New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Buying a new rip panel saw

Posts

Buying a new rip panel saw

#1

Buying a new rip panel saw

Simon St.Laurent - Dryden, NY

The world seems full of crosscut saws in every price range, but saws actually filed for rip seem to be available in two price ranges: garage sale and flea market specials under $10, and new saws for at least $100, going to about $240. The 'retuned' used saws I've seen are sometimes in the middle (often eBay), but also tend to be in the higher range if the seller is trustworthy.

I have two garage sale specials ($2 each) that kind of barely cut. One is covered in varnish, while the other, a Disston that's seen happier days, has an weird irregular tooth patten that makes me wonder what happened.

I will eventually joint and start over on the Disston, and will look more closely the next time I'm at a show with tools I can touch, but I'm wondering if there's an easier path to getting a quality rip saw. (In particular, if there's an easier path I can recommend to people who want to rip wood more than sharpen metal.)

Thanks!

Re: Buying a new rip panel saw

#2

Re: Buying a new rip panel saw

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

No matter which saw you buy, or how much you pay for it, sooner or later, you will need to sharpen it. You may as well start practicing as soon as possible. As long as your flea market special doesn't have a lot of pitting, or a bent saw plate, or impulse hardened teeth, that would be a good place to start. The grunge can be easily cleaned off the saw plate and handle. No sense practicing either sawing or sharpening on an expensive saw. Save your money for that one until you can really appreciate what it will do for you.

Re: Buying a new rip panel saw

#3

Re: Buying a new rip panel saw

Ron in Sterling, CT

I would watch the flea markets for a GOOD vintage rip saw (i.e. Disston, Atkins, etc) which has a plate that is straight, and not pitted. These are usually available for $5 to $20. I would then clean it up and send it out to one of the guys for hand sharpening. This can usually be done for $30 to $40, depending on condition. So, for $50, or so you have an excellent rip saw.

Ron

Re: Buying a new rip panel saw

#4

Agree

Brian Greene

I absolutely agree. Leave the $2 junk where you found it and look for $10-20 brand name saws in good shape, just needing some love. Send out for filing and setting.

I have two rips, two cross cuts and a back saw in this category and have never regretted it.

Re: Buying a new rip panel saw

#5

Re: Agree

Patrick Gibbons

Rip saws will perform well even with some pitting. It's a judgement call. Your one saw with strange teeth may have been filed that way on purpose. To facilitate starting a cut, some would have the front of the saw with more teeth and less aggressive pitch. I have an old Richardson Bros rip saw that someone over zealously cleaned. The brass is too bright. It is still an excellent saw that I need to sharpen and put to use. Often, a saw like that will sell for less. May not look as good as it should but performs well.

Re: Buying a new rip panel saw

#6

Ellis Walentine

You may be interested in this book

Ellis Walentine

Just today, I received my first shipment of the WoodCentral facsimile edition of Charles Johnson's Saw Dictionary, published in 1909 and generally lost to the ages until 2008, when Dan Donaldson and I unearthed three copies in three states and managed to compile a true facsimile edition. The book is 62 pages long including all the intros and such. It is 5 1/2" x 8 1/2" and perfect bound. Compared to the disintegrated state of the originals, this book is crispy and clean.

I have not yet listed the book in the store, but I should have the pricing and shipping figured out soon. I'll post a notice that it is officially available.

Ellis Walentine, Host


Re: Buying a new rip panel saw

#7

Re: You may be interested in this book

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Heck, Ellis, the price is right there on the cover! :D

Re: Buying a new rip panel saw

#8

Ellis Walentine

Adjusted for inflation ...

Ellis Walentine

... that $1 book in 1909 would be $24.41 in 2009 dollars, or about $25 even today. Maybe that's the price I should be angling for. :)

Ellis

Re: Buying a new rip panel saw

#9

Adjusted for inflation

Patrick Gibbons

At $25 it would still pay for itself in files, saws, labor and quality of work.

Re: Buying a new rip panel saw

#10

Re: Buying a new rip panel saw

Tom

The 300 mm Japanese replaceable blade saws sold with names like zona, are designed for softwood, but I have used them to rip maple, they are a good choice. I buy the blades, and gizmo, and make my own handles,

http://www.fine-tools.com/kataba.htm

A very very good choice when you want cheap blades you can sharpen when they get dull, are the German Bowsaws. These things are really good at ripping, and doing some joinery. I would avoid the ones that are now sold with japanese blades. The idea of adapting a japanese blade to a bowsaw is good, but the execution doesn't work for me. They are just the usual hyper sharp, blades for coarse crosscutting of softwoods. If that is the task, they might be OK.

Ah times have moved on, this source (there are US ones also), has Japanese rip blades, but they still look really aggressive. Get the two heaviest German rip blades, like a 5 point:

http://www.fine-tools.com/gestell.htm

I also have a few Diston saws from the golden age whent he saw handles were fully formed and the blades didn't look like they came off a roll. Very beautiful saws, and in my case quite cheap, some work required. I don't use them all that much because saws you like too much tend to run into staples, or barbed wire. So while I am no tool collector, I respect fine stuff, and just don't run this stuff much.

I don't buy expensive saws. I did go crazy and buy the first expensive dovetail saw that came out and actually worked, I got three Independence saws. And I also bought one 500 dollar Japanese saw. But other than that, I normally buy saw around 30 dollars. I find they work fine, and saw filing isn't my favourite thing.

Re: Buying a new rip panel saw

#11

Re: Buying a new rip panel saw

david weaver

Simon - the short answer that is long on economy and usefulness is to buy saws needing refurbishment but very little of it. That means if you find a full plate disston D8 with teeth that are already sharp and even or that just need a little bit, and that is straight, it's worth your money to give $50 for it if you have to. It'll save you about two hours of clean up, tooth adjustment and sharpening, and probably 5-10 bucks worth of filing.

What are you looking for, a 22 or 24 inch panel saw in rip, like a dainty 7 or 8 point saw that's intended to cut small cabinet pieces, or are you looking for a saw to rip rough lumber, like a 5 point disston d8 thumbhole?

New makers don't make a lot of the latter, but if or forgo your power tools, you're going to want something like that. You will probably end up wanting both, but my preference is to repurpose an inexpensive crosscut saw (which are out there in droves with good teeth) in 8 point that's 26 inches long to do the finer ripping.

The more you refurbish saws, hammer them straight, reshape teeth - the better you get at doing it, but the less you need the saws. It's a real conondrum. Nobody else is really willing to do it for you, though, and the guys that do get prices that make no sense to me since their saws cut no better than yours will if you have a decent hand at filing and have sharpened a dozen or so saws.

Re: Buying a new rip panel saw

#12

Re: You may be interested in this book

john sayles

Ellis,

Color me very interested in the book.

(full disclosure: I may have a "saw problem")