New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Deep thoughts

Posts

Deep thoughts

#1

Ellis Walentine

Deep thoughts

Ellis Walentine

Tom mentioned in the Compass Plane thread below that Japanese and Western timber framing traditions were functionally much alike. I'd like to explore the similarities of cultural traditions a bit further...

I have been fortunate in my career to have made lasting friendships with some well-known craftsmen from distinctly different cultural traditions – notably Frank Klausz from Hungary and the Eastern European tradition, Toshio Odate from Japan and the Japanese shoji making tradition, and Ian Kirby from England and the English Arts & Crafts tradition – who emigrated from their home countries to the US and carried on those woodworking traditions here.

What these cultural woodworking traditions had in common were their internally consistent philosophies and methods of work. Each had traditional bench styles, tools and techniques, as well as design and aesthetic standards. Ask any of these craftsmen how to accomplish any task in the design/build sequence, and they would tell you exactly how it was done and why; yet, each explanation was different. In other words, they had been taught different ways of reaching the same outcome and all were valid, effective and internally consistent.

The US has been a melting pot of such traditions, and with the rise of woodworking magazines, videos and now web-based instruction, the pure traditions have given way to a more individualized approach to getting to the finished result. Toshio once told me that magazines are like orphans ("a child without a parent") in that there is no thread of consistency running through them. Individual authors espouse totally different ways of doing things, and there is no programmed instruction like in the old days.

In this modern era, with new technologies and priorities, where cultures are no longer isolated from each other, indigenous traditions are already fading into the background. Should we wax nostalgic about this and try to keep the pure traditions alive, or should we distill what we can from all traditions to produce a broader vocabulary of awarenesses and tools and methods?

I guess the question is, where exactly are we going? Or is there a predictable or desirable destination? Seems to me that we all have different things that motivate us: tools, techniques, finished products, and the diverse experiences of the design and creative processes. What will the role of the craftsman be?

I was just curious as to how you all feel about this. It might be a good survey question for an upcoming News & Views column.

Cheers,

Ellis

Re: Deep thoughts

#2

Clint Searl

Re: Deep thoughts

Clint Searl

IMO, there's no end point. The evolution of woodworking is continuous, its operative genes at any time determined by the natural selection of techniques that abet creativity, with a dash of current fashion thrown in. The tree will always have several branches, like Neanderthal, and will likely sprout new ones, like CAD/CAM and 3D printing. The more varied the DNA, the more interesting.

Re: Deep thoughts

#3

Re: Deep thoughts

Brian from Monument

This sounds to me like a form of evolution.

And is ultimately the fault of technology (vhs, dvd, tv etc), travel, and leisure time.

Is it really a fault? Nope, it is fate.

Will individual cultural techniques be preserved well if woodworking goes the way of language, perhaps.

And there are always those pesky electron powered devices.

I will not give up my router,!

nor my table saw

nor my jointer..... Sorry, I forget this was a hand tool area....

I do own chisels and saws of both western and Japanese design.

So my tool usage is already evolving.

I still cannot get used to the Japanese concepts about pulling a plane.

Is that a resistance to culture ?

Do I need to go to some form of cultural learning/reeducation center?

Re: Deep thoughts

#4

craigd

It's all good

craigd

What I really love about this "new age" is that I can learn from all these cultures (and hopefully understand them), to whatever depth I want, and pick and choose what works for me or works "best" to accomplish my goals. Equally important is that these traditions are recorded (to the bottom) before they are lost to homogenization; to my mind, Toshio's writings and the recent Roubo translation are very important. Then anybody, anywhere, can become a faithful practitioner of "lost" arts with the understanding why it is worth doing (which could be a living museum, reconstruction or because it is cool).

Re: Deep thoughts

#5

Re: Deep thoughts

Tom

At some level the Japanese and Western traditions re very different, which one would expect if one saw the products of the work. A lot of the apparent differences came from a variety of variances that are not taken into account. So for instance a lot of the info about Japanese woodworking was driven by timber framers. So one got articles about their unencumbered benches with no vises and so forth. But that is what you see in a western timber shop where there are dozens of hefty horses supporting the timbers as the joints are assembled and fitted. The variations appeared greater because the Japanese timber methods were being compared to Western cabinet traditions. There still isn't a figure over here that I am aware of who represents the methods of Japanese cabinetmakers, or musical instrument makers, etc...

