New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

I hope you can fix stupid!

Posts

I hope you can fix stupid!

#1

I hope you can fix stupid!

Ron Harper

A little embarrassed to admit that I am just now putting together the toy box that we talked about months ago. I am a multitasking procrastinator. I can put off several projects at the same time.

Finally at it. Corner one joined.. Dovetails not too bad. Started on back so that by the time I got to the front they would be fair. These will clean up after glue up and a little planing.

Corner two tails and pins cut. Looks like a slight improvement. Cut the slight champhers on the tails ON THE WRONG FACE of the board. Now, that actually would not be a problem if my layout and execution of the joint had been perfectly symmetrical. How you likin those odds?

What to do? Trimmed the tails so they went together as a gappy joint.

Well a girly girl's toy box needs decorative moulding on the corners, doesn't it? Sure does now.

A photo would be unnecessary self- flagellation

Re: I hope you can fix stupid!

#2

Re: I hope you can fix stupid!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Ron and all,

I do stuff like that. Like today, I was gluing a piece of inlay into a leg post; on small parts, i like to just dip them right into the gluepot, bring them out dripping and press them into place. On this particular piece, I had to shift it in my hands to get it wet all over, and then, and then....Oh no's, I lost my reference, which side is which? Which is up and which down? Well, I got lucky--my first try worked, but it was pure luck.

Here's the most important thing I've learned (speaking just for myself) about hand tool work, and hand methods. There are very few things you will do which can actually ruin your project. There's almost always a fix, and a good fix too, one that won't be seen and is structurally sound. To me, this is a great relief, don't have to work in fear of a mistake. Plus, hand tool mistakes are made at slow speed, not at 14,000 rpm.

On your toy box project, molding is not a bad idea anyway. But fill those tail gaps with carefully prepared slices of veneer taken from offcuts of the same wood--if you have sawed the tail waste, you could even look on the floor and find some adjacent wood that's an exact grain/color match. Glue those veneer slices in there. If you're able to match wood, you may be able to conceal it perfectly. If not, you've restored structure, and the molding will be just fine.

Wiley

Re: I hope you can fix stupid!

#3

Re: I hope you can fix stupid!

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Ron

Been there and done that!

I assume that the ends are not symmetrical to allow you to flip the boards? So, if the chamfers are shallow, it may be possible to fit and glue the ends together, and then plane the joint until the chamfer is removed. This will result in a tapered end - which you can say is a design feature! :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: I hope you can fix stupid!

#4

Re: I hope you can fix stupid!

Lars Parrington

aren't you planning to paint this chest? just fill the mistakes with wood putty.

Re: I hope you can fix stupid!

#5

Re: I hope you can fix stupid!

Tom

I think what might have worked would have been to join all the corners, then run a scallop over the dovetails so that just the dovetails would be reduced in height, all around, by the degree of the bevels. This if done elegantly would add an interesting detail. If I haven't got the right end of the problem, there are always ways around it. You can be sure that most decorative elements probably started up for some similar reason.

Another option would be to cut open and redo two of the corner's assuming Barbie would still fit inside.

The bigger lesson is to suck it up when mistakes happen and if necessary start again. All the work that goes into covering up an error, all the work that still remains to be done. And for what? To get something you didn't want in the first place. Something people are all going to have to pretend is "great" for the rest of time. It is part of maturing in a craft. It may even cause a scar deep enough that one doesn't make similar mistakes.

It has always been accepted that fixing mistakes is part of being a great craftsman. Even if one never makes mistakes they crop up in stock, or the work of people around one, or in repairs. But the objective of invisibly fixing stuff without breaking step should not affect results. If something goes wrong with my boat project, I can fix almost anything, but it has to be in a way where it isn't going to break way offshore.

People sometimes wonder why they can't shoot the arrow in a 10 ring consistently, or bag the big buck. Well there are only hits or misses, if you have a huge degree of satisfaction in almosts, that is what you get. If you don't pass on the little bucks, it will take an act of god to get you a trophy.

I am a frequent advocate for the idea of learning through practice not projects. This is really excellent advice, that I don't expect anyone to actually follow (at least not in woodworking). But when something goes wrong (and it isn't an actual eureka discovery of an even better outcome) you can write off the losses as just being practice. If a person won't do the practice then maybe the next best thing is to convert errors to practice. So ends the sermonizing.