New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

The Chair - The fingers (pt 1)

Posts

The Chair - The fingers (pt 1)

#1

The Chair - The fingers (pt 1)

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I was tempted to wait another week before posting this part of the build. However it is two weeks since my last post and I had begun receiving email asking whether I had given up! Oh to have the time to be in the shop during the week! But I am back in my day job and it will be another week before I again get a chance to do anything, so here is the update - about 3 hours worth over this weekend past.

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Furniture/TheChairTheFingers%28part1%29.html

Since there is time, any feedback is welcomed, particularly with regard methods of transferring finger outlines.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The Chair - The fingers (pt 1)

#2

Ellis Walentine

Looking good, Derek

Ellis Walentine

As for transferring precise layout information, I've never used your tape method so I don't know how it works. Do you leave the blue tape there while sawin? And, if so, do you saw through it or outside it?

I used to cut tiny, precise pieces out of ivory with a fretsaw, and the layout method I used involved polishing the ivory surface, then painting it with sumi ink, and then scratching the pattern through the ink with a very sharp awl or pointed diamond engraving pen. For following straight lines, you could use a knife for an even finer line than a pointed tool. This left a very visible and durable line to follow when sawing. On she-oak maybe you could put a light coat of gesso on the surface and knife through it to the wood. Just speculating; never tried it.

What would concern me more, though, would be any imperfections in the right angles that you so carefully crafted between the faces and the cheeks of those fingers. You'd be using the back of your crest rail to mark out the fronts of your arms. I wonder how perfect that is likely to be, regardless of how well you've measured those right angles. Whenever I needed something to fit within another piece perfectly, I made a test piece from metal or hardboard depending on the tolerances I was after, and used it to gauge the negative shape -- in this case, the back rest fingers. The gauge piece will tell you where and by how much the fingers vary from perfect compliance with the shape of the gauge, so you can further tune up the fingers, and then use the gauge itself to do the layout. On thick work like this, though, you'd still have to verify the perpendicularity of the cheeks; the gauge would only tell you if the shape was uniform.

Once you've committed to a method and cut your arm pieces, you can still correct slight problems by using some kind of layout blue and sneaking up on a perfect fit, as you would when scraping babbits or truing a plane sole, for instance. You'd need to come up with something that could be thoroughly removed so it doesn't interfere with the glue line. The final scraping would have to be done with an eye to the locations of your leg tenons as well, of course. You probably don't have a lot of room to err there either. (Did I just say that? Getting late. :)

Ellis

Re: The Chair - The fingers (pt 1)

#3

Re: Looking good, Derek

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

What would concern me more, though, would be any imperfections in the right angles that you so carefully crafted between the faces and the cheeks of those fingers. You'd be using the back of your crest rail to mark out the fronts of your arms. I wonder how perfect that is likely to be, regardless of how well you've measured those right angles. Whenever I needed something to fit within another piece perfectly, I made a test piece from metal or hardboard depending on the tolerances I was after, and used it to gauge the negative shape -- in this case, the back rest fingers. The gauge piece will tell you where and by how much the fingers vary from perfect compliance with the shape of the gauge, so you can further tune up the fingers, and then use the gauge itself to do the layout. On thick work like this, though, you'd still have to verify the perpendicularity of the cheeks; the gauge would only tell you if the shape was uniform.

Hi Ellis

A short while after I had flattened the face at the end of the arm (where the fingers would be sawn) I realised that I had focussed the wrong side. Planing that side meant that I could not match the face as I should have planned to do. It was then too late to plane the other side as the wood remaining would then be too narrow for the dimensions. As a result I had to ensure that the rear side of the backrest (where the finger joint would be sawn) had to be perfectly parallel to transfer the markings. The die was cast and I had no choice but to continue down this path.

Reflecting on this I now realise that it probably makes no difference whether the markings are transferred from the face or the back: they have to be perfectly square otherwise gaps will show once the carving is done. The real joint lies in the centre, not at the outside. It has to be straight and square all the way through.

I think the idea of a test piece is helpful. A tight fit on one side must be a tight fit at the other side when the piece is flipped over.

The blue tape method aids accuracy a great deal as it is so easy to see lines. For this the tape needs to be cut with a blade, not an awl. I shall redo the marking with fresh tape as I have had an idea what to use for a knife. A long, one-sides blade is needed, and ideally two blades to cut from opposing directions. It has occurred to me to try the blades on the Veritas skew block planes. We'll see if this works. Once the marking is done, the blue tape should offer up an exact copy of the waste. It is left on the workpiece and one saws against the edge of the tape.

Thanks for giving me the push to do the fingers with rounds (and not points). It has been an interesting puzzle .... and that is where all the fun lies!

Regards from Perth

Derek