We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I recently obtained a Stanley Rule and Level No 94, brass bound boxwood 48" fourfold rule, which needs a bit of work. I need some advise on the best practice.
First, the brass alignment pins have gone missing. Where do I find brass wire of the appropriate gauge, and what is the best glue to seat them in the boxwood?
Second, the rule lines and numbers have over the years lost most of their pigments. How best to restore the contrast? What should i use for black pigment, and for a binder? What is the best way to apply it so as not to turn the whole rule black?
I would like to use it as a sector as well as for the typical uses of a rule. (Reference Jim Tolpin and By Hand and Eye, by Lost Art Press for an explanation.) I am not, however at all willing to follow Chris Schwarz recipe to make a sector from a "crappy ruler." Taking direct measurements off of furniture, etc. requires that the inch graduations be extended to and down the inner edge of the rule, and then these new engravings also filled as in item #2, above. What is the best method to extend these graduations?
When I'm done with the new markings, should I lacquer, or shellac, or just wax it?
I can't help with most of the questions, but if you can't find off the shelf wire the size you want, you can get a draw plate to make wire smaller. Wire to be drawn should be annealed, then the end is tapered a bit and pulled through successively smaller holes until the desired gauge is reached. I seem to remember beeswax as the recommended lube, but I don't recall ever using any as I was drawing silver wire - and silver is wonderfully ductile.
The alignment pins in Stanley rules are steel. On my No. 36 the diameter is a little over 1/32" and seems to be within a few thousandths of some 18 gauge music wire I have a supply of.
I'd be happy to send you some of the wire. Drop me an email if you're interested.
No need to send me any wire, Steve, but I thank you anyway. I'll find some that's about the right size, maybe from a wire nail or brad or broken tiny drill bit. There are lots of those in my Dremel kit . Funny that I had assumed it was brass instead of steel. It should be easy to secure it with some hide glue, except I cooked a batch of it this evening, delaying delivery of a restoration of a piece of furniture. The hide glue should also close up the holes that have been widened over the years in the mating boxwood.
"Oxalic acid works particularly well on wooden rules because the numbers were stamped on using India Ink, which is a form of carbon black. As it happens, oxalic acid will not remove or change the color of carbon black. I would worry about using an abrasive like tooth paste on a rule - it might rub some of the India ink off."
and:
"restored with Boraxo and oxalic acid. There was quite a bit of both red and black ink on it as found. I was able to work those stains out without losing any of the calibration inking. I used Renaissance wax afterward and left the brass alone"
I have a copy of Phillip Stanley's Source Book For Rule Collectors and looked up some info for you. The pins were indeed made of steel. To blacken the graduations, first a clear finish was applied to the rule. This was to keep the blacking from staining the surface. Then the graduations and numbers were stamped or cut into the surface. Then a black paste was applied liberally with a brush and wiped away with a soft cloth leaving a residue in the markings. The paste used by the Chapin-Stephens Co. was made of boiled linseed oil mixed with lampblack. The author assumes that other manufacturers used something similar. An article on the sector is reprinted in this volume. The book is published by Astragal Press and may be of interest to you. The construction process is given in detail.
Alignment pins were often removed by users to allow the rule to sit flush on a surface. The holes were delicate and frequently damaged. It appears that no glue was used to lock these in place. A hole was drilled and the pin was installed in a friction fit. When graduations were hand cut, a pattern was placed next to a blank and a tee square used to extend the placement of the cuts which were made with a dividing knife, evidently a tool specific to rule making. Rabone stated a certain one foot rule with 540 lines could be cut in about ten minutes.
I know Incra has some tee rules that might work for you.
I'll look up Phillip Stanley's book. Last weekend, a friend showed me a basket full of ruler in his collection. Evidently, collecting these can be a very dangerous slope. I'll bet he has a copy of Stanley. I wonder how it will complement my book by Jane Rees?
