New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Books Edited by Bernard E. Jones

Posts

Books Edited by Bernard E. Jones

#1

Books Edited by Bernard E. Jones

William Duffield

I just received The Practical Woodworker (4 volumes), edited by Bernard E. Jones and recently published by Popular Woodworking. I have had a paperback copy of The Complete Woodworker, also edited by Jones and published by Ten Speed Press in 1980. Does anyone know if there is anything in The Complete Woodworker that is not in The Practical Woodworker? If not, I would like to donate "Complete" to my Woodworking Association, as there is no reason for it to take up any room on my bookshelf.

Re: Books Edited by Bernard E. Jones

#2

Re: Books Edited by Bernard E. Jones

Patrick Gibbons

I've got both and believe that your new 4 volume has it all. A quick check of table of contents of both works will confirm it. The 4 volume work is a great reference. Ten Speed Press related they removed parts of the book that were not relevant for today. I have found the "new" sections to be valuable for the techniques discussed and fascinating for the items we don't need in our lives anymore. Some chapters do not provide enough to learn how to do it, or at least not easily. The chapter on carving and the subject of chip carving is one example.

Re: Books Edited by Bernard E. Jones

#3

Re: Books Edited by Bernard E. Jones

William Duffield

Thanks, Patrick. That's what I suspected, it's more the Incomplete Woodworker, or the "Reader's Digest" version (an unwelcome reference around these parts, perhaps). Still, I've gotten lots of useful information from it over the years, even though some of the explanations have been a little briefer than I would have liked. It was definitely a good value at about $2, 17 years or so ago. I will with a clear conscience, pass it on to the beginners who our woodworking club continues to attract.