Re: index finger on closed tote
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Steve and all,
I agree with Sir Wm. Pointing is good with sawing too.
Specifically to your question about grip, I had to go pull out a couple of closed tote woodies to see what I do, and why. I tested with a C&W try plane and fore plane. Herewith the results....
1. Curling the finger over. You mentioned it being natural to want to curl your finger over the top. Like this, maybe...
http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/10250300263/in/set-72157635030917606
When I first picked up the try plane or the fore plane, holding it up with elbow bent at 90 degrees or so--like you do when you just pick something up to look at it--I also let my forefinger cross over the top. It seemed natural. The reason I think is that the whole hand is making a curl--the little finger is curled around, all the fingers want to curl together.
But things change when I put the planes on the bench in planing position. Now I'm not holding the weight of the plane--the bench is supporting the plane, and I'm going to push it, which is different. As I get ready to plane, the hand shifts to this position, a two-finger grip. Now the little finger and index finger want to be straight together, the two middle fingers around the tote:
http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/10250268763/in/set-72157635030917606/
[The hand looks a bit distorted in these photos because i'm twisted around trying to take a picture of the left hand with camera (phone) in right hand.]
2. Bench height and tote shape. I tested all this on two benches, one at 29-1/2" height; one at 36" height (I'm 5'11"), and got the same result: I always want to use the two-finger grip for planing, with little finger and index finger straight. I also checked one of Konrad Sauer's panel planes, which has a higher tote and room for fingers, and got the same result.
On lower benches, and especially if the plane has a longish horn, there's no option. You can't curl your fingers, because the lower bench height and prominent horn are breaking your wrist! But even on the 36" bench, where there was no wrist/handcurl fight going on, I still wanted to point the index and little fingers.
In summary, test the matter on your bench with another plane that you already use. What do you actually do? In answering this, consider what kind of horn you're going to put on the tote of the fore plane.
Hope this helps!
Wiley