I think I have everything I need to restore the markings and color the new ones. I'll start with a coat of shellac. I don't have lamp black, but I think the vegetable black pigment I do have has very similar properties. I have BLO to bind the pigment, so I should be good to go. The only issue is whether to apply shellac or lacquer as a final top coat.
I did find out one curious property of the manufacturing process. I was trying to remove a couple of spots of very dark corrosion on the hinge. The brass looks like it was polished very finely, but a lot of that is an illusion. The scratch pattern left in the brass is hidden by the clear finish coat, but it showed up very distinctly when I cut through the finish with some 1000 grit SiC paper. It should disappear again when I repatinate the surface and coat it with shellac.
I've been using a well worn grey "ScotchBrite" pad to remove some of the stains. It might instead be a Norton BearTex brand pad. I'll try a little Bar Keeper's Friend, which seems to be mostly oxalic acid and talc, to see if I can lighten up some of the patina on the one surface that is darkest. I suspect the color may be below the finish, however.
I think Patrick has solved all my repair issues. I'll just drop a little hide glue in the pin holes, smooth them off and call it "done."
You may have solved the pin problem perfectly. I've seen a lot more damage done to rules by their pins than damage averted. Maybe more people should have removed the pins from their old rules sooner. I hadn't even considered the damage that could be done if it were being used to measure a piece of finished furniture. Rules that were not bound probably warped more severely and more often than rules bound with brass, and the pins must have helped to keep them square and flat.
I have one of those Incra t-squares, and also one of their protractors, but I use them very seldom, probably because they feel very fragile to me. I built a custom fit box for them and secreted them away in a drawer. "Out of sight; out of mind." I don't think they are as fragile as they appear, as long as they are treated with respect. The thin plate might make it easier to align the extended marks to the existing ones. I also have to think about a saddle square to extend them down the side of the rule.
Now the issue is to figure out the most effective shape for the dividing knife. It might be a little easier to find, now that I know what it is called.
Before starting this enquiry, I forgot to look in my copy of Jane Rees' The Rule Book: Measuring for the Trades. Maybe she has more information in there. I'll report back if I find anything.
On pp 122-123 in Stanley's book is a picture and description of a dividing knife. It comes from a source printed in 1858. The knife is uniquely made to be used with a dividing plate or a dividing square. The description is long and involved and provides enough info to make one if you wish. Let me know if you want a copy of it.
The Rule Book also has information on marking rules, including photos and descriptions of some of the machines that did the job. There's just no description of the shape of the cutting point, so I will have to experiment.
Joel at Tools for Working Wood offers the Phillip Stanley book, at basically the same price as Amazon, when shipping is calculated. What is really surprising is some of the exorbitant prices asked for used copies by other booksellers.
Before I do any experimentation on my No. 94, I have a Stanley Works No. 68 of very little value that I can try techniques on. It works OK as a rule, but wouldn't be accurate enough to use as a sector due to some serious warping. I definitely don't want to mess up the No. 94. According to Walter, it is more valuable than I suspected. It appears I got a good deal on it from the MofA.
Vegetable black, lamp black and carbon black are more or less the same thing. To some extent the difference depends on what organic compounds they started with.
I have "a couple of" projects I have to finish up first, so I'll get back later with photos and progress reports.
You guys have this all solved and I don't pretend to be up on the ruler restoration thing but the metal pin element of joints has fascinated me since I stumbled into using it on a project. At the time it seemed perfect for the application and so I would enjoy adding my thoughts if you can stand it.
Some thoughts :
the measurement of the wire should be on the order of one thousandth or even less (in the realm of ten thousandths.
Glue is not necessary to hold the pins in place. Use what is called in machinist lingo as an "interference fit". Ha, ha, nails are employed this way, albeit in an extreme way, and we all know how well they can stay put and be difficult to remove.
BUT
with more precision and fore thought the wire can become a precision nail
AND
with a well planned and SLIGHT interference fit will stay in place without glue
BY
pressing the pin into place rather than using a hammer.
REMOVED BY
using a strong and slightly smaller pin in a drill press to press out the pressed in pin when required. The PRESS aspect of the drill press is brought into play. You don't turn on the motor just put the pin in the chuck and press over a block with an appropriate hole in it.
