New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

On glues.

Posts

On glues.

#1

On glues.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

An experienced professional furniture maker in Perth recently shared this information with me ..

"for whatever reason (age, biological breakdown, acidic attack from sap in the Jarrah timber) hide glue in Jarrah chair joints always seem to go brittle and crumble...and the joints come loose.

It was for this reason that mechanically engineered sound joints are handy.



After trialling several glues over the years, (PVA, Urea Formaldehyde, & epoxy) we ended up settling on the epoxy.

Epoxy seems inert to acidic attack, from the sap in the wood.

It also seems to form a bond stronger than the parent material surrounding it.

Jarrah pretty much only occurs naturally between Yanchep National Park - down to Albany way east about as far as Narrogin (12 odd km's east of there out the Harrismith road) and it disappears where the Wandoo starts.



These soils are generally the Darling Scarp granits and also the bauxite gravels - as well as much of the swan coastal plain, etc.

Jarrah trees are a rather unique eucalypt - in that they thrive despite the poor soils and rainfall - they are highly adapted to their environment compared to a lot of other forests and forest species around the world. A lot of other species wouldn't do at all well in the conditions that Jarrah seems to thrive (including frequent fires).

One of the unique conditions is that these soils tend to be deep leached gutless grey sandy soils, once under the sea... (think white beach sands).

One major characteristic is that they are on the acidic side of the neutral Ph scale. As a result the sap in the tree is slightly acidic.

When you season the timber and remove the free moisture (sap) as well as the inter-cellular moisture and intra - cellular moisture, down to EMC (Equilibrium Moisture Content) ~ 12% for Swan Coastal plain - the remaining 12% moisture is the same acidity as the soil in which the tree was grown.



Thats 12% acidic sap does over time react with various glues in various ways.

The hide glues seem to go brittle and crumble.

Likewise my experience with U/F 62 (Urea Formaldehyde)

My results from epoxy resin, which is seemingly inert to weak acid attack that Jarrah sap represents - seems to produce joints where the glue is stronger than the parent material surrounding it.

Failures seem invariably to be of the timber surrounding the joint rather than the joint and glue itself."

The choice of glue has been on my mind for some time, although there is quite a way to go before I get to use this. It sounds like epoxy is the way to go as (1) it is less likely to break down, and (2) it has some flex, and this is needed in a leg join.

My only concern is repair - which is inevitable down the track. Even sitting quietly on the seat will create some flex. My experience is with two-pack West Systems epoxy. The good thing is that one can add new epoxy over old epoxy, which you can also do with hide glue but not with yellow/white glues. Epoxy is also removable with heat, however this is not really practical with a failing joint. I suppose one can soak it in acetone (although how this will affect the finish I shudder to think). What other methods are there?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: On glues.

#2

Re: On glues.

William Duffield

Acetone only dissolves the unreacted hardener and resin, but not the cured epoxy. Luckily, jarra is resistant to fire. :D You can cause it to release (melt, I guess) with heat. I would contact Gougeon Bros. to find out what temperatures are effective, but I know it is less than 451° F.

Note, when reglueing, or adding epoxy over previous layers of cured epoxy, that there is a condition called amine blush or bloom, that IIRC is a chemical that can form on the surface of the cured epoxy during the curing, that should be cleaned off before applying another coat of epoxy, or you will have bonding problems. I don't know any more about it than that, but Google will give you lots of info.

Re: On glues.

#3

Stephen Shepherd

Give up Jarrah.


Re: On glues.

#6

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Give up Jarrah.

Stephen Shepherd

Derek,

There are several ways to make hide glue flexible, just add some glycerin to the glue. Have you got a copy of my book?

Stephen

Re: On glues.

#7

Re: On glues.

Warren in Lancaster, PA

It could well be that jarrah grows on acid soil, but I very much doubt that acid in the wood is causing glue failure. Here in Pennsylvania we routinely glue woods that have tannic acid. Even if the wood were very acid it would be a trivial matter to neutralize the wood with ammonia, baking soda, washing soda or the like.

At lunchtime today I made a baking soda solution and applied it to a piece of jarrah. Bubbles would indicate acid, but there were none. I then put a tiny drop of vinegar on the jarrah with a 1.4 mm screw driver, let it dry and applied the baking soda. Plenty of bubbles.

Re: On glues.

#8

Re: On glues.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Warren, I was interested to learning this about Jarrah and hide glue as well. It is not something I had come across before, and not something that I had experienced either, however I do not have any previous experience with chairs (where movement would test the join).

I ran the question on the Australian forum and either there was no one sufficiently experienced to negate it, or the others there (and a few did reply) simply agreed.

Does it come down to epoxy or hide glue? In the videos of the chairs being assembled at the factory it looked like they were using a white glue.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: On glues.

#9

Re: On glues.

