New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Has anyone tried these blades? *LINK*

Posts

Has anyone tried these blades? *LINK*

#1

Stephen Shepherd

Has anyone tried these blades? *LINK*

Stephen Shepherd

Anyone out there given the new tapered blades from Lee Valley?

Stephen


img

tapered plane blades

Re: Has anyone tried these blades? *LINK*

#2

Re: Has anyone tried these blades?

Tom

I was interestedin trying them out in their new miiracle metal I can make O1 blades faster tjan I can get to the store about ten miles from here.

The only other thing was that they seem a little short for classic English style blades initially I made mine on the shorter side and they were not long enough. I haven, t settled on a length yet.

Re: Has anyone tried these blades? *LINK*

#3

Re: Has anyone tried these blades?

Bob Rozaieski

I'm seriously considering it. I have some 16/4 beech just dying to become a new fore plane. I really like that these are tapered like a traditional iron. I'd have a hard time tapering one myself, especially at the price.

Re: Has anyone tried these blades? *LINK*

#4

Re: Has anyone tried these blades?

david weaver

I haven't, partially due to their length, and partially because of the number of good vintage irons I have...

but I figure that it's worth mentioning that two simple searches on ebay usually yields a glut of vintage irons, double or single, that are much more attractive on a vintage style plane (and longer if you'd like to seat a long wedge):

*"taper plane iron"

*"parallel plane iron"

...depending on what you're looking for.

Re: Has anyone tried these blades? *LINK*

#5

Why taper blades?

Bruce McCrory

Rob your comment is intriguing. Don't want to sabotage this thread, but there must be a reason to want, or go to the trouble of tapering.

Re: Has anyone tried these blades? *LINK*

#6

Re: Why taper blades?

david weaver

You need to fit a parallel (non taper) iron to a plane only one time to find out why taper blades are preferable.

Getting the wedge out of a plane with a taper iron is easy. Getting a hard seated wedge out of a plane with a parallel iron is a real problem.

Re: Has anyone tried these blades? *LINK*

#7

Re: Has anyone tried these blades?

Stuart Hough

I have an old wooden-bodied jointer that has a tapered iron. I have to agree with the info on the LV website that explains it is easier to keep a tapered iron seated, as the force of planning attempts to drive the iron backward (upward), but due to the taper it remains where set easier than with a parallel iron.

Re: Has anyone tried these blades? *LINK*

#8

Re: Why taper blades?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

In addition to David's point above, the tapered blade under planing load tends to wedge itself tighter. In effect, it is dovetailed between the wedge and the bed.

Wiley

Re: Has anyone tried these blades? *LINK*

#9

Re: Why taper blades?

david weaver

Wiley - that desire to get the wedge tight enough with a parallel blade, to do something that the wedged blade does easily (stay advanced where you want it) probably just adds to the difficulty of getting the irons out.

When I first made moulding planes, I was too cheap to buy tapered iron blanks. I put flat blanks in the moulding planes and they sat for a day or two. It was a BEAR to get the wedges out of the planes. I theorized about putting weight in the ends of the wedges, and all kinds of lazy things.

I'm still too cheap to buy tapered blanks, but I sand taper into the moulding plane irons I make now with a belt sander and a hand jig. It only takes a little to make a huge difference. (I wouldn't do it with a bench plane iron, though).

Re: Has anyone tried these blades? *LINK*

#10

Re: Why taper blades?

Tom

I mostly use non-tapered blades and:

1) There are some planes where it really is next to impossible to adjust the blades if they aren't tapered. This can be because there is a poor angle of hit on the wedge or heel.

2) There are also many planes where it is easy to use parallel blades. The general run of bench planes, for instance. With a well fitted blade, ramp, wedge, and the proper choice of woods. Would they be better with a little taper to them, probably, because every so often you end up with them really in there, and no easy way to get them out, though I always have without undue violence, so it is not a real problem for the most part.

Another thing I don't like about tapered blades is that they often taper right down to downright flimsy thicknesses that don't feel right when struck, and tend to vibrate nostily, or mark the hammer.

I don't know if there is a serious reason for going so light, but maybe there would be a good compromise if one went from 3/16 to 1/8, rather than all the way down to 1/16th. Possibly they were just cheaping out at a time when anything in metal was more expensive to get than it can be today. Doubling the top thickness would mean an eight fold improvement in stiffness.