For an example this is the way watches and air and other gas gauges are held together. The hands on a watch are just pressed onto a metal shaft (no glue).
You may have seen or even own those sets of drill bits with number designations such as 9, 10, 12 and letters such as A, B, C. That was for this sort of thing.
In wood it is going to be all different and I recommend empirical experimentation. Using the same wood and pins and split a few and see what works best. It might be a case so simple as to spin the side of a drill bit on some abrasive a couple of times to get the diameter you need. I like the idea of more precise measurement and a precisely linear drill bit but that is just my machine tool head talking.
See the following photos for one example that I have photos of already using this press pin construction. Brass in this case but for the ruler steel would require less skill to put in and take out. Brass might be easier to take out later; perhaps less corrosion from moisture.
aaaaaaaaaah yes . . .
that leaves stainless steel pins
That is the modern solution !
PS: see photos . . . the idea here was if and when I need to replace the "sacrificial" top rail on one of these bubinga Krenov saw horses I could just press the pins out etc., but would stay in situ until such time.
PPS: I couldn't help adding a few more photos of the horses. One of my first real fine woodworking projects I turned into an opportunity to explore and practice wedged tenon aesthetics and fool around with different end treatments to the ends of the pins.
Yes, I think that's a little involved for my tastes. I like making simple tools, and improving on tools to make them more useful, but starting from scratch to replicate an old too I can buy is going a bit too far. I should be spending my time on home improvements, building furniture, and even shop improvements.
Patrick, thank you for the offer, but since the book is still in print and being offered for sale by a fellow woodworker, who I know and respect and would like to keep in business, I'm ordering the book from him. Hopefully, a few pennies will get back to the author as well. There's bound to be lots more information in it I will find useful in the future.
Interesting techniques, there, Winton. I have drill bits in Imperial fractions and a few in metric, but I think very few Letter or Number bits: Maybe an "O" for pens and maybe one number bit to match a tap.
Please, don't worry about "hijacking" a thread. It doesn't take most of us long to know whose posts we want to read and whose usually don't provide much useful to our current quest, and those we simply skip or bleep over.
I saved the photos of your beautiful saw trestles, because I need to build a set to complete one of the projects that's high on my list. I think I have already decided to make the upper rail interchangeable, but I think I will need to swap them more quickly than would be practical using a press fit brass rod. I might want to use them with a track saw, and I might need to replace the upper rail with a sling, to hold a canoe or kayak. I won't be afraid to get mine beaten up, since I have some tulip poplar earmarked for them.
I used poplar to make saw benches because I had some in 12/4 and eight years later they're no worse for wear. Plus what once was dark green is now a beautiful chocolate brown.
I pulled some 5/4 and 8/4 tulip poplar down out of the shop loft last night for the specific purpose of making some saw trestles. It's been air drying up there for 3 years. I'm working on a novel design, but I'll need to post it on the power tool side, instead of here, because it relies on a table saw taper jig and extensive use of Festool Dominos to totally avoid any complex (i.e., skillful) joinery. Sometimes, you just need to spend some shop time in relatively brainless stress relief.
I discovered, several years ago, that changing poplar heartwood from green to dark brown required only the application of some Watco Danish oil.
Very curious. I have an 8 oz. tub of very finely ground vegetable black, that I'm sure I bought from one of the top expoxymongers, but Google can't find any reference to it, or to any lampblack or carbon black or vege black in any form but paste. My suspicions are that the State of California declared this stuff "unsafe at any speed". I'm really not surprised, as it is extremely finely ground, and easily airborne, and thus easily inhaled. My paranoia tells me that, if you don't use a respirator when mixing it that you might be at small risk of contracting black lung disease. The same concern might be raised for the colloidal silica epoxy thickener and silicosis. But the exposure I get in my shop is probably well below the threshold needed to cause any symptoms.
The Stanley Rule book should arrive at the local post office this morning.