New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Rules for figure and warp?

Posts

Rules for figure and warp?

#1

Rules for figure and warp?

Bruce McCrory

I got some figured maple for guitar bodies that was rejected for various reasons. Right now, I am trying to sort it for a side tables project. Booked pieces are 7" x 21", and not really the best in looks when mated--why they were rejected in the first place. However, some are about 10" to 11" wide, and could be used singly in my design.

The problem is this: 'Everyone' preaches to use pith side for top surface of a table to avoid roof-gutter look when the stuff cups. However, grain figure invariably is best at the bark surface.

So, how do I take advantage of the best attribute of this wood, and avoid one of its worst?

Re: Rules for figure and warp?

#2

Re: Rules for figure and warp?

Bob Lang

Ignore the rules and do what looks good.

Bob Lang

Re: Rules for figure and warp?

#3

Re: Rules for figure and warp?

Lars Parrington

Are there aprons on these tables? If so, the aprons will hold the top flat if adequately attached.

Get the wood as dry as possible before flattening, it will warp in the opposite direction as it regains moisture. The pieces are small enough you could fit them into your oven, if you really want to get them dry. Not convinced that's necessary or even desireable though.

In use, avoid getting the tabletop wet. That can cause compression shrinkage, which would result in the wood cupping up regardless of its grain direction.

Re: Rules for figure and warp?

#4

Re: Rules for figure and warp?

Bruce McCrory

Thanks, Lars. Yes, these will be modifications of the popular Little Shaker Table. Well, almost any "end table" looks like them. The maple is kiln dried. I think I will let the wood sit for a while, rather than chance killing another kitchen oven.

To fit our dimensional needs with the limitations of the wood pieces, the surface will be about 18/17-inches by 22-inches, the maximum I want to try with breadboard ends. I am looking at a picture frame layout scheme (3-inch frame surround) to build up the required dimension. It might end up looking like a whirligig--the main reason for my query.

I liked Lang's suggestion, too. :)

Re: Rules for figure and warp?

#5

Re: Rules for figure and warp?

Sgian Dubh

"The problem is this: 'Everyone' preaches to use pith side for top surface of a table to avoid roof-gutter look when the stuff cups."

I wonder who Everyone may be because I've never heard that 'rule'? I certainly wouldn't advocate it. I suspect it's one of those internet myths that becomes a 'truth' through repetition of someone's inaccurate, but plausible, take on a subject they know too little about.

I'd go along with Bob who suggests you ignore this foolish 'rule' and put together the most attractive grain match. Let the rails hold the top flat through the method chosen to hold the top down to those rails, but also allowing a little for expansion and contraction (2 - 3 mm) of the top across the grain. There are several methods for that, e.g., expansion plates, buttons, pocket screws, etc. Slainte.

Re: Rules for figure and warp?

#6

Re: Rules for figure and warp?

Bob Lang

The one rule I have is not to surround a piece of solid wood on all four sides with a mitered frame, everyone thinks that will look cool, but I think it's doomed to failure.

I also have an issue with breadboard ends as a structural element. I can easily bend a narrow piece of wood by hand, but can't do the same with a wide one. I haven't figured out the magic that allows an easily bent piece of wood to keep a difficult to bend piece straight. But it does look nice if the wood doesn't move too much.

The problem with reading to get information about woodworking is that you can't be sure if the guy who wrote it really knows what he's talking about or is just repeating something he read somewhere. To actually learn (so you're not just some guy repeating what someone else wrote) you need to make stuff and make mistakes. It also helps to look at lots and lots of pieces of furniture and compare what people tell you you should do to what the guys before you actually did.

Bob Lang

Re: Rules for figure and warp?

#7

Re: Rules for figure and warp? *LINK*

Lars Parrington

Sounds like your table will have sturdy aprons, so the solution may be as simple as just securely attaching the top to the aprons. Of course, allowing for shrinkage/expansion of the top as Richard (Sgian) wrote below.

