New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Marking mortices (Part I)

Posts

Marking mortices (Part I)

#1

Marking mortices (Part I)

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Whenever I see photos of someone checking a stretcher for square, it looks like this ...


It looks square, even when you hold it up to the light ...


However, if you reverse the square and measure across the wide side, any error present is magnified and is easier to see ...



Is this degree of accuracy necessary? Well, errors can be additive, and door/panel frames need all the help to end up flat. Anyway, it is better practice to measure for square across the wide side than across the narrow end.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Marking mortices (Part I)

#2

Using a square

Warren in Lancaster, PA

We usually flatten a face side first, so that it is flat in length, flat in width, and out of wind. This is our reference surface. We then true an edge so that it is flat and square to the face. To test for square, we hold the stock of the square against the flat face and check the edge, usually at several places. This allows us to see just how much needs to be taken off to true the edge. In your example, you are holding the stock against the edge, which is not a reference surface, and has not been trued. If you look at the discrepancy on the face side, it does not give as good a picture of what needs to be removed as looking at the discrepancy on the edge directly.

In the case you present, we cannot see the board as well as you. However, it appears from the picture that the face is not flat to begin with. In any case I think the square would rock when held to the board in the traditional way, even if you could not see light under the blade of the square.

Here is what Peter Nicholson, former London cabinetmaker, wrote in 1812:

Re: Marking mortices (Part I)

#3

Re: Using a square

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Warren

No, it is the reference side. The board has been turned around.

Yes, I agree that there appears to be a curve - I'm not sure now if that is real or the camera lens.

I was just trying to demonstrate that we get a truer reading by using the square the other way around. Other than you and I, no one here appears interested. perhaps its a bit too esoretic. Oh well ....

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Marking mortices (Part I)

#4

Re: Using a square

Lars Parrington

Derek, I don't think your idea was new to me, but having read your initial post a few days ago put it fresh in my mind. I made good use of the trick yesterday, while making sure a couple tools (table saw and miter cutter) were set up to cut squarely. It may not have occured to me otherwise, and it was actually a surprisingly big help.

The error was maginified just as you showed, but an even bigger help was that the tongue of the square revealed that my reference faces were not perfectly flat. One reference face had a slight curve to it. In this case, when the stock of the square was referenced off the face, the edge appeared to be out of square. But by reversing the square to reference off the edge, the tongue of the square revealed the slight curve in the face and also that the edge was square to the average of the curve.

So, thanks for posting. I learn a lot from this forum, even though I am not too vocal on it.

Re: Marking mortices (Part I)

#5

Re: Using a square

William Duffield

Well, I cared, but I didn't find anything useful to add to your observations at the time. Warren makes some very good points. On his inspiration, I'll toss a couple more trivial comments at you now: I find it's easy to flip the square and check it both ways. Note also that if you set the heavy head (instead of the lighter blade) on the narrow edge, it is more difficult to balance and register agains the edge, than if you can push the head up against a wider face with all four fingers.

Re: Marking mortices (Part I)

#6

Bevel edge square

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Derek and all,

I thought it a good topic and a good post, but like Sir Wm. did not have much to add at the time.

One particular application where high precision is wanted is edge joining. In that case, I like to see, and see directly and quantitatively, how much light the square is passing. For that reason, I like a small bevel-edge square, especially the Mitutoyo 916-101 (3" x 2") or 916-100 (1-1/2 x 1), which have virtual knife edges. You can always see some light against backlighting, so it is extremely quantitative. With the small square, you can make one pass quickly down the edge and get a mental scan of the entire edge.

Bevel edge squares are always expensive, because you're buying more precision that you need or use for woodworking, and all edges are hardened, but if you can find a deal, they are very fast to use, and yield lots of information.

Wiley

Re: Marking mortices (Part I)

#7

Re: Using a square

david charlesworth

dear Derek,

My second book page 78. shows the advantage of magnification of error, when a small square is used that way.

A small square is easier to hold tight to the edge.

Best wishes,

David Charlesworth

Re: Marking mortices (Part I)

#8

Re: Using a square

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

And there it was David, on pages 78 -9 ...

"... the errors of squareness will be multiplied".

It's been a while since I read this volume, but the concept must have been deeply buried and just taken time to surface in my consciousness!

Regards from Perth

Derek