New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Repairing my Record quick release vise

Posts

Repairing my Record quick release vise

#1

Repairing my Record quick release vise

Patrick Gibbons

Some time ago my Record vise started malfunctioning due to a worn pin. On the back end of the screw is a hole. A pin fits through this and holds a plate on the screw that also butts up against the guide rods. When you reverse the screw, the plate keeps it from unscrewing from the vise and disengaging the half nut. A search of the internet revealed this to be a common problem with these vises. I've ordered some 3/16" drill rod to replace the pin.

If one looks in Landis' Workbench Book, he has a diagram of the Record vise that shows a plate that has holes in which the guide rods fit and there are two washers on the screw between the plate and the pin. My vise was made right before Record went away and the plate has bosses rather than holes into which the guide rods fit.

My questions concern the washers and the pin. My Record does not appear to have any room for a washer. Does anyone have my generation of the vise and does yours have a washer? Also can you tell if the pin has been peened to keep it from exiting the hole?

Sorry about such a long entry for such simple questions. Thanks in advance.

Re: Repairing my Record quick release vise

#2

Ellis Walentine

Re: Repairing my Record quick release vise

Ellis Walentine

My 70s-vintage #53E has the heavy plate with holes for the guide rods. It also has the two washers you mentioned, and wear is not an issue because the pin bears on the outer washer and doesn't wear against anything because the washer spins. Also, the pin doesn't appear to be peened, although it is so tight that I was thinking it might have been heat-shrunk into that hole.

Probably not much help, but if you can get a washer between the pin and plate, you'll eliminate the pin wear problem. OTOH, at this point in your life, what are the odds you'll wear out another pin anyway?

Ellis

Re: Repairing my Record quick release vise

#3

craigd

zipties

craigd

My solution (has worked for over five years now):


Re: Repairing my Record quick release vise

#4

Re: zipties

Dominic in Buck's County Pa

same here!

Re: Repairing my Record quick release vise

#5

Re: zipties

Patrick Gibbons

Why in the hell did I waste money on ordering drill rod? What a great use of zip ties. Amazing how wide spread this problem is. Think of all that money Irwin Record saved on washers. Maybe 10c/vise. Probably more like 5. I think I'll use the drill rod and the zip ties. Let's see... 4c for zip ties, $1.72 for 36" of drill rod of which I'll use about an inch or about 5c. Let's throw in another penny for shipping on the three items. So, a ten cent fix for a ten cent problem.

Thanks again for the advice. Great ingenuity.

Re: Repairing my Record quick release vise

#6

Re: Repairing my Record; Success...for now

Patrick Gibbons

I found that using the pin alone would not work. The screw still slipped out of the half nut because the guide rods wouldn't stay in the bosses of the plate. They still shifted with the zip ties added. This made it obvious how much better the original design had been. I bought a thin washer, I forget what the hardware store called it, and put it between the pin and the plate. To do this required chucking the pin in the drill press and filing one end narrower to get it started in the hole. I had contemplated hardening and tempering the pin but laziness won out. I suspect the washer will wear off, the pin will wear and shear and the whole repair will need to be repeated. Probably in short order as well.

Re: Repairing my Record quick release vise

#7

craigd

Re: Repairing my Record; Success...for now

craigd

I just spent some time under the bench figuring why the half nut on my vice didn't always fully engage (and pop under load) and noticed that the cotter key at the end of the screw was sheared around 90%. I also added a washer but it needs to be a loose fit (ie thin) or things just grind back there.

Re hardening the pin - it is best to have the more easily replaced part be the softest one, eg the keys on motor shafts. Plus, I think it has only two functions: hold the plate on and act as a garter to open the jaws so it takes a while to grind through it.

Too bad the zip ties didn't work - the backing plate on mine will spin like a propeller without them. I had thought about drilling & tapping the guide rod(s) so I could run a screw in to hold the plate but the ties worked too well.

Re: Repairing my Record quick release vise

#8

Re: Repairing my Record; Success...for now

Patrick Gibbons

The ties helped considerably. They just didn't work alone. I also thought about tapping and screwing. It's an option if the pin wears out too quickly. Hardening the pin may reduce wear but I was also worried about if it might make something else wear out from contact with the pin. Right now the vise is working. I now have a tail vise again so time to get back to work. Incidently, I have noticed that Record changed the design on their half nut/quick release mechanism. I think this and the plate/pin redesign were not as robust as their original. It's interesting that old Record vises are still soldiering on while newer ones break down.

Re: Repairing my Record quick release vise

#9

Thin washers

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Auto parts stores sometimes have thin washers of various sorts for automotive functions. If your hardware store washer fails, you might consider finding a good parts guy/gal* at an auto parts store and see if they can come up with a solution.

*When trying to find good ones, I'm usually biased toward gray hair, but this is not always an accurate predictor. The BMW motorcycle dealership in the next county south of us, back when my son was riding, had a woman in her 20s who was one of the three best parts folks I've ever met; and I've been blessed with meeting some good ones. You want someone with broad knowledge of the inventory and the ability to think outside the catalog listings of what a given part is for.

Re: Repairing my Record quick release vise

#10

Re: Thin washers

Patrick Gibbons

Yesterday I couldn't remember this, but the thin washer was a machine bushing. Seems to me that a washer is a bushing. Nevertheless, it was a good fit.

Re: Repairing my Record quick release vise

#11

Good advice, Bill

Patrick Gibbons

It's much easier to pay more for a part when a good portion of the purchase price goes towards knowledge and judgement. In fact, it's a bargain most of the time.

Re: Repairing my Record quick release vise

#12

Re: Thin washers

Bob Hackett

I would think that these washer would be more of a thrust bearing.

It`s my understanding that bushings are usually a bearing that wraps around a part to support/allow either rotational or linear movement rather than limit or prevent it.

Re: Repairing my Record quick release vise

#13

Re: Thin washers

Patrick Gibbons

Makes sense. Sounds like I got the right thing.