Will you have a drawer in the apron? Then the apron wouldn't be as sturdy.

The breadboard ends are icing on the cake. They would add additional stiffness to the panel and could make attachment of the top to aprons very easy.

I don't understand how you intend to do a picture frame wraparound with the breadboard ends. How would the panel be allowed to shrink/expand? Reminds me of this door posted by Mark awhile back:


http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/handtools.pl/md/read/id/466748/sbj/mitered-bread-board-end/

Re: Rules for figure and warp?

#8

Re: Rules for figure and warp?

Bruce McCrory

Thanks, Richard. A while back, was it Tage, said to swap the grain directions? That's what I learned, anyway. (Not from him--shop class.) The intent is to give both hold-downs and breadboards breathing room.

Re: Rules for figure and warp?

#9

That's it!!

Bruce McCrory

You got it right on the barrel, Lars. Although, with a door like that I would squelch the full mitre to avoid corners getting chewed up over time.

The piece is small enough, and movement mostly in the glued portions, face grain, that the bread boards need account for the highest moisture which in our climate can be rain forest any day of the year.

Re: Rules for figure and warp?

#10

Trapped by board size

Bruce McCrory

I know your concern, Bob. I am not above shaking the boat to get reactions. Bark/Pith up or down was a minor worry. (Although Tage Frid had a cow over contrary comments--no, his thought is buried in a Google copy of FWW.)

The biggest concern is mitering the breadboards. They aren't common to me in that configuration, and only serve to add a couple inches to the table depth. My needed dimensions are larger than the wood available. Breadboard is an imagery description for the M&Ts to attach butt and edge pieces.

The layout of grain/figure is also driving the design requirements. Unless a pattern is created, these little bits of wood will be a mess. Booking pieces from a single board is one thing. Using two or three different boards is quite another.

Re: Rules for figure and warp?

#11

"Attention"

Bruce McCrory

"Reaction" is not correct. Meant attention.

Re: Rules for figure and warp?

#12

Re: That's it!!

Lars Parrington

So the top of your table will be the same design as Mark's door? Will the center boards be held together with T&G (no glue)?

Sounds unconventional, but awesome.

Re: Rules for figure and warp?

#13

Re: That's it!!

Bruce McCrory

Been hunting for more info, and most is negative, which makes sense when looking at tables an army could sit at. But the more I read movement the less worry I have. My table is only about 18 inches total width.

Let's see what comes together.

Re: Rules for figure and warp?

#14

Spittle-bugs on stilts!

Bruce McCrory

I will try to photograph this harlequin in the making... I like an accent, in one place; not a blinking, flashing, neon and strobe and anti-aircraft beam of look-at-me splash. They are simply sofa end-tables.

Images of popcorn figure, which western Big-leaf Maple does well, influenced my wood selection. I came home from the supplier with a bunch of quilt figure maple and, I am afraid. These little tables will be too wild looking! I need to go back and get some normal wood.

I need to get a book-set of crazy flame figure, anyway. At least, that...

The "tablets" came into the living room, I shuffled slabs and tried numerous combinations. Five pieces of quilt-top? One (center) of quilt, and four of flame? Only, the second book of stripe has split wood and finished width will be too narrow. Two sides, stiles in this case, will be multi-directional flame figure, and; all I could do was mate them with quilt, including a brown streak of heartwood. Gross!

Then, the aprons-

I pre-selected long boards, not pairs, in quilt figure. The drawers faces will have super-nova grain explosions, bursting rays surrounding inclusions, which then transition into popcorn clouds. What do you do instead? Hide them on the back? The drawers sides will be normal straight quarter grain. The drawer bottoms? Tiger stripe... Because that is how they warp.

The new style of twisted eye-popping furniture grain must reflect a twisted society impressed by graphic marketing. D++mn you, Garrett; Taylor, and FWW, PWW! Me?

Not my fault! :\