We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I decided to stop highjacking Derek's Wegner chair post and start new. This is my funky attempt at a wooden tool rest. I make windsor chairs and turn alot of spindles. I hate moving the tiny supplied rest back and forth,especially when roughing out a blank. In Curtis Buchanan's videos he shows his wooden rest. That inspired me to make one for my lathe. Because I sometimes make shorter spindles I made several sizes of rest with one base. I keep a wrench on hand to loosen and tighten the base bolts to move the rest. It isn't perfect but it makes life alot easier for me. Shown below are the other rests I attach to the base. The big one has some vibration issues because it extends past the base on both sides. I'm thinking about a beefier rest with a permanent base for this size which is the one I use most.---Jack
If I recall correctly, Frank Pain's "Practical Woodturner" describes the use of wooden tool rests he says are better than metal for production work because gouge dents mark the positions of details, so no measuring or template is needed. It's important that there be a curved surface on the rest, so that the place your gouge touches the rest varies with diameter cut. That way the dents don't interfere with other operations. He is definitely concerned with work speed, facilitated by always keeping the lathe running while changing work.
He does also point out that his way of working has largely died out, and was writing in 1957.
I've attached an image of my lathe tool rest. I made it out of an upright piece of 6/4 beech glued and screwed to a cut down 2x6 (fir?). It is held on the lathe bed by adjustable levers and metal blocks, just like the old metal rest. I draw the profile and dimensions on the wood rest to guide me in making multiple turnings.
I recently did (4) joint stool legs using this and they turned out fine.
It seems to me it would make more sense to mark your distances and diameters on a story stick that is separate from your tool rest. That has several advantages. First, if you want to build another spindle or other turning to the same design later, you don't need a separate tool rest for each project. I end up moving my tool rest several times during the turning of each piece, mostly to adjust the distance from the rest to where I am cutting. If your marks are on the tool rest (instead of having been transferred directly from the story stick to the rough turned stock), there is a good chance that you will move your rest laterally, and misalign your zero point and throw off all your measurements.
I also mark all my important diameters on the story stick, and lay the stick on the lathe bed, across the banjo, so I can quickly pick up any diameter with a pair of calipers. The technique I use here is to label each longitudinal point with a letter, and then measure the diameter at that point to the right across the story stick, tick it and label the tick with the same letter.
If what I am turning is not a roughly cylindrical spindle, I can even roughly shape the front edge of the story stick to the final shape of the stock. That way, parallax errors in marking the stock are significantly reduced, and I can quickly remove more material with my roughing gouge, before precisely marking the detailed points on the stock. Note that when I mark a point on the story stick, I always use a square, aligned to the rear edge of the stick, and draw it all the way across. This makes it more precise and easier to mark the diameters on the story stick, and more precise to transfer the measurements to the stock using a divider point, or awl, or pencil.
If I'm making several identical turnings, then I transfer the letters from the story stick onto pairs of calipers, one set for each critical diameter. I hang them on pegs above the lathe. You never have enough calipers. I pick up more whenever I find them inexpensively at a tool meet. The tips need to be dressed so they don't catch in your work while you are holding the caliper in one hand and turning down to the specified diameter with your parting tool in the other hand.
For measuring diameters that are exact Imperial fractions, if the shape of the piece I am turning is wide enough at that point, I use mechanic's open end wrenches instead of calipers, and write the fraction on the story stick instead of measuring and marking the diameter. It is especially important to use these when turning tenons. Don't use cheap stamped wrenches. They are not accurate and they tend to catch on your turning. Professional chrome plated Craftsman, SnapOn, Matco, SKWayne, etc. will give you much better results.
I very rarely use square backed skews or square backed scrapers, so my tool rests don't get dinged up very often. Relying on dings to position your tools is a really bad idea, because most tools are held at a variable angle, so you get a swarm of dings instead of one.
