New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Cup or twist first?

Posts

Cup or twist first?

#1

Cup or twist first?

Steve Corpstein

If I want to flatten a piece of Walnut with hand plane only, should I be taking the cup or the twist out of my reference face first? Also, would a jack or #6 be best if the board is only 24" x 10" in dimension?

Re: Cup or twist first?

#2

Re: Cup or twist first?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Steve,

Couple of thoughts. First, satisfy yourself that this board will have enough thickness left after you're done flattening to serve the purpose you have in mind. If not, you're better repurposing the board and doing nothing til it is resized for the repurpose.

To answer your question. If the board has twist, then two of the diagonal corners will be high, and two will be low. Get the board secured, shimming if need be, and knock down the high corners. The best plane for this is one with some camber to the iron--plane length doesn't matter much here. You want to start with the plane most suited for roughing, then go to the longer, flatter-ironed plane once you get the obvious high spots knocked down.

Now inspect the board and go after the next high area. You can control this with any long straight edge--a level is useful, or your number 6 tilted up on edge. The main thing is not to take any meat from a low place, cause every time you do that, you establish a new datum to be planed down to. You want to keep in mind a mental image of the whole board--kind of a topo map of the board--and arrange for each transect to run along ridge lines, or hit multiple high spots, and miss low spots including low edges.

You get to a point midway in the work with the obvious high places knocked down, where the plane, the no. 6 now, is making a shaving pattern which tells you what is high and what is low. The plane itself is telling you the topo map. Set up a pattern which moves across the board regularly--whether lengthwise or diagonally giving way to lengthwise--but don't stay in one place or start obsessing about any one spot because that will surely result in a low place.

Hope this helps.

Wiley

Re: Cup or twist first?

#3

Re: Cup or twist first?

William Duffield

First, ask yourself if you need that particular board in that width and length, or do you have other alternatives. If you need it, then Wiley's advise works (unless getting it flat also means the thickness goes to zero somewhere. Otherwise, you have to decide what is the most economical way to break it up into smaller pieces that can be flattened and still have enough thickness to be useful. In general, boards with twist (or bow) can to be crosscut into shorter stock before removing the twist to end up with sufficiently thick pieces. OTOH, boards with cup can usually be salvaged by ripping them narrower. If the figure of the cupped board allows ripping, jointing and regluing without obvious figure mismatches, you can salvage a wide panel from a board that would otherwise end up too thin.

Re: Cup or twist first?

#4

Re: Cup or twist first?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The reason why we work on the twist first is that taking away the high corners to get the board out of wind will also reduce the cupping appreciably. Working on the cupping first will not help with the winding.

Even though all four corners may appear high when we just look at the cupping, it is best to take greater amounts off those corners which contribute to the winding.

Re: Cup or twist first?

#5

Re: Cup or twist first?

Tom

On the plane bit, use the lightest, and most powerfully cutting plane you have. Assuming there is some material to remove, it is about the rate of removal not features in the plane that only mater when you are down to the thou.