I am sure that Derek has issued ecstatic reviews on some of the following planes: Krenov, Mung fang whatever, ECE, HNT, all of which use parallel blades in wedged planes.

Re: Has anyone tried these blades? *LINK*

#11

Re: Why taper blades?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Tom

You're right as always.

Tapered blades are my first choice when it comes to making traditional woodies. By that I mean, woodies that are based on designs of the 19th Century and earlier. The taper does enable the blade to be held more firmly, however I have other woodies with parallel blades that hold nearly as well. As david pointed out, removing a stuck tapered blade is easier than removing a stuck parallel blade. I suspect that these were the main reasons for using tapered blades in the past.

The fact is that there are many fine woodies that use parallel blades. the planes of Jim Krenov are famous in this regard (although he did add a novel cross pin design), and HNT Gordon and Mujinghang are two of those whose planes I have. Steve Knight used to build woodies with parallel blades.

One advantage of a parallel blade (over the tapered) is in making fine adjustments to its projection. It is easier to withdraw the blade (reduce the projection) by taping on the heel of the body. The tapered blade will resist moving, which is its very strength.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Has anyone tried these blades? *LINK*

#12

A bit more discussion please

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

"One advantage of a parallel blade (over the tapered) is in making fine adjustments to its projection. It is easier to withdraw the blade (reduce the projection) by taping on the heel of the body. The tapered blade will resist moving, which is its very strength."

___

Hi Derek and all,

I would appreciate a bit more discussion on this point. Is this theoretical or has it been tested? I have had no difficulty hammer-tuning my C&W (Old Street) woodies, which have tapered irons. But then I don't have comparable parallel-blade woodies to compare to, so I can't argue the point from experience, even anecdotally.

What seems right to me is that the user's familiarity with the plane will be the decisive factor in adjustability. It only takes light hammer taps, or just simple hand pressure, to set the C&W wedge--so it's not surprising to me that the planes fine-tune readily.

What is the experience of others?

Thanks,

Wiley

Re: Has anyone tried these blades? *LINK*

#13

Re: Why taper blades?

Steve Voigt

I have bought a lot of vintage tapered irons in the last couple years. I agree with Dave that they can be great, with a couple of caveats.

Unslotted single irons on ebay are quite rare, unless you want to pay import shipping from gandm tools (an ebay seller) in Britain. However, those are competitively priced with the LV irons.

Tapered double irons are more common, but you need to be careful. Many of the irons out there are pitted to death, or so short that the laminated bit is almost used up, or so badly dubbed that it would take forever to flatten. Even old irons in good condition can take a lot of work to flatten.

With that said, there are still bargains to be found. I recently got a huge, 2 5/8 x 8 1/2 Butcher slotted iron in absolutely mint condition for $12 plus reasonable shipping. So, my advice is to be patient, wait for good irons, and buy new-old stock whenever possible.

Regarding adjustment, I don't have any parallel single irons, so I can't comment on what Derek said about adjustability. I do have some parallel double irons (Hock), but the combined sandwich of parallel iron + chipbreaker is actually slightly tapered, so it should work much like a tapered iron. I do know that all my woodies are pretty easy to adjust--it is just a matter of practice.

Re: Has anyone tried these blades? *LINK*

#14

Re: Why taper blades?

Steve Voigt

Tom said:

I don't know if there is a serious reason for going so light, but maybe there would be a good compromise if one went from 3/16 to 1/8, rather than all the way down to 1/16th.

I forgot to mention this in my other post. This came up recently on another forum. The vintage irons that I have that are in unused (or near) condition taper from a fat 3/16 (like .195 - .210) down to 3/32 or a little more (say .095-.105). There are exceptions, but this is the norm. I'm not sure why LV went with the taper they chose, but I agree with Tom that a little more meat would be better. As Dave mentioned, even a little taper makes a big difference; more is not necessarily better.

Re: Has anyone tried these blades? *LINK*

#15

Re: Why taper blades?

Tom

That is interesting Steve. One often gets old planes where the striking end is badly bent, in part because it was iron. It should be possible to use them without abusing them, but the evidence is that somewhere along the line they got ill used. One just can't imagine that on a Krenov stubby.

Re: Has anyone tried these blades? *LINK*

#16

Re: A bit more discussion please

Tom

I can see both sides. It gets darn hard to write some of this stuff without numbers we would all understand, even if we had access to them. Or without so much mumbo jumbo that it all seems mealy mouthed.