The Japanese benches are very similar to Roubo, or sticking benches that similar window makers used over here.

I think our methods are evolving along a puttering line. There are certain activities that get disproportionate treatment. Like a certain cut in the smoothing process, but little work is done on roughing out. The recent trend towards all hand tool woodworking has pushed back a lot on that, and we have interesting new directions as a result.[

Tools grow up around a range of cultural interests, but in our case there is no collective goal that demands a certain approach, and in many cases the tools are the end in themselves.

Re: Deep thoughts

#6

Re: Deep thoughts

don stephan

Your primary point has great merit. Take rough milling from one culture, building the frame from another, making drawers from another, and mounting the table top from another, and there may be many workarounds and inherent problems all yielding a less desirable finished table.

Re: Deep thoughts

#7

Re: Deep thoughts

Edward in Vancouver

It's a very good subject, and one that merits a lot of discussion.

From 1985-1988 I was "indoctrinated" in the Swiss trades apprenticeship system--but as a cook, not a woodworker. The apprenticeships in Europe are part of the Federal educational system, but more importantly each trade has a big say in the curriculum for apprentices of that trade. In my case, I knew that each apprenticed Swiss Cook--regardless if they spoke French, German, or Italian, could produce, say Vichy Carrots, or Sliced Veal Zurich Style in a fairly consistent manner; each with minor variations, but on the whole more or less the same. The goal of the apprenticeship was to give the apprentice the tools--the techniques and knowledge, so they could freely create whatever they needed to create.

Thing is, most of the woodworkers I know of are not professional--that is they do not earn their bread and butter from woodworking, they do it as a hobby.

So is there a "right way" and a "wrong way" of doing things? For me in woodworking, there isn't. Dovetailing a blanket chest for my daughter by hand may be right for me currently, but using a router jig to dovetail 24-odd kitchen drawers is a right way as well if I were to rely on woodworking for my bread and butter.

Re: Deep thoughts

#8

Re: It's all good

Tom

I think it is all good in the same way that a donut, a pizza, a cup of coffee, and a Mars are all good, compared to an integrated cuisine like French cooking. And I say that as a consumer of all but the last thing in the sentence. It's mostly just grazing, there is no understanding etc... without a little discipline. But then why should we have pretentious objectives for our personal enjoyment.

At a cultural level I rarely believe anything I hear. I don't think most people have a clue how the tools work, and when I go to museums, I see blades put in planes backwards. Even if one looks at Odate's book, it was vivid on the personal and not all that much more than encyclopaedic on the rest. If you look at Roubo, the main message taken up seems to be that to do heart surgery, you should first equip yourself with a dentist's chair.

Also, as far as the Japanese stuff is concerned. A) There are Japanese texts that have yet to be translated into english, I think they may play a larger role, but I don't speak Japanese... ; B) They still have all these crafts actively. Predictions abound that they are on their way out, and this has been predicted for 30 years. It may be happening, but their craft culture is not all in the past.

Re: Deep thoughts

#9

Great post Ellis

Ron Harper

Wow. This is a very deep area of discussion. I very much resonate with the quote from Odate. I believe the magazines are like orphans. I think Chris Schwarz tried to do some consistency at PWW for a while. But it was tough to do. I am an older guy, recently retired who has gotten rid of his power tools and gone hand tool for a whole lot of reasons. I see no particular virtue in that. It is a matter of preference and an adaptation to a heslth issue in my family. I have come to very much appreciate Mr. Sellers. He is consistent. He knows why he does things the way he does them. He, like Chris Schwarz advocates hand tools as a very sensible way to create beautiful pieces of furniture. They both use power tools. They do not have to do so. Their message that is very often overlooked is that a person who wants to create beautiful, useful pieces of furniture does not have to invest thousands of dollars in machinery to get it done. I very much enjoy watching Tom Fidgen work. There is a method to the way he builds furniture that is beautiful to watch. I can learn much from him.

Yes, power tools can save time, particularly in a production shop. Yes, there are things we can do with hand tools that piwer tools can not replicate. One of the most delightful parts of all of this is that there are at least half a dozen methods for hand cutting dovetails. They all work very well. Pick one and do it.

Re: Deep thoughts

#10

Choke Me In The Shallow Waters Before I get Too

Winton Applegate

. . . Deep . . . don't let me get too deep.

(from the song What I Am by EDIE BRICKELL & NEW BOHEMIANS)

First off let me say I approve of the company you keep. (or you could sub in there "am jealous" in place of "approve").

