New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Marking Walnut, Wenge, Cocobolo, etc.

Posts

Marking Walnut, Wenge, Cocobolo, etc.

#1

Marking Walnut, Wenge, Cocobolo, etc.

William Duffield

I attended the annual conference on Woodworking in the 18th Century last week in Williamsburg. While there, I learned an old trick for marking dark, resinous woods, such as black walnut, wenge, cocobolo, etc. This is from David Salisbury, Colonial Williamsburg joiner and cabinetmaker. David is the guy on the cover of this book: http://www.amazon.com/Tools-Working-Eighteenth-Century-Decorative-Publications/dp/0879350989/ref=sr_1_3?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1390838416&sr=1-3&keywords=18th+century+woodworking+tools

While I haven't had much problem with walnut using a Pilot P500 gel pen, the darker, "oilier" woods are a problem. I've tried using a drafting lead holder with yellow lead, but the points are too fragile and too difficult to keep sharp.

What works is a soapstone pencil. These are available at welding supply stores, as they also are used for marking steel. Here is a "boutique" source, online, with photos.

http://www.brooklynslate.com/products/soapstone-pencil

These are rectangular, with flat, square and parallel sides, typically 3/16" thick by 3/4" wide and a few inches long. They are sharpened with abrasives (a grinding wheel or sandpaper, for example), in the shape of a single edge, single bevel marking knife.

David was using one for marking double through tenons on the ends of some walnut rails. He had made some setup blocks, which he stacked next to the rails, and laid the soapstone flat on top of the blocks to transfer their thickness to the walnut. The soapstone left fine, highly visible lines.

Re: Marking Walnut, Wenge, Cocobolo, etc.

#2

Re: Marking Walnut, Wenge, Cocobolo, etc.

Peter Evans

Thanks for tip, I have some of these and did not got round to using them, think I picked them up at a flea. Never thought of sharpening them like a knife!

Re: Marking Walnut, Wenge, Cocobolo, etc.

#3

Re: Marking Walnut, Wenge, Cocobolo, etc.

Winton Applegate

Well that's cool. Thanks !

I inherited a pile of those soap stones from my Dad; he was a steam (pipe) fitter.

Be sure to also check out Jim Kingshott's joinery video.

He knifes the lines, rubs the whole area with chalk and what remains are highly visible spider web thin lines.

His way takes more time and effort though.

Finally I have a use for the soap stone.

(they don't mark on the cold rolled steel that I work with. I have to paint blue die like stuff on and then scribe through that to leave silver lines.)

Re: Marking Walnut, Wenge, Cocobolo, etc.

#4

Re: Marking Walnut, Wenge, Cocobolo, etc.

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

For those who have not inherited them, I found some Friday at my locally owned Ace Hardware, at 3 for $1.89 + tax (a lot less than the Pilot P500 pens I usually use). If you want to buy them in bulk from Amazon, they go for as low as about 11¢ each (plus shipping), about the price of a #2 Ticonderoga pencil.

I hope this doesn't degrade into a single vs. double bevel, round vs. flat, bevel angle, and sharpening media argument. ;^)

I'll try to get out to the shop this afternoon, sharpen one up and try it on some lignum vitae stock. However, I have my doubts it will work on jarra. :^)

Re: Marking Walnut, Wenge, Cocobolo, etc.

#5

Be sure to sign up for the Gold Member card.

Winton Applegate

Well I am sure "those who KNOW" are in solidarity with me when I say the one and only TRUE soap stone WAY is :

Flat not round

Single bevel ; 35 and 1/2 degrees exactly

and

Two soap stone sticks one for a left hand bevel and one for a right hand bevel marking styleye.

Those are facts and are almost too obvious to mention.

: )

By the way for Thee True Soap Stone Woodworking Joinery Marking Connoisseur I am will to part with, that is . . .

. . . errrr . . .

trade . . .

. . . for a modest monetary consideration . . .

(financing available, certified checks only please) (shipping extra)

the VINTAGE,

PROPERLY AGED, in a carefully controlled environmental environment. (First in my Dad's shed and then my tool crib.) soap stones.

They come with a certificate of authentication and a guarantee that the temperature of the carefully controlled environment, in which they were aged, never exceed the critical parameters of - 20° F and 110°F. (except for perhaps when they were in his tool box on the back of the company truck that one bitterly cold, record setting night in Greeley, Colorado back in fifty nine)(. . . wait. . . strike that)

Quantities are EXTREMELY limited. Sign up for the Gold Member card for a generous five percent discount.

Re: Marking Walnut, Wenge, Cocobolo, etc.

#6

Re: Somewhere Between El Capitan & El Rio Platte

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

I think I can cut your costs in half! These sticks are double ended. You can put a left bevel on one end and a right bevel on the other. Does this tip make you cringe? Well, do you worry when your grandchild uses the eraser on the end of a sharpened #2 Ticonderoga?

Stay tuned for a scholarly dissertation on how to measure the Rockwell Hardness of your soapstone, including a .xls attachment correlating hardness with bevel angle and with optimum choices for particular timber species.

If my title seems somehow less than relevant, El Capitan is solid granite, while the Platte River is "too thin to plow, to thick to drink." Soapstone is somewhere in between.

Re: Marking Walnut, Wenge, Cocobolo, etc.

#7

Re: Marking Walnut, Wenge, Cocobolo, etc.

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

Photos will come, but my computer system is currently mostly disassembled while we are working on the "data center" (my kitchen) including new cableways, and this iPad doesn't do a lot of things very well, including uploading pictures. I am mostly pleased with the results I obtained on lignum vitae, wenge, morado, satine, morado, and others, but less so with the marks on Brazilian rosewood. I put an edge on the soapstone at my slow speed grinder, but the bevel angle (eyeballed at around 30 or 35°) was too small to hold up well, and it immediately started to break down and leave fat lines. I suspect the soapstone should also work to accentuate knife marks, like chalk, and shoud wear better than chalk in that mode. When I use chalk for marking orientation in joinery, I have to be very careful to renew my chalk marks before I completely rub them out.