New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Ichihiro comparable chisel

Posts

Ichihiro comparable chisel

#1

Ichihiro comparable chisel

Allen Fulmer

Hey guys,

I'm looking for a white steel #1 chisel, of a top quality, comparable to Ichihiro like the title states. I've been given suggestions of kunikei as even par, also Yamahiro. What do you guys think, anyone use any of these or anything else? I've read a little about each of these two but nothing other than hearsay. Kiyohisa is out of the question only because no one can get them because of the insane wait for his work.

Re: Ichihiro comparable chisel

#2

Re: Ichihiro comparable chisel

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Kiyohisa is out of the question only because no one can get them because of the insane wait for his work.

Well I cannot avoid the gloat :) ... but I did wait 3 years for these. They are indeed a pleasure to use: very easy to hone and yet hold an edge really well. They balance wonderfully in the hand.


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Ichihiro comparable chisel

#3

Re: Ichihiro comparable chisel

Allen Fulmer

Derek, I've seen your chisels every time I google Push chisels. They're extremely nice. Unfortunately I'm a little late to the party on Japanese chisels. So another high quality maker of white steel #1 it is.

Re: Ichihiro comparable chisel

#4

Re: Ichihiro comparable chisel  *LINK*

wilbur

I use the regular Fujihiro chisels that Imai makes. They are white steel #2, and are really good. His “sword steel” chisels use white steel #1, and are supposed to be outstanding. I haven’t had a chance to use the sword steel chisels myself, but they might be worth looking into.


“Sword steel” chisels by Imai, via Hida Tool

Re: Ichihiro comparable chisel

#5

Re: Ichihiro comparable chisel

Allen Fulmer

I was originally looking at the sword steel chisels, but then I decided I didn't want the mokume style look. Just a black finish chisel. But i have heard amazing things about the sword steel chisels.

Re: Ichihiro comparable chisel

#6

Re: Ichihiro comparable chisel

Paul M.

I don't know about premier makers names, but I've been using my Matsumura white steel firmer chisels for about 10 years and have absolutely no complaints. I find the tiny handles of Japanese chisels disappear in my hands, so I opted for the larger version. I use these as bench chisels and I've never found any reason to want additional chisels above these. They also come in standard sizes if you have smaller hands. Linky below...

http://www.craftsmanstudio.com/html_p/J!14.306.htm

Re: Ichihiro comparable chisel

#7

Two generalities and couple of specific

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Generality 1. Japanese smiths give rise to contagions. Suddenly one is very 'hot'. The ones who were hot yesterday are no longer so hot. Where does it come from? Vendor campaigns reinforced by opinion leader customers. Tasai was super hot; then Funatsu (Funahiro) was hot; now Kiyohisa and Ikeda are hot. There are others going back further in time.

Generality 2. Your best bet--and really only bet--is to develop a lasting relationship with a vendor. And keep it. And be patient. The vendor is not always ordering out of a catalog--he is also trying to obtain the choice items which are limited by the smith's production rate, and it isn't easy. Some of the smiths will deal direct; many only through brokers. When the vendor comes across something really choice, he has a decision who to offer to first.

Couple Specifics. Check with Stu or with Tomohito Iida regarding the availability of Funatsu-san's (Funahiro) slicks in a clean steel, like the white #1 you cited, or Bohler 990K. Though I don't know personally, Ikeda-san (Kunikei) has the reputation you're asking after--again, check with vendor for availability. Assorted references:

http://www.japan-tool.com/nomi/Konobu/Konobu_Uchimaru.html

http://japantool-iida.com/chisel_bench/2008/05/genjyu-funahiro.html

Suggestion: If there is something that So Yamashita has that you know you want, write with Want to Buy and Smith's Name in the subject line.

Wiley

Re: Ichihiro comparable chisel

#8

Re: Two generalities and couple of specific

Allen Fulmer

Hey Wiley,

I actually was emailing back and forth with Tomohito last night and today. Hes made some good suggestions. He currently has a set of 10 Kunikei Oire available in rosewood handles in White #1 that im considering. Just not sure if i want to pay for a set of 10 when I dont need a set of 10.

I also put an order in for those very thins we were discussing. Tasai is gonna make them in custom specs for me.

Im still waiting to hear back from Stu as well. I havent gotten a chance to ask him his recommendation, but he is working on some other things for me.

Re: Ichihiro comparable chisel

#9

Outstanding they are

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

I only have two of them, should get more :)

They take an incredible edge and keep it forever. In my limited experience, they impress me as much as my Yataiki saws. They're that good.

Now, how do I convince "the boss" that I also really need some Tasai thins...

DC

Re: Ichihiro comparable chisel

#10

Re: Two generalities and couple of specific

Allen Fulmer

Hey Wiley,

Without scrolling back through all the content of your posts, Do you have any experience with the Genjyu Funahiro chisels? Or do you know anything about them. From what Ive read theyre hard as nails. But no one knows what kind of steel he uses to make them?

I specified a clean white steel but in a bench chisel rather than a push chisel. Ive got my Tasai's for pushing ;)

Re: Ichihiro comparable chisel

#11

Re: Two generalities and couple of specific

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Allen,

I think 'genjyu' is some sort of Japanese superlative or honorific, and could apply to whatever the maker assigns it to. I have two Funahiro slicks that I bought 8 or 10 years ago as 'genjyu' through Hida Tool. They are super blue steel and hard to sharpen. In fact, I use diamond paste on them.

More recently, couple years ago, in a conversation with So, I understood him to say that the current Funahiro genjyu was an ultra-clean steel, maybe Bohler 990K. Bottom line: You have to ask the vendor what's in the steel, and have him verify with the maker.

Wish I could tell you more, but that's it.

Wiley