New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Hand plane help

Posts

Hand plane help

#1

Hand plane help

Steve Corpstein

Scenario: This past week I had some time off of work so I decided to learn to cut dovetails by hand. I had some scrap maple in the box, so I hand sawed the end off to get rid of various other tests done to the edge. Figured I'd shoot the end square and give myself an even chance at some decent dovetails and that's where my troubles started.

I'm using an LN #9 with what seemed like a properly prepared blade (A2), primary bevel at 25*, secondary micro-bevel at 27* with the back highly polished and I used the ruler technique for good measure. All the edges were done on 6k and 13k stones and under a magnifying glass looked very polished and uniform.

Plane mouth was set to a small opening (and wider during the day) and I played with blade protrusion, but no matter what I tried, I had to apply a lot of force to go through the wood and really struggled to get the end square and smooth. What do you guys with experience think was most likely the cause of my struggles? I kept thinking blade preparation, but no matter how carefully I honed the edge, it never really got any better.

Re: Hand plane help

#2

Diagnostic

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Steve,

How thick is the maple? And is it hard (sugar, birdseye) or soft maple?

I suggest repeating your effort on thinner stock, say 1/4" thickness. If that goes smoothly, go up to 3/8", 1/2", and so on, and see how the difficulty progresses with increasing thickness.

On the other hand, if the 1/4" or 3/8" gives problems, you're looking at something very basic in the setup.

I have found that this kind of exercise--working from easy to more difficult--can provide insight into what is happening at the cutting edge, and allow you to work through the problem. Personally, when the stock gets up around 3/4" to 13/16", I'd rather just plane it square and plumb in the vise, but then I don't own a specialty shooting plane.

Wiley

Re: Hand plane help

#3

Re: Diagnostic

Steve Corpstein

The stock was 3/4" hard maple. I had the same results with a piece of poplar, which is why I didn't blame the wood, rather the fault is either the tuning of the plane including blade edge, or myself which I suspect because I'm by no means experienced. I'm working at it as much as I can.

Re: Hand plane help

#4

Find a point of success

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Steve,

Back off on thickness until you find success. Then go forward from there. Handtools is analog.

Just my 2 cents, from experience.

Wiley

Re: Hand plane help

#5

Re: Hand plane help

Brian Greene

I expect the issue is either the edge or the overall tuning. At the risk of offending, you never mentioned whether, despite your efforts, the blade was actually sharp. Try the end grain pine test with a very fine setting for example. On the maple you might try wetting the end grain with alcohol or paint thinner. This softens the fibers. Even water will do but doesn't evaporate quickly and can lead to rust. Good luck.

Re: Hand plane help

#6

Ellis Walentine

I agree with Wiley

Ellis Walentine

If you need excessive pressure to take a shaving, my hunch is that you're taking too big a bite. Try the smallest possible depth of cut that actually touches the wood, and advance the iron just a tiny bit from there. You might also want to rub the sole of your plane (and the side it is riding on, for that matter) with a dab of paraffin or paste wax to lessen the resistance on the shooting board and the workpiece, and practice taking light, rapid passes rather than slow, deliberate ones. Let the momentum of the plane do the work.

And, as others have suggested, make sure the blade is sharp. You shouldn't see any reflected light when you look at the edge from the end. It should slice pine endgrain easily.

Let us know if any of these suggestions work.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Hand plane help

#7

Re: Find a point of success

Hank Knight

I'm with Wiley. I find hard maple a bear to work on the shooting board, especially hard maple over, say, 1/2" thick. Back off on the thickness or find a softer wood, like soft maple, walnut or cherry. I think you will have a much more satisfying experience with one of those, not only shooting, but also with dovetails. Dovetailing two pieces of hard maple together is a challenge!

Hank

Re: Hand plane help

#8

Re: Hand plane help

Patrick Gibbons

I do not have experience with this plane so forgive my hubris for chiming in here. I believe this is a bevel up plane. Adding a 2 degree micro bevel makes the bedding angle 47 degrees. I presume you're going through end grain. All these elements make for a hard job. Have you successfully done this before? How does the plane perform on long grain? If OK then it is probably technique on end grain. I would get rid of the micro bevel and reduce the bed angle back to 45 degrees. A very light cut works better and letting the weight of the plane do the work is better than trying to force it through.

Re: Hand plane help

#9

Re: Hand plane help

John in NM

My first reaction is that you may be over taking the plumbing a bit with all the sharpening. Bear in mind that you could probably get a blade adequately sharp for shooting by rubbing it on the sidewalk - all the fussy stuff you read about is concerned with a. saving time, and b. getting beyond adequate.

Getting beyond first reactions, I think Ellis probably has it right - too heavy a cut. Back the blade out so that it doesn't cut at all. Start sneaking up on it and you will find the point where the cut works well. Wax the shooting board and plane too, that makes a big difference.

Re: Hand plane help

#10

Re: Hand plane help

Steve Corpstein

I finally noticed today that the edge of the board had such an angled cut on it that when I was sliding the top to the sole, the bottom was actually catching the rear of the mouth. Went back and cut a properly perpendicular saw cut and things worked much better. I don't get a shaving, more chalk than shaving, but I think that's because of the species of wood. If I use the same plane setting on the long grain, it takes a shaving that anybody would marvel over. So blade was sharp, projection was right, mouth was set correctly, it looks like I need more practice with hand sawing so I can cut straight. Thanks for all of the analysis, I appreciate the help.

Re: Hand plane help

#11

Good work!!  Persistence pays!