I don't know, but I like it better.

Re: #7 vs #8 jointer plane

#4

bridger

Re: #7 vs #8 jointer plane

bridger

I have a 6, 7 and 8. as far as appropriate use it's a pretty straightforward selection based on the size of your project and how long you'll have to be manhandling the thing around.

there is another thing you might want to consider when deciding how to populate your plane stable. the #8 has a unique blade size. the #4-1/2, #5-1/2, #6 and #7 can swap blade and chipbreaker sets, which can be a great thing to either expand the versatility of your planes or let you organize your sharpening into one session at the beginning or end of a project.

Re: #7 vs #8 jointer plane

#5

Re: #7 vs #8 jointer plane

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Good points made by all.

I have a couple of wooden jointers, even a 36" monster (which gets used for levelling panels), with the 28" length being the more usable extreme for long edges.

However I still return time and again to the Veritas BU Jointer. I have a Stanley #7, which is a good plane, but the Veritas offers a little more in cutting angles and ease of set up. The other point, Simon, is that the Veritas is a combination of the #7 and the #8 by virtue of having designed in the mouth further back. This creates a plane the total length of a #7 but with the registration (area in front of the mouth) of a #8.

The blade width of the #7 is 2 3/8" and that of a #8 at 2 5/8". That is a lot of blade to push, although a waxed sole does help. The Veritas is 2 1/4" wide. LN make a similar plane. Keep in mind that most edges you plan to plane will be around 3/4" or, if you match plane, around 1 1/2".

Given the choice of #7 or #8, I would plump for the #7 because of blade width and that it is lighter. Given an open checkbook, I would go for one of the BU planes.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: #7 vs #8 jointer plane

#6

Re: #7 vs #8 jointer plane

Tom

So the purpose of a longer jointer, the only thing it achieves as a mater of certainty, like a jelly mold turns out the shape it forms every time, is to dial in a certain amount of spring for a given amount of shaving. There is a ratio of the sole length to a given amount of blade projection. So given that the most popular jointer length seems to be the 7 the most logical assumption is that it does all the normal things as well as any other jointer could do them. So the only reason to require an 8 would be if you lived in, say, a house that was about 14% larger, and contained 14% larger furniture. More realistically, if your average preferred work was a little larger, say tables, but even then there is no real difference, and tables are large, so the weight comes into it.

It is often suggested than an 8 would be better at flattening stuff, or more accurate, because it would span bumps better, but this betrays a misunderstanding:

- On really large surfaces like table tops, a jointer is questionable, but if it is used, it does not span widely enough, you still have to know routine, and measure, and work down certain areas. There is nothing that says this will go any better with a long plane, though it will tire you out. When they really flatten stuff they use s scraper with a point on it, not some tool 22 inches long.

- Spanning high points is a crap shoot, you can't be sure whether they are all a few inches aparts (as they might be if you used a roughing plane), or who is to say they are not the exact distance apart of the 7? And think hard about what happens, exactly how is this all working when you fall off these points as you go forward, or the plane rocks from side to side. While these effects seem simple they are not as simple as all that.

- So what can you do about the lack of simplicity? You just always hollow, if you find a crest beat it down, until the plane stops cutting. At that point you are back to the issue of which plane has the best spring geometry for the work you are doing. So let's assume the 8 is best. All that means is that as you end the process, you would have to reduce the blade projection by 14% to be at the same spring as the 8, but with a 7. Of course nobody really can tell that much of a difference, and if you could, reducing the cut as you finished, could be an advantage.

So people don't really think about it in these terms, though they experience it as they plane. At the end of the day, the differences are slight, and other factors are likely to intrude. If you actually spring joints it does mater, but if you don't (see recent thread), then it is completely irrelevant, you could do the work with a 5.

Re: #7 vs #8 jointer plane

#7

Thank you - that sends me in a bevel up direction

Simon St.Laurent - Dryden, NY

All of these replies have been great. The #7 seems saner now. In particular, though, I'm not sure why I didn't take the bevel-up planes seriously. Maybe it's just because I'd only used the #8, and they seemed just a little too small and too different.

