Re: A couple comments
Tom in Toronto
"Second, I would try to preserve the rounded points on the finger joints (no rhyme intended), primarily to preserve the look of the original. There are a few things that I regard as inalterable, one of which is a design detail in a reproduction of a classic piece. You may have the best intentions and the most well-rationalized reasons for taking liberties with it, but it isn't your design. An informed viewer will see -- consciously or unconsciously -- that there's something different about this joint with the pointy fingers, and the overall effect will be diminished. Sorry, that's my feeling on this matter."
Having argued both sides of this question already, I think I came out on the side of sticking with the original, in part because it would be fun to make a rounded float...
On the repro thing, the logic dictates as you say, I suppose. Against that are a few things. 1) One is the idea that Derek is making a strong statement about this thing being made by hand, which at least to this audience is a major theme he has, and from a certain perspective this is the logical joint to make that statement. of course like a bad tattoo he will have that satisfaction only for a while, and have to live with the rest of it for ever 2) There is always the possibility they got it wrong. From what I can see there are several structural flaws in their approach. You would be a better judge than I, but is it really the case that people always repeat signature flaws? I thought a lot of repro work often corrects the master. So at some level it might depend on whether one thinks they saw any joint at this point, and the joint they chose as a sginature (krenove exposed dovetails), or something that they would have hiden had they been able. There are construction and aesthetic shortcuts in this piece that are like a 2x4 across the bridge of the nose. 3)
"Making those rounded sockets should be pretty easy, without resorting to drilling. You can saw down to the diameter of the 3/16" round and take out the rest with a chainsaw file."
I have might doubts in both directions. For this joint to come off, and be strong, is has to be melted together. That is less easy, particularly given the difficulty of the layout. The rounded ends aren't going anywhere, and if there is anything about the shape or length that is the least off it will be very noticeable. On the other hand, the points are also a problem, or might be, as they can penetrate even split each other, for much the same kind of reason. Because of the slope, there is a multiplier effect whereby a small eror around a pencil line is a much bigger depth error.
Anyway, I imagine at the rate he works, Derek already has made whichever cuts.