More "Inventors" Who Just Don't Get It
William Duffield
http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2013/11/131122165645.htm
This is another exercise in futility. Why didn't they read Pye or Walker and Tolpin before embarking on this?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
More "Inventors" Who Just Don't Get It
William Duffield
http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2013/11/131122165645.htm
This is another exercise in futility. Why didn't they read Pye or Walker and Tolpin before embarking on this?
Re: More "Inventors" Who Just Don't Get It
Patrick Gibbons
The research seems to have more application in electronics. It's just crazy stupid for woodworking. I have to believe the article is leaving much out. Otherwise the research is just worthless.
Agree...
John in NM
I would hazard a guess that the researcher is simply interested in woodcarving, and is using that as an impetus for his elctro-mechanical research. Even if such a device worked perfectly every time, the cost/benefit is so heavily weighted one way that this will always be little more than a neat bit of research as far as woodcarving goes. It may have real practical application in other fields, but not in handicrafts.
I think they get it
wilbur
I do see an application for this. Think about this sort of device mounted on a robotic arm. You get factory production of items that show the sort of item-to-item variation that you would see in hand work.
"Creativity is all about error..."
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
And more generally, it is a study in design, using the concept of 'error' (as a feedback signal) to create something that is not pre-programmed.
I think it's an interesting study in design, but will not be a threat to people who can really carve or design (or write music, etc).
Wiley
Re: More "Inventors" Who Just Don't Get It
Adam of Oakland
i find it depressing. completely depressing. I'll echo the above comments that there must be more to the story than what the article reports.
I wish i could explain it better but I do worry about the mechanization (and implicit scalability) of artisanal creations, be they wood, clay, horseshit and straw, etc. provincial attitude i guess. my ego and my hands are almost indistinguishable it seems.
i'll say this: wood misbehaves. wood is a lover. wood requires empathy. It (she? He?) has grain, color, strength...stuff that eludes programming so far. but being a computer programmer, i know it wont be long before some brat from Stanford or MIT adds those factors into a massive array of compute nodes to figure out exactly how to choose the optimal continuous grain pattern for a series of drawer fronts in an haute chippendale reproduction that will not be discernible from the original. Sold at Ikea for $Dollah-2wo-NINETY-EIGHT.
I'll reiterate an old commercial slogan from years ago: "Is it live or is it Memorex?" Talk me down, comrades. I was looking forward to chopping broccoli tonight with my old Japanese vegetable knife. Is the patina I see on the blade, and the hammer marks from forging a digitization? Did I have the red pill by mistake?
-Adam weeping in Oakland
Re: More "Inventors" Who Just Don't Get It
William Duffield, on the Cohansey
My sentiments, exactly, Adam. BTW, I started programming in 1966.
Where's that (hand-made) wooden shoe, when we really need it?
Or sabot, hand- and brain- and heart-made.
Re: More "Inventors" Who Just Don't Get It
Adam of Oakland
1966, yeah, ok, you 'da man!
I had to look up the word: Sabot, but yes, wooden clogs: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sabot_(shoe)
I want to think there's also a way of honoring hand craft that is not anachronistic for the pure sentimental aspects, though. I want to say a modern piece or contemporary, or something that is timeless can be brought forth with an empathy that only the hands eyes and wood can discuss. I suppose this is a tiresome subject, lot's of e-ink has spilled.
if i run 8 miles tomorrow on my usual route, i would have broken feet in wooden shoes. there must be a coexistence. please, i will have a computer making TCP/IP communique to a local hub connected to the internet backbone. I will discuss fun topics with colleagues on the internet forums. but save the arts. save the real crafts. spare them from this foggy drape of abstraction and statistical interpolation. or imputation.