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Hide glue naturally becomes more brittle with age. That is why it is so easy to take apart an older chair; a sharp blow will shatter the glue. With other glues it is difficult to disassemble without doing some other damage to the stretchers or finish. And many glues are hard to clean off the joint to get to bare wood.

I have glued plenty of 18th, 19th century chairs, but not any Danish Modern chairs. They seemed to be everywhere forty or fifty years ago, not so many today.

Re: On glues.

#10

Jesper, Denmark

Re: On glues.

Jesper, Denmark

Derek,

The Danish commentary in the video from PP confirms that they are using regular white carpenter's glue.

Re: On glues.

#11

Re: On glues.

Tom

But not Jarrah?

White glue is OK, just be sure to get stuff that dried hard, hard, hard. Flexibility in glue is a bad thing where wood joinery is concerned. May not always be true, but it is a good default position. The most readily available white glue that dries hard and has low creep is Titebond 1. Maybe the other TBs are just as good, but I don't have decades of industry wide experience to prove the point. LMII also makes a purposely very hard white glue, but it isn't as easy to get as TB.

Re: On glues.

#12

Glue and maintenance or repairs

Bruce McCrory

Most restorers seem to prefer hide glue and resign others to red regions. Your own experience can verify some of the questions. We can count on chairs not specifically built to mechanical joint advantage to fail at some point. I slather outdoor furniture with epoxy, and only "one-shot" indoor use with the same.

You don't need to replicate the Chair identically, unless you intend forgery and I think it is spared that label for the next fifty, or so, by using 'brilliant' curly Jarrah. Improve the joint connections, if that will delay sloppy movement.

My 20 cents...

Re: On glues.

#13

Re: On glues. And epoxy removing soap

Tom

I think epoxy is a good bet, and I wouldn't prefer anything to west with a little colloidal to mix to preferred thickness. I've used barrels of the stuff on boats, along with every other brand I could test. WEST is the best overall (however many of the others are quite usable in certain applications). There are some epoxies that are relatively soft, which isn't a good thing. Some of these keep hardening over months and eventually get quite tough. WEST is there overnight, which does help at times and is never a real problem.

Amine blush is one of those things that the competitors of WEST have dreamed up to counter their market position. WEST does sometimes blush, a nice word for the surface feeling like it was coated with marg. This is worse the hotter and wetter you are working in, but it is a secondary bonding issue. If you coated the tenons one day, let them dry fully overnight in a wet hot enviro, and then glued them into the mortise the next day, not having taken a few seconds to wipe them off, you could have a problem... There are some folks, who with their process, find the blush is just one more thing they don't want to do, and there are other epoxies that work for them.

I wouldn't worry much about regluing epoxy it should work fine. One secret you won't like is that you can cut off the old epoxy, and no mater how loose, fill the joint with epoxy and it will be stronger than with the tight fit. Obviously nobody wants to go there. But it can be done. This provides more long term options than other glues (well, except that you can do the same thing starting from other glues if you can get them all off.

The problem I have with other glues is believing that when the repair comes it will be dealt with competently. It doesn't happen today, and I am not so sure it will happen in the future. One thing epoxy has going for it in M&T, is I just don't know of any stronger bonding glue that will last as well in the first place, so there is that.

If you use epoxy and get any on your hands, as when a glove wears through, just apply a dab of butter, or lard, and dry wash, when you have that done wash with a generous amount of dish soap. These are the two products that are required to remove epoxy from skin without using harsh solvents.

The full recipe appeared in Epoxyworks first and is on several websites:

http://www.dixdesign.com/epoxsoap.htm

Re: On glues.

#14

Re: On glues.

William Duffield

He makes jarrah sound like the vegetative equivalent of the monster from Alien. :D

Re: On glues.

#15

Re: On glues.

david weaver

There is a desire among guitar makers to have the hardest glue possible to transfer tone. Is that part of the reason that LMI sells really hard glue?

Re: On glues.

#16

Re: On glues.

Tom

My main concern is strength. With bridges, one gets creep which can cause the bridge to lift. Structurally harder is almost always better. Even where there is a lot of flexing, the thin layer that most epoxy uses consist of is more than flexible enough.

There is skepticism on the tone side, because the layer of glue is so thin that the wood is in full contact with the wood. But if they can sell varnish, then can sell glue. Plus hide glue is great anyway.

Re: On glues.

#17

Re: On glues.

david weaver

Speaking on the tone thing, I agree. I had a talk with George Wilson at one point about all of the things that people claim they think they can hear in guitars. I'm a (former) heavy buyer of guitars, and not a maker - but there are things I see people saying about what makes one guitar better than another that make me think they're just ripe for getting overcharged.

Especially when people talk about all of that stuff and how it relates to an electric guitar, and then they run their guitars through some kind of modeling amplifier.

I wish I would've done my buying after I was a woodworker! I'd have different guitars and generally less expensive.