On glues.
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
An experienced professional furniture maker in Perth recently shared this information with me ..
"for whatever reason (age, biological breakdown, acidic attack from sap in the Jarrah timber) hide glue in Jarrah chair joints always seem to go brittle and crumble...and the joints come loose. It was for this reason that mechanically engineered sound joints are handy. Epoxy seems inert to acidic attack, from the sap in the wood. It also seems to form a bond stronger than the parent material surrounding it. Jarrah pretty much only occurs naturally between Yanchep National Park - down to Albany way east about as far as Narrogin (12 odd km's east of there out the Harrismith road) and it disappears where the Wandoo starts. Jarrah trees are a rather unique eucalypt - in that they thrive despite the poor soils and rainfall - they are highly adapted to their environment compared to a lot of other forests and forest species around the world. A lot of other species wouldn't do at all well in the conditions that Jarrah seems to thrive (including frequent fires). One of the unique conditions is that these soils tend to be deep leached gutless grey sandy soils, once under the sea... (think white beach sands). One major characteristic is that they are on the acidic side of the neutral Ph scale. As a result the sap in the tree is slightly acidic. When you season the timber and remove the free moisture (sap) as well as the inter-cellular moisture and intra - cellular moisture, down to EMC (Equilibrium Moisture Content) ~ 12% for Swan Coastal plain - the remaining 12% moisture is the same acidity as the soil in which the tree was grown. The hide glues seem to go brittle and crumble. Likewise my experience with U/F 62 (Urea Formaldehyde) My results from epoxy resin, which is seemingly inert to weak acid attack that Jarrah sap represents - seems to produce joints where the glue is stronger than the parent material surrounding it. Failures seem invariably to be of the timber surrounding the joint rather than the joint and glue itself."
After trialling several glues over the years, (PVA, Urea Formaldehyde, & epoxy) we ended up settling on the epoxy.
These soils are generally the Darling Scarp granits and also the bauxite gravels - as well as much of the swan coastal plain, etc.
Thats 12% acidic sap does over time react with various glues in various ways.
The choice of glue has been on my mind for some time, although there is quite a way to go before I get to use this. It sounds like epoxy is the way to go as (1) it is less likely to break down, and (2) it has some flex, and this is needed in a leg join.
My only concern is repair - which is inevitable down the track. Even sitting quietly on the seat will create some flex. My experience is with two-pack West Systems epoxy. The good thing is that one can add new epoxy over old epoxy, which you can also do with hide glue but not with yellow/white glues. Epoxy is also removable with heat, however this is not really practical with a failing joint. I suppose one can soak it in acetone (although how this will affect the finish I shudder to think). What other methods are there?
Regards from Perth
Derek
You can cause it to release (melt, I guess) with heat. I would contact Gougeon Bros. to find out what temperatures are effective, but I know it is less than 451° F.


