New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

The Chair - Coping the tenon shoulders

Posts

Re: The Chair - Coping the tenon shoulders

#2

Re: The Chair - Coping the tenon shoulders

William Duffield

Good work, Derek!

I also have a set of crank neck incanel gouges. Mine are Buck Bros. They work fine for paring, but as you have discovered, the crank gives too much springiness when struck with a hammer.

That looks like Roy Underhill's hand in one of your photos. :D

When coping the shoulders, you should try to minimize the amount of undercutting you have to do. The less shoulder end grain that you leave directly supporting the joint, the more likely it will get compressed over the long term, opening the joint and weakening it. I'll admit I've done it too, because it makes it a lot easier to get the joint to close up so it looks like a sounder joint, even with square shoulders and a good shoulder plane, and even though I should have spent the extra effort on getting an exact fit. I suppose I had an excuse: I had a deadline. The chairs had to be in the dining room in time for Thanksgiving dinner, and the turkey wasn't going to wait. >(

My recommendation would be to spend the time necessary to refine the shape of the incanal gouge's edge instead of falling back to the 1/8" chisel.

Re: The Chair - Coping the tenon shoulders

#3

Re: Melted!

Tom

Nice.

I do and don't agree about the undercutting. If you are using epoxy for your joints, it obviously won't mater. Beyond that, one does have to ensure there isn't a knife edge there, but it takes relatively little endgrain to bear the loads, and relatively little of it will get used since the joint will fail before it gets recruited.

Re: The Chair - Coping the tenon shoulders

#4

Re: Melted!

William Duffield

I definitely agree about the epoxy. :) However, in general, as long as the user of the chair and his descendants will have access to someone who can maintain it properly, I strongly prefer hide glue due to its repairability if and when the joint fails. Of course, those are awfully stringent requirements. Maybe epoxy is the best choice for chairs in today's world. :\

I think I see your point about the end grain area, as well. I will think about that a lot more. It appears that Derek's 1/8" chisel is removing a major proportion of the shoulder in his chair, but as long as the undercutting doesn't get close to the ends of the shoulders, where most of the compression occurs, he should probably be all right.

Re: The Chair - Coping the tenon shoulders

#5

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Melted!

Jesper, Denmark

The joint strength will be the adhesion between the tenon cheeks and the mortice, supported by the mechanical contact between the shoulders and the leg. Regular wood glue will be as strong as epoxy - which will not ad strength to the end grain in the shoulders.

I'm sure that the tenon fit in OZ will be as perfect as in the originals.

Re: The Chair - Coping the tenon shoulders

#6

Re: Melted!

William Duffield

In OZ, at least in Perth, my expectations are the same as yours. However, in general (or perhaps in the abstract), if you are relying on the glue to fill in behind undercut shoulders, epoxy has an advantage over aliphatic resins or hide glue, because the former fills the gaps and does not shrink as it cures (at least the epoxies I use don't shrink), but the others shrink as the water in them evaporates, and do not give as much support to the shoulders as the bond eventually deteriorates between the tenon cheeks and the mortise sides. As Tom points out, if you are careful about how much material you remove and where you remove it, and especially if you are using "harder than a woodpecker's face" OZ hardwoods, you shouldn't have a problem.

I might be a little more concerned if he were using a few of the OZ woods which have an extremely large proportion of medullary ray cells, since I have found the rays in some of these to be softer than the rest of the wood structure. Derek knows about this property, I'm sure, and I don't think he has chosen any of these for this chair.

Re: The Chair - Coping the tenon shoulders

#7

Re: Melted!

Tom

I don't use epoxy much in furniture building, but some people do use it when working with SA woods because it is the only thing that sticks (actually hide glue sticks pretty well). Maloof used it on his rosewood chairs. The wood Derek is using doesn't look waxy like that, but you never know. What I like about epoxy is that it is regluable, like Hide glue. I guess not "like hide glue" in the sense that hide actually remelts, so maybe you get a 100% chemical bond, or you can totally remove it and start from scratch. But reglued epoxy joints are normally more than strong enough. And as you point out, in this specific case they can be relied upon to fill any undercutting so that question just disappears. In fine woodworking one has to be careful that epoxy doesn't bleed through the edges of a wood joint and create a shadow of a different colour. This normally isn't a problem if the finish is optically comparable.

Re: The Chair - Coping the tenon shoulders

#8

Re: Melted!

Bruce, a MN Galoot

what epoxies do you use, William?

Re: The Chair - Coping the tenon shoulders

#9

Re: Melted!

William Duffield

Mostly West System, but I've also successfully used System 3 five minute and T-88.

I like Gougeon Brothers products because they are well documented and they have many years of practical experience building and racing yachts. If you follow their documentation, which is clear and comprehensive, you get consistent, high quality results. Note that I used to work for a retail woodworking supply store, so the System Three products were easily available at a discount, which I took advantage of. West System was more expensive, but there was a West Marine store which carried their products, on the way home. Also, the town I live in has two marinas and a yacht service company who use West System extensively, so if I ran out I could go down the street and refill my cans of resin and hardener from their drums at large volume prices. I use West #205 fast hardener in the winter, and the #206 slow hardener in the summer and when I have a complicated glue up. I use the #207 less often. Mostly, I use West 406, 403 and 410 fillers. At times I have substituted the System 3 Silica for the West 406 with no problems.

Re: The Chair - Coping the tenon shoulders

#10

Re: Melted!

William Duffield

Perhaps more pertinent to your location, Bruce, the Gougeon brothers also designed, buit, and raced ice boats. :D

Re: The Chair - Coping the tenon shoulders

#12

Re: Melted!

Bruce, a MN Galoot

The Gougeon Bros products also figured prominently in the construction of my cedar strip canoe. I have the pumps and some leftover 405 resin/hardener, but their tech staff tells me that it's old and should be thrown.

I recall one incident with my canoe. I had scraped the excess off the fiberglass I was laying and put it into a paper cup. It had started smoking in the cup and by the time I walked to the other end of the canoe it was hard as a rock. Very hot, too.

Re: The Chair - Coping the tenon shoulders

#13

Re: Melted! *LINK*

William Duffield

I've had that happen too. My plastic cup full, with an acid brush in it, swelled up like a candy apple and swelled over the top.

In the middle of the summer, we might want to go get their 209 extra slow hardener. That's why they advise you to spread it out into a shallow pan, to increase the surface area. The hotter it gets, the faster it sets up. The faster it sets up, the hotter it gets. It's an exothermic reaction.

The hardener darkens substantially over a couple years or so, but it doesn't seem to affect its ability to harden the resin.


http://www.westsystem.com/ss/hardener-selection-guide/

Re: The Chair - Coping the tenon shoulders

#14

Re: Melted! I'll raise you one stem

Tom

When I built my tri, the whole stem was epoxy and glass, there was a vertical mass of epoxy, triangular in shape and about 2 inches a side. I Have poured much larger blocks of epoxy, and never had a problem, but apparently the vertical orientation of the material was a heat trap, and the whole thing smoked as though it might catch on fire. The best I could do was spray it with compressed air, which did the trick, though I might have been better off to have backed off from the thing and just let it go, but it was in a rented shop, and I was responsible. Having since met a few firemen, I think there is a possibility I could get cancer from that single exposure. The right way to have done it, which was used on the keel, would be to wire some wood into the middle of the fillet so that the epoxy wouldn't be thicker than a 1/2". Cheaper too.