I find a hardened steel tool rest is a much better choice than one of wood, even than the hardest and most impact resistant wood I can find in my shop. If you want to make a long tool rest, start with a piece of bed frame angle. It's still soft enough to dress with a file when necessary. Take the paint off the upper edge, and relieve the edges so it isn't gouging your gouges. This tool rest system gives excellent results, and the posts are easily mated to bed frame steel to make extra long rests. Drill and tap your lengths of bed frame to match the threaded ends of the posts.
Woodcraft doesn't provide the manufacturer's name, but I'm sure there are other retailers who also offer this tool rest system.
If you are doing a lot of long spindles, your most efficient option is to buy a second post and a second banjo from your lathe manufacturer to use with your home made long tool rests.
I misspoke(is that a word?). I don't turn my spindles. I turn alot of legs and stretchers,but they are all technically called spindles. Some bamboo style spindles need to be turned though but I don't make them very often.---Jack
Your points are noted, but in my limited experiences making turned stuff (handles, small table legs, clock bonnet spindles, etc.) precise measurements were not needed, at least how I work. Maybe it is just my approach to some aspects of woodworking. If the (4) leg turnings had the same pommel lengths (within ~1/8") and roughly looked the same, I was thoroughly satisfied. In the case of this most recent joint stool, the original stool's legs were not exactly identical - they didn't have to be so. In my copy, some of the diameters were off by at least 1/8" or so - I don't care. I simply try to make each turning look pleasing as an entity. The rived chestnut-oak stock used for my copy shrank amazingly, so I turned each leg within the particular leg's shrunken dimensions - I had chopped the mortises while the stock was green. There are even some flat spots on the round turnings - just like the original! I think each leg looks nice, even when placed next to each other. In reality, two of the four legs are quite different in some of the turned diameters - this done to compensate for the green-to-dry shrunken dimensions. When assembled into the finished stool, they looked fine, "non-identically". If it looks good - it is good...
I personally like using the wooden rest. I have turned several items using it. I just use an eraser to remove my pencil markings when I need to do a different design. In this case of the joint stool legs, since there were square pommels, I could not move the rest closer. And my rest was sufficiently long to not have to move it laterally either. Dumb luck on my part.
For what it's worth, I did first make a storey stick with all the pertinent dimensions - I used this to transfer the pencil markings to my wooden turning rest. It was also used to layout all the joinery mortises, etc.
For exact tenon dimensions, I do like your method using an open end wrench. However, in most of the limited stuff I've turned, not much is critical, so I simply use calipers.
Bottom line - I can appreciate the various methods others use for turning, but for me, I personally like the feel of a wood rest, and the "inaccurate variability" that creeps into my work due to some of my practices. I think it adds character. (If I really want precision - as in my bow making work - I can use my Southbend metal lathe to turn wood.) After all, the old guys doing these turnings, especially those for joint stools and other early furniture, did not have access to precise measuring devices and relied on muscle memory and sheer repetition to do their production work.
Just my $0.02. See you at the CJWA meeting on Wednesday night - I'll be bringing the joint stool "in the white" to the meeting. Note that I have finished rounding off the seat edge - it is no longer square as in the photo above.
Very nice, John. I'm looking forward to seeing it in person. I remember you demonstrating splitting out the stock from green oak. Was that two years ago at the Somerset woodworking show? The turnings on the one you chose to reproduce remind me of the shape of canons.
Small inconsistencies, as you describe, definitely add to the charm and historical accuracy of reproductions. Somewhere, I have an antique night table with turned legs. When I needed to do some repairs to the joinery several years ago, close examination showed me that it had not been turned. All the turning details had been hand carved by someone who evidently didn't even have a lathe.
One more note (of course not applicable to a joint stool) regarding sizing tenons with a mechanic's wrench: If you try it, you will soon find that your wrench is wider than your parting tool. This is annoying and leads to inaccuracies which are more important in a tenon than in decorative turning. I prefer using a bedan for this job, but I have a tool acquisition problem. A square nose scraper, or even a skew chisel will do the job.