New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

The Chair - Arms and Backrest begun.

Posts

The Chair - Arms and Backrest begun.

#1

The Chair - Arms and Backrest begun.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Here is the work completed today ..

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/Furniture/TheChairInitialStepsArmsBackrest.html

I do have a question for all. Please have a look at the area where the finger joints will be. I am interested in your opinion in regard to the run out here - will it be strong enough (the finger joint will use epoxy)? Photos are near the end.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The Chair - Arms and Backrest begun.

#2

Re: The Chair - Arms and Backrest begun.

Robin Corell in Atascadero,CA

I think the Finger joints are the only ugly aspect of the design of the chair. I would seriously consider Some variation of a stepped scarf joint.

Robin

Re: The Chair - Arms and Backrest begun.

#3

Soft finger joint is part of design

Bruce McCrory

Derek said:

"Added to the complexity of reproducing the shape is the finger join between the arms and the backrest. This has been cut with a Shaper. The one modification I shall be making is to saw points to the joint where it is rounded."

The arm/back joint is a strong visual element of the wood back design--leather seat version. Changing it from fingers to Japanese saw teeth will be a jarring new feature unsympathetic to the native curves of the chair. But that is your choice, and understandable when facing additional complexity of cutting curves. The string in the paper design version probably hides them anyway. The back is a gnarly looking hunk of wood.

Hopefully, you and neighbors have relief from the heat; or soon!

Re: The Chair - Arms and Backrest begun.

#4

Re: The Chair - Arms and Backrest begun.

Tom in Toronto

Well, as far as the epoxy is concerned I don't think that is going to help much, Epoxy is great glue but it's main magic in this app is to fill gaps. So within reason, if you goof the joint it will make up for gaps, it can fill a 6mm gap, but if the fiber is going in the wrong direction or missing, it isn't going to help there.

You do seem to have seriously bad runout. In the arms your run-out is in all the wrong places compared to the sample chair. The back piece is harder to read in your sample. But one picture shows only a few cathedrals on one side of the back rest, so it looks like their grain runs pretty well around the piece , which is quite a trick.

Your grain orientation will weaken the chair, my guess is mostly in the resting one's hands on the rear rail and leaning forward (thereby pressing down) mode. It should be pretty strong in the leaning back mode, but then it also depends on racking, which is hard to see without having the chair in front of one.

Additionally for a lessor soul than you the shaping on the back could be made a little more complicated due to grain reversals. And the back of the joint will probably have more of an end grain colour to it.

Re: The Chair - Arms and Backrest begun.

#5

Re: Crack-a-shima

Tom in Toronto

What about this crack:


I love the two little screws, yeah, that should do it.

Re: The Chair - Arms and Backrest begun.

#6

Adam of Oakland

Re: The Chair - Arms and Backrest begun.

Adam of Oakland

Hi Mr. Cohen - I couldn't predict whether the grain direction would lose any strength here. it's a complex wood. I WOULD probably hedge on the matter, even if it looked a "sure bet" with the stock you have on hand.

I'd make the piece and attach it to the already nicely constructed base of your project. but attach it in a way that makes the back replaceable should it fail.

not sure that helps. solid work so far!

-adam of oakland

Re: The Chair - Arms and Backrest begun.

#7

Query

Andrew F in Australia

Gidday Derek.

Had a quick look at the issue and can't quite get the question with apologies. Are you asking if the strength of the end grain will be sufficient?

Just a couple of dot points I noted from looking at the pictures.

Epoxy needs a minimum glue line thickness of 0.5mm for the strongest bond. It may not be the best choice for the finger joint with minimal gap. The epoxy would be an ideal choice for that felling shake (?) or gum vein which would solve your concerns on that strength issue. Nothing wrong with using epoxy on the finger joint however, it'll still set well.

Another poster pointed out that the finger joint is the ugly part off the design but from what I'm hearing you're trying to make a replica copy of the chair so I'd leave it there. To improve look if you really wanted to, I'd consider running the joint vertically instead of horizontally but you may not have timber to do this. Rather than redesign the first one, I'd be tempted to leave it as per original so you can see if there's another reason for the top rail being designed in this manner.

Trust this makes sense. Typing it up in tiny font on a mobile phone so I think I've picked up all the autocorrect mistakes.

Re: The Chair - Arms and Backrest begun.

#8

Re: Query

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks Andrew.

You have confirmed a thought I had about the use of epoxy here. I am hoping that the fit will be tight, and that means that epoxy is not really indicated. I think that I shall use hide glue in this instance. Any thoughts about that?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The Chair - Arms and Backrest begun.

#9

Hide Glue

Andrew F in Australia

Hi Derek,

Depends on the joinery - it'd work fine, but it's a joint that sees flexing and hide glue doesn't have much flex.

I'd be leaning towards either a crosslinked PVA or taking a shaving out of the internal of the glue joint after you've formed it and use epoxy.

Cheers,

AF

Re: The Chair - Arms and Backrest begun.

#10

Re: Hide Glue

Tom in Toronto

Well one question one might ask is how much of epoxy's full strength does one need, it runs way north of what you will need in this situation. A bigger problem with epoxy, given it's 100% solids deal, is can you get it all out of the glueline, or at least tight enough. Sometimes one has problems only because it hasn't been given the time to move. I doubt that will be a problem in this joint since there is a lot of endgrain in this joint, ant it will allow the epoxy to soak in, for a tight fit. On the other hand, if the dry fit is melted together, you can use any glue you want to. Assuming you can actually get clamping pressure on it. With epoxy you don't need any clamping pressure, but you need some just to make it tight.

Re: The Chair - Arms and Backrest begun.

#11

Re: Query

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Derek,

Wonderful work so far!

Couple of things about hide (that I like for this application). It's wonderfully transparent to finish, and will not darken the join line. It tends to pull pieces together as it dries. Stuff looks 'growed together'.

I"m not following exactly how you will do the glue-up, as I understand you will join first, then shape. However, if practicable (and I understand it may not be), I would suggest using a high gram weight hot hide, stick the two mating parts right into the glue, and then stick them together. Practice dry first, til you're comfortable. Hold the parts in place for a few minutes, or get a clamp on if you can. That hot glue will pull that join together to the max. Many other options of course, but for your consideration....

Great work!

Wiley