New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Shinto rasp info wanted

Posts

Shinto rasp info wanted

#1

Shinto rasp info wanted

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I am interested to hear from those with experience using a Shinto rasp, particularly along with Auriou rasps. The Shinto is the one made of saw blades.



Specifically, is it capable of wasting wood across the grain really fast? I am considering it for my chair build, for the initial, rough removal in shaping the thick, hard Jarrah backrest - to bring it down in thickness, essentially as an alternative to a bandsaw (I am trying to stay with handtools here).

I have Auriou rasps (the coarsest is a 10 grain) - so I am curious how this compares and where it fits in the coarseness ratings?

I do plan on using spokeshaves for shaping. These are, however, not for the coarse work first needed. The other option is a drawknife - but I am unsure how well I can control the curving cuts needed in the Jarrah (I have just one drawknife, with a flat blade). Consequently I am just exploring other options. The Shinto came to mind. It looks to have potential - something to roughly shape the outline before bringing spokeshaves in. I just do not know if it is fast, or no faster than my Auriou 10 grain.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Shinto rasp info wanted

#2

Wasting wood

Paul in NJ

Derek,

Sorry, I have no experience with that Shinto rasp but have a couple of possibilities for wasting wood.

1. Saw a series of cross-cuts and break the wood in between with a mallet and chisel.

2. Use a large deep gouge.

3. Use a bowl or scupltors adze.

4. Turning (bow) saw with a coarse blade.

regards,

Paul Dzioba

Re: Shinto rasp info wanted

#3

Re: Shinto rasp info wanted

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

As I commented over on another forum, my problem with the Shinto rasp was that it's a flat rasp only. I've never found flat rasps worthwhile; planes and spokeshaves are faster for me on flat surfaces.

Re: Shinto rasp info wanted

#4

Re: Shinto rasp info wanted

Robin Corell in Atascadero,CA

I have a Shinto and it's nearly worn out from use. They work best on soft material. For hardwood a rasp works much faster and leaves a smoother surface.

Robin

Re: Shinto rasp info wanted

#5

Re: Shinto rasp info wanted

Patrick Gibbons

I've never worked with jarrah and understand that my suggestion may not be helpful. I wouldn't sell the drawknife short. I'm not the most talented woodworker and still achieve very good results with this tool. If I pay attention to the grain, take slicing cuts, keep my blade sharp and mind what I want to remove then I can shape a piece faster than with any other method. I can then refine with rasps or smooth with a shave.

Re: Shinto rasp info wanted

#6

Re: Shinto rasp info wanted

Tom

I haven't used it either, but I have used hack saw blades as rasps, and even they are pretty aggressive. They are held at an angle to the work, and are often bent. More a fairing thing, but they do cut, so in the right situation, I have always thought the Shinto would be aggressive.

If there is anything to bandsaw, I would use a bowsaw. Then If I can't get at it with chairmaking tools, I tend to have to fall back on surforms, and microplane rasps.

Re: Shinto rasp info wanted

#7

Like it, though on poplar

Simon St.Laurent - Dryden, NY

I've been playing with various rasps, but haven't yet reached (or bought) the Auriou.

I like that switching from coarse to (sort of) fine on the Shinto is just flipping the tool over. So far it's been great on poplar (and a little bit on pine and maple). The main danger is that my daughter really likes using it, and is sometimes tempted to demolish the wrong wood.

So far I've been happier with the Shinto than with recent-vintage Nicholson rasps, though I have some older rasps that seem to produce a better finish and move less jerkily.

The Microplane has also done nicely for these experiments, leaving a smoother finish though it doesn't feel as responsive in my hand as the others.

You likely have harder wood, so I'm guessing the only real answer is to try it.

Re: Shinto rasp info wanted

#8

Re: Wasting wood

alohafromberkeley

Hi Derek, my first post here...so be gentle on me. I have the side handled Shinto and it's an amazing tool. Cuts fast and very easy to control. Don't push too hard -like all good tools, let it do the work. It has 2 sides- coarse and fine.I find it easier to use the rasp than to hand plane a lot of the wood I work for guitar finger boards (cocobolo, bloodwood and rosewood(s)) I use it for initial work on rough blanks and I follow it with the Dragon rasp or the Iwasaki files for smoothing. Never used an Auriou- out of my league moneywise. Give the Shinto a chance- you may find yourself reaching for it more and more as time goes on. It's worth more than the cost of the tool......Wes

Re: Shinto rasp info wanted

#9

Re: Shinto rasp info wanted *LINK*

charlie belden

Consider MicroPlane.

Because the micro plane "rasp" can be reversed in the snap in handle, you can cut on the pull stroke OR the push stroke by merely popping out the replaceable "rasp" part. This lets you keep the handle in your dominant hand for power and the other hand on the thumb sized tip for control of direction and downward pressure to depth of cut With tradition rasps, when you want to cut on a pull stroke you have to hold the toothed end of the tool. Pulling on something when its teeth are biting into your fingers is a bit "uncomfortable". Pressing a bare finger or two or a thumb down onto teeth doesn't feel that good either.

Curved and V microplane rasps can be snapped into the handle as well so you can have three rasps but only need one snap in handle. Pretty neat system MicroPlane has put together and they work well as well.


MicroPlane woodworking versions page

Re: Shinto rasp info wanted

#10

Re: Shinto rasp info wanted

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks for the information, Charlie.

I have a microplane - bought and used it some years ago before I owned decent rasps. It leaves a nice finish. However it cuts very slowly, and I need something to waste wood fast!

I did test my drawknife on a scrap of this Jarrah. It is an 8" Wilkinson which I spent time sharpening to a razor edge. Well, it is not going to do the job either. The wood is simply too hard to take deep cuts.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Shinto rasp info wanted

#11

Clint Searl

Re: Shinto rasp info wanted

Clint Searl

It demands a bit of finesse, but nothing wastes wood faster than a Lancelot disk on a 4 1/2" angle grinder.

Re: Shinto rasp info wanted

#13

Clint Searl

Re: Shinto rasp info wanted

Clint Searl

Reminds me of a chainsaw joke with the punch line, "What's that noise?" :D