Now I need to explore those options. Lie-Nielsen seems to have a wider blade, and Veritas seems to have more blade possibilities, as well as compatibility with their smaller planes (which I don't have, but...).

Hmm.... Thanks!

Re: #7 vs #8 jointer plane

#8

Re: #7 vs #8 jointer plane

Kees

Originally in the wooden plane world, the really long ones were jointers for edges. Especially edge glueing needs precise straight edges. For panels, tables and such they had a try plane which was a bit shorter. These don't need to be so precise and a shorter plane saves energy.

Re: #7 vs #8 jointer plane

#9

bridger

Re: #7 vs #8 jointer plane

bridger

tom- you're overanalizing this. the #8 is more accurate because of length and more stable because of weight. it's also more work to use, more expensive to buy and doesn't fit in as many toolboxes. use what you like. you *could* flatten your benchtop with a #2, but if you had access to a #7 I bet you'd use that.

Re: #7 vs #8 jointer plane

#10

Re: #7 vs #8 jointer plane

Patrick Gibbons

I take a different bent on this. When I buy lumber, it costs me about .25 cents a board foot extra to have the wood surfaced three sides. A little more and it's sanded too. This is too inexpensive to justify owning a machine planer. I do buy some lumber in the rough and do need to flatten panels, etc. A 6 will usually do the job on already flat boards. A 6 also worked just fine on my bench top (8' x 32"). My 7 is used mostly on edges. A three or four foot panel can be done with a jack or even a 4 1/2. Lighter is better, as far as my middle-aged, couch potato muscles are concerned. There are times when the 7 is the only plane that will work. Most of the time, something smaller will do just fine. Starting with surfaced lumber precludes needing long, heavy planes as much as in the past.

Re: #7 vs #8 jointer plane

#11

Re: #7 vs #8 jointer plane

Tom

"tom- you're overanalizing this."

No, I am correctly analysing. I really wish people got this point about planes, because once on thinks about them correctly, their use is more rational, and easier. I have proved incapable of explaining it well in writing over decades of trying. It really needs video. David Charlesworth did a great job of describing stop cuts in one of his tapes, and if you understand that process you understand what the relationship of blade projection and sole length gets you.

If you are more an action type, get two equal straight board edges, and two planes, one plane short and the other long. Set both to take the same reasonable shaving. Use stop cuts until you have both edges planed to the point where neither plane can take a cut, except at the ends. You will notice the jointer cut less curvature into the board. That is all it does differently than any other plane. They are longitudinal hollows. Just as one might have a set of hollows of different radii, one has a set of planes that introduce different longitudinal curvature. They do have other features, like degree of blade camber, blade width, but those are incidental.

"the #8 is more accurate because of length"

Accuracy is not an inherent function of length. Say a jointer holds curvature to 1 thou over 22 inches, and a jack at 1 thou over 14 inches. One is a better tolerance in a certain sense, but accuracy is properly a mater of how close to that setting a plane holds. You would have to develop a standard, but there is no real reason why a shorter plane would be less accurate. It will even hold the same tolerance, but at the "cost" of taking a finer shaving. However, jointers were not designed to take finer shavings, so they will not necessarily have a gear you can shift down into to deliver a tighter tolerance. I have one that does, but it is 18 inches, and hard to hold the tolerance even at that length. It is normally considered easier to hold tolerances over shorter distances/lengths. There are some boutique uses for all this stuff, but the main use with a jointer is jointing edges, and that can successfully be done with normal performance, nothing crazy refined.

" and more stabl because of weight."

The lack of stability in heavy metal planes, or their need for weight to cut, is largely a mater of poor design. I have wood planes that weight a 1/4 what metal ones do, and have low CGs, or better cutting geometry than metal planes. In any case one should get good results with anything, with practice.

