New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Whoops....

Posts

Whoops....

#1

Jack Guzman from Maine

Whoops....

Jack Guzman from Maine

I've been following the plans pretty closely while building this high chair. I wasn't really happy with the layout for the arm. It called for gluing up three pieces into the arm curve shown. The problem is that because of the curve I was stuck with grain runout. I figured that this was the way the original was built so it must have worked and I will go along with it.

This morning I finished shaping the spindles and started to dry fit everything to see how well it would go together. I got all the spindles started and was gently tapping the arm down going back and forth along it. I got the short spindles started and tried to bring the arm to the arm post by flexing the spindles.Just as I got the tip of the post into the arm it snapped as you can see.

I am going to build a new arm. This time I will use green oak and steam bend it to get the grain in the desired curve before shaping the arm.

Now I wonder if the original actually was cut from unbent stock as the plan showed or if it was wrongly drawn that way by the plan creator.

Nevertheless from this point on I'm using common sense. ---Jack


Re: Whoops....

#2

Piecing

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Some have three pieces on the bottom layer and one piece on the top layer of the arm. The top piece overlaps both bottom joints. As you discovered, you don't want short grain on the arm. This style of arm is awfully heavy for that much one piece steam bend.

Re: Whoops....

#3

Re: Whoops....

Jim in N. Va

When you laid out the pattern on your stock, couldn't you have put the short grain in the back where it would have been reinforced by the top piece? Then, you would have the grain running with the arms, not across.

Re: Whoops....

#4

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Whoops....

Jack Guzman from Maine

This was my second piece. The first one had the grain like you say but the short grain blew out when drill bit went through it. When I redid it I decided to try the grain in a new direction.

Re: Whoops....

#5

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Piecing

Jack Guzman from Maine

I thought of that. What I may do is bend three pieces and make the same style join,just have the grain following the curve.Two on the bottom and one on top. That should make all the difference.

If I tried to make it out of one piece I would have to make it a narrower arm. I don't think I could get wood that width to bend that much.

Did I mention that I love this stuff?---Jack

Re: Whoops....

#6

Re: Piecing

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Here is another method, middle piece full height, lap joints with the arms, locked with spindles.


img

Re: Whoops....

#7

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Piecing

Jack Guzman from Maine

That might work without bending. I'll look into it.---Jack

Re: Whoops....

#8

Re: Whoops....

Mike from Suffolk VA

Jack,

I have made several of these chairs from Carlyle Lynch's plans and have had the same problem that you have had. One of mine broke when I dropped it on the floor. Bending from one piece should not be impossible. I believe I saw on one the episodes of the Woodwright’s Shop Curtis Buchanan bending a one piece arm similar to the one on your chair. You may be able to go to the Woodwright’s Shop web page and view the episode on line. You also do it in two pieces bending the lower portion so the grain would be continuous. After I recover from a knee replacement in May, I may try the one piece arm.

Wish you the best in your endeavors, and your chair looks great.

Mike formerly from Suffolk now in Zuni

PS I just checked at WindsorChairResoures.com and the list the videos that I mentioned above and they are from season 2006-2007, Windsor High Chair with Curtis Buchanan, Parts 1 and 2. Happy viewing.

Re: Whoops....

#9

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Whoops....

Jack Guzman from Maine

Nice video. Thanks for that. I learned alot about chair building from watching Curtis Buchanan.It appears that it can be done. The arm on the Lynch chair is shorter and more of a bend but I suspect the shape was a result of the mode of building it. I am going to try another glue-up first. I found some 6/4 cherry that would work for a center and some 3/4 cherry that has some useful knots in it that I can get strong short ends out of . I roughed it out today and will attempt to build a new arm tomorrow. I'm basically following the three piece method that Warren showed a picture of.---Jack

Re: Whoops....

#10

Re: Whoops....

Tom in Toronto

If you visualize a straight line through the exposed part of the arm, it would only start to get bad short grain a few inches past the doubler. Seems that is why the doubler is there since there would seem to be little other reason, and it starts at exactly the right point.

Re: Whoops....

#11

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Whoops....

Jack Guzman from Maine

Tom, You are right. Except for one thing,the arm has a tight curve and near the end it curves back so I couldn't get a piece of straight grained wood to lay out in a way that didn't expose some short grain. I solved that by making the new piece out of a piece of cherry with some knots in it. I followed the curve around the knot for both arm pieces. Also the original plan calls for butt jointing in the center which places a spindle right through the joint. I don't like that arrangement.I'm going to lay it out with a center piece at full thickness and make the arm ends join with the center at about 1/3 of the way through the center piece using half laps. I'm taking a break from that project for a few days but I'll post results when I complete it.---Jack

Re: Whoops....

#12

Re: Whoops....

Tom in Toronto

Good luck Jack! Both you and Derek have these projects with a puzzle key, the chair. Makes it tough for armchair pontificators.

Re: Whoops....

#13

Jack Guzman from Maine

Thank you