When it comes to tapping a wedge, I would guess it goes beyond pure theory that tapered blades respond differently than straight ones. The straight ones are like boats, X displacement per inch of immersion, meaning you can whack them a long way without the advance per stroke varying much, or having to worry about the wedge pressure changing.

With a tapered blade you have the fun that comes with the blades loosening more with each blow, and the possible need to estimate what happens to depth of cut when you re-tighten the wedge.

On the other hand, in skilled hands what problems or benefits any of this presents should not be apparent in the work, or even in the use of the plane. We drive in the snow and ice up here, but until the tires actually cut loose from the roadway, and the car gets ditched, it all seems about as difficult. In fact, the sunny weather in the summer often has a lot of hot and bothered drivers doing pretty unpredictable things to rival winter driving. So better/worse, or easier/harder. Not all that easy to say, but sometimes a reasonable shortcut in the prose.

Re: Has anyone tried these blades? *LINK*

#17

Re: Why taper blades?

david weaver

Yeah, not to suggest ebay is the only option, and there is a learning curve if you buy a bunch of pitted irons.

I have often been too stingy to get most of the fixed price listings, and haunting ebay in the past has yielded such things as 3 double sets for 10 bucks, etc.

derek did point out kenyon irons one time in another thread, and the ones that are up there now seem to be a little less primo in terms of the hard part of the iron, but purchased two of those when the supply originally was offered, and I think the two were about 50 bucks delivered and are smart looking pieces of gear.

The LV isn't a "bad" option so much, it just appears to me that someone with the means for the vintage irons, esp. with the desire to seat a large wedge, will probably prefer a vintage iron.

Someone using three oilstones with no means to abrade metal faster may not have such a love for the vintage irons, though, unless they are already properly prepared.

Re: Has anyone tried these blades? *LINK*

#18

Comment on the "ill use of blades"

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

I see a lot of hammered plough irons, similar to what is being described in this thread for thin-at-the-top tapered irons. This mushrooming bears no proportion to the amount of tapping either type of iron would require in the intended use.

My conclusion: Down through the decades, somebody--not the original owner--had used the mushroomed irons as chisels, splitting wedges, box openers, etc.

Wiley

Re: Has anyone tried these blades? *LINK*

#19

I think I understand....

Bruce McCrory

My initial assumptions reflect Tom's, above. Hence, the question. I see the tapers, just never thought much about them. Thanks,

Sorry, to the OP for this distraction.... :\

Re: Has anyone tried these blades? *LINK*

#20

Re: Comment on the "ill use of blades"

Tom

I see that on planes that one would not want to use as chisels. And I also wonder whether the average plane so used would make it back together and into our shops. But I don't doubt what you describe happens either. Just about all the other tools seem to have got abused in some mode. I sometimes wonder to what extent the original makers should be held responsible for the fact that their tools couldn't deal with transitional uses. Obviously not much. Maybe current tool which tend to be overbuilt would do better, should a transitional period occur at some point, which seems possible.

Re: Has anyone tried these blades? *LINK*

#21

Re: Comment on the "ill use of blades"

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Tom,

I didn't mean that the plane would be involved in the ill-use. Rather, the blades appear to have been removed from the plane and used as chisels, etc, resulting in mushrooming. Then returned to the plane, or a different plane.....

The alternate theory would be that the blade had gotten frozen in place over time, and to remove it from the plane, a later user or recycler had taken a steel hammer and pounded it down through the throat to get it loose--that could easily happen with a tapered blade (after beating hell out of the butt of plane, where you also see hammer tracks, in an unsuccessful attempt to back out blade/wedge).

Wiley

Re: Has anyone tried these blades? *LINK*

#22

Re: Comment on the "ill use of blades"

Patrick Gibbons

I think most tools get abused after the user is dead and gone. Others come into possession, haven't a clue or a care about proper use and abuse the tool on occasions separated by long periods of neglect.

Re: Has anyone tried these blades? *LINK*

#23

perhaps

John Pappas

I have some tools from an old friend...and they get the care that tools from an old friend deserve. Always a reminder of our friendship.

Re: Has anyone tried these blades? *LINK*

#24

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Has anyone tried these blades?

Stephen Shepherd

Thanks for the interesting response to my question, yet the question still goes unanswered, guess I will have to try one.

Stephen