" it's also more work to use, more expensive to buy and doesn't fit in as many toolboxes. use what you like. you *could* flatten your benchtop with a #2, but if you had access to a #7 I bet you'd use that. "

I have 4 or 5 jointers from 18 inches to 30ish. I would not choose them for flattening a table. They would not be any better at that than any other plane, and they are very heavy. About 35 years ago I got a commission to make a round table, and one couldn't just walk along the edge leaning out a bit towards the middle to take a cut, on had to reach right to the center and beyond, then lift the 7 pound 7 ounce weight of the Record jointer all the way back. I was early 20s at the time, but I still got complaints from my back.

Re: #7 vs #8 jointer plane

#12

The weight has...

david weaver

..nothing to do with poor design. A jointer plane that weighs less than 5 pounds is a pooch to use in a heavy cut while pushing the plane.

For giggles I weighed all of my planes last week and was surprised to find that the vintage jointers (as in the ones people used to make a living) were approximately the same weight as the metal jointers that stanley made. My jointers weighed around 8 pounds - all of them.

This isn't something that occurs by chance.

A plane that is pulled can weigh less, but it's not by superior design that such a thing is allowed.

Re: #7 vs #8 jointer plane

#13

Re: #7 vs #8 jointer plane

Tom

"Originally in the wooden plane world, the really long ones were jointers for edges. Especially edge glueing needs precise straight edges."

"Precise" what does that mean, you have already noted straight. And how is that precision derived from the fact the sole is longer?

Jointers can't make edges straight, any more than gouges automatically carve dogs. But jointers can establish a repeatable degree of curvature which for a given shaving is less than that of a shorter plane. I would say they do that precisely. It is also the only thing they do that other planes do not do. I am not really sure why that is so hard to grasp.

For better or worse it is also true that some use sprung joints. This is exactly what comes off a jointer plane used in it's workmanship of certainty mode. Just a fact.

If you want a straight edge you either have to fiddle away at it, or you can back out the curvature, which is pretty easy to do, but so called workmanship of risk. The only thing it does as a certainty, for having a longer sole is establish a longer arc for a given shaving.

One can talk about this all one wants, but it only takes a moment in the shop to see it for oneself.

What I find interesting about try planes is that they seem no longer to be in broad use. This is odd when one considers that most boards have more planing to do on the faces than the edges, even after they come off a jointer and/or planer. Jointers remain popular, even though their most common use is to joint edges that have already gone through a planer or jointer. In those cases the much vaunted spanning the bumps type "precision" is irrelevant, but the jointer remains the tool in use.

Re: #7 vs #8 jointer plane

#14

Re: #7 vs #8 jointer plane

david weaver

try planes are probably not in use for two reasons

* few people are roughing wood by hand and using an interim step. They're either jointing an edge, removing planer chatter, or knocking off a high corner before placing something on a power jointer

* The use of most of the try planes out there requires understanding of a double iron. I had bought one a while ago and figured that I'd set it aside until I could figure out how to use it without tearing out the surfaces of panels

* Most people learn to dimension wood from a video, and check everything with precision tools when they do. I doubt they have an understanding that a properly planed board from a try plane is ready for a smoother and there will be no visual detriment.

There has been, at least as long as I've been woodworking, a serious lack of wanting to do anything that doesn't turn out great on the first try, aside possibly from dovetails.

If something doesn't work right, don't set it aside, get rid of it and go to lie nielsen and find one of the absurd gadgetry fixes they are now offering (the high angle frogs, the devices to sharpen drawknives, etc). And then go back to the power tools.

Re: #7 vs #8 jointer plane

#15

Re: #7 vs #8 jointer plane

bridger berdel

I made some desks recently. the tops were too wide for any of my machines to flatten, so I did it with planes. I was planing for several days to get them all flat. the usual, winding sticks and straightedges, taking progressively finer shavings. scrub with a cambered 5, follow with a long plane, finish with a smoother. I have a 6, a 7 and an 8, and I put them all into play. the 8 is a beast, too much for leaning out into the middle of a large panel. I ended up using mostly the 6 and 7.