Deep thoughts
Ellis Walentine
Tom mentioned in the Compass Plane thread below that Japanese and Western timber framing traditions were functionally much alike. I'd like to explore the similarities of cultural traditions a bit further...
I have been fortunate in my career to have made lasting friendships with some well-known craftsmen from distinctly different cultural traditions – notably Frank Klausz from Hungary and the Eastern European tradition, Toshio Odate from Japan and the Japanese shoji making tradition, and Ian Kirby from England and the English Arts & Crafts tradition – who emigrated from their home countries to the US and carried on those woodworking traditions here.
What these cultural woodworking traditions had in common were their internally consistent philosophies and methods of work. Each had traditional bench styles, tools and techniques, as well as design and aesthetic standards. Ask any of these craftsmen how to accomplish any task in the design/build sequence, and they would tell you exactly how it was done and why; yet, each explanation was different. In other words, they had been taught different ways of reaching the same outcome and all were valid, effective and internally consistent.
The US has been a melting pot of such traditions, and with the rise of woodworking magazines, videos and now web-based instruction, the pure traditions have given way to a more individualized approach to getting to the finished result. Toshio once told me that magazines are like orphans ("a child without a parent") in that there is no thread of consistency running through them. Individual authors espouse totally different ways of doing things, and there is no programmed instruction like in the old days.
In this modern era, with new technologies and priorities, where cultures are no longer isolated from each other, indigenous traditions are already fading into the background. Should we wax nostalgic about this and try to keep the pure traditions alive, or should we distill what we can from all traditions to produce a broader vocabulary of awarenesses and tools and methods?
I guess the question is, where exactly are we going? Or is there a predictable or desirable destination? Seems to me that we all have different things that motivate us: tools, techniques, finished products, and the diverse experiences of the design and creative processes. What will the role of the craftsman be?
I was just curious as to how you all feel about this. It might be a good survey question for an upcoming News & Views column.
Cheers,
Ellis