Second I think it is an awful shame the traditional teaching channels are all but gone.

In the same breath I will never be able to be an apprentice to one of the masters.

From reading how it was for Mr. Odate and Mr. Klausz I am not sure I would have the fortitude to survive it.

Personally, having always taught myself nearly anything I want to learn from books and magazines, I am used to the melting pot of methods. I suppose the way I go about it would be on the order of Bruce Lee's systemless system :

favoring the use of techniques from various sources

put all methods to rigorous test

toss out what sounds good but doesn't work well in practice, or in combat as it were.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tDl3bdE3YQA

Re: Deep thoughts

#11

Somebody Is Paying Attention

Winton Applegate

If you look at Roubo, the main message taken up seems to be that to do heart surgery, you should first equip yourself with a dentist's chair.

Thank you for that.

I thought it was just me.

Re: Deep thoughts

#12

Re: Deep thoughts

Don Slaughter

Great topic, Ellis. Those elite folks you mentioned were dedicated craftsmen who gave their lives to the craft. Although there continue to be such dedicated craftsmen the majority of consumers of magazines and tools are not. I, for one, am a retired therapist who always wanted to build stuff out of wood but, after high school shop class, was whisked away to the army then to a wife & family to provide for and no time to indulge in MY passion...until I retired. Norm & Roy inspired me to start making things for my kids & grandkids. The rags sold me a lot of stuff I'll never need but I have evolved into a decent craftsman with a fairly sophisticated appreciation of what counts. Brian Boggs, Russ Filbeck and others are teaching & promoting American heritage crafts. Hand tool use & appreciation is being revived and the venue of woodworking is thriving. The 'thread of consistency' is the market which is too diverse to be parented by a single cultural foundation. Woodworking means something different to each of us....thus it has many meanings...and our numbers are growing exponentially.

Re: Deep thoughts

#13

Re: Deep thoughts

charlie belden

Ellis posed this question:

I guess the question is, where exactly are we going? Or is there a predictable or desirable destination? Seems to me that we all have different things that motivate us: tools, techniques, finished products, and the diverse experiences of the design and creative processes. What will the role of the craftsman be?

I think the answer has to do with the terms Craftsman, Artisan and Artist.

The craftsman of the past made a living exclusiively from his/her skills and reputation in a given market, selling his/her knowledge, skills and expeprience in making spepcific things - to a client. Usually the craftsman had a repetoire of things they'd been trained to make - a few types of chairs a few types of dressers, a few types of tables, etc.. The type of wood and finishes and perhaps small details might vary but the joinery and construction would be basically the same from piece to piece. The client dictated the what was to be made and the craftsman made it as specified. The carftsman was, to a large extent, bound by "tradition" - "a Right Way that is The ONLY Way". As Ellis noted, "the Right Way" could vary from culture to culture, each method resulting in the same functiona;ity, but different means of getting there.

The artisan of the past also made a living exclusively from his or here skills, reputation, etc. BUT had more leeway in how a piece was to be made and, to a greater extent than the craftsman, more leeway in how the piece would look. The artisan didn't limit himself or herself to his or her existing repetoire and was free to explore other methods of construction as well as the look of the piece. The artisan was more open to developing new techniques and the use of new tools, than was the craftsman.

The artist is often more speculative than the craftsman or artisan, the latter working for a client, the artist working with no specific client in mind and no specifications to be constrained by. Of the three, craftsman, artisan and artist, the artist is the most open to trying new things - new suject matter, new materials, new techniques - in general - new ideas. Artists push the boundaries of what was "acceptable". At the time, they were, and are, the prototypical Starving Artists and what they create may not be appreicated, or highly valued - until after they've been dead for a decade or two ; )

It's the artist that pushes, or pulls the artisan and craftsman to grow beyond what they already know how to do.

Now if you put the word "hobbyist" or "amateur" in front of "craftsman", or "artisan" or "artist" - well all bets are off. Some will work as if they were in the 17th century while others may try to work in the 22nd century. They differ from the more limited definitions or craftsman, artisan and artis - because making money is not their motivation.

As to Where is This All Going? - as knowledge spreads more people will use that knowledge - and some will expand that knowledge. And the more people actually MAKE tangible things ( as opposed to "financial instruments" - like "derivatives" - the more diverse the "crafts" will become - or not.