New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Simple question on Harder waterstones

Posts

Simple question on Harder waterstones

#1

Simple question on Harder waterstones

Tony Wilkins

I'm thinking about expanding/replacing some of my water stones. Right now I have a Hida #1,000 and King #6,000. I'm thinking of adding ceramic stones (shapton, sigma, suehiro) to the mix both to save on soaking and to get a higher grit than #6,000.

One thing that stops me, and leads me to my question, is the difference in flattening. The best ceramic stones advertise dish resistance. I flatten my current old-tech water stones at least before every sharpening.

My question: How often would I need to flatten 'dish resistant' ceramic water stones?

TIA,

Tony

Re: Simple question on Harder waterstones

#2

Re: Simple question on Harder waterstones

wilbur

I have Shapton Pro waterstones (1000, 5000, 8000 grit). The frequency of flattening depends on what grit you’re talking about. The higher grits require less flattening than the 1000 grit waterstone.

From a practical standpoint, I flatten the 1000 grit nearly every time I use it for more than a touchup. I flatten the 5000 or 8000 probably once for every 5-10 times it gets used.

Re: Simple question on Harder waterstones

#3

Re: Simple question on Harder waterstones

Brian Greene

Stones with a high ceramic content such as Bester and Imanishi (my favorites) are indeed more dish resistant. How much so? How less frequently will you need to lap? That depends on the manner of your use. I find that I can go quite a long time because I think I'm very good at using the stone evenly. I don't usually; however, when I have left them for a while I have also been surprised. The more often you lap the less material you lose to the process.

The real advantage of these stones is the speed at which they cut; 2-3 times faster than Kings.

Re: Simple question on Harder waterstones

#4

Re: Simple question on Harder waterstones

Tom

Use the whole stone.

Re: Simple question on Harder waterstones

#5

Re: Simple question on Harder waterstones

Archie

+1 on the above 3 responses.

For me, it's a speed boost. By flattening more often, I both clean the stone of swarf/loose abrasives as well as keep its cutting speed much higher. Since I have multiple higher grit options, I have little need to "load" a stone in order to use it further. However, that's a preference issue and not one of need.

Enjoy

Re: Simple question on Harder waterstones

#6

When they are bowls