New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Climate differences affecting drawer fit

Posts

Climate differences affecting drawer fit

#1

Climate differences affecting drawer fit

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi all,

I live in inland So. Calif. Some things I make will likely end up in San Francisco, near the ocean. It's dry down here. I have made tight-fitting drawers. Won't say piston fit, but planed down to just enough clearance to slide. Say, less than 1/64" clearance any side. After some years, these drawers haven't moved perceptibly, and they give no problems.

But what about San Francisco? It's colder and wetter seasonally up there, and more ambient humidity most of the time. I don't know how to ask the question, because if a piece is made up there, with wood equalized to the weather, and stays there, that's different than a piece acclimatized to the dry and later moved up there.

Anyone have any insight as to how much clearance a drawer made in the dry might need, in order not to get stuck shut in SF?

Thanks in advance,

Wiley

Re: Climate differences affecting drawer fit

#2

Re: Climate differences affecting drawer fit

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I made a side table for my daughter, mostly built in the spring. Here in MN, there are wide seasonal swings in humidity. IIRC, I made the drawer with a bit less than 1/16" clearance. Around the middle of July, she complained that she couldn't get the drawer open, neither could I, until I removed the top and applied force from a Stanley WonderBar. That's what it took.

I took off another 1/32" from the drawer sides and she's never had another problem. I guess that amounts to somewhere between 1/16" and 3/32" total.

Re: Climate differences affecting drawer fit

#3

Re: Climate differences affecting drawer fit

Tom

So this is basically two questions. One is how much accommodation would the drawer need seasonally in SF. And the other is where do you make it so it is in the middle of that slot.

I'm sure many are better able to answer the first. The second, I do by making the piece in the neutral environment. That is what we do with guitars. Whatever the humidity number is for the median, that is where I store parts when I am not working on the parts. I have a range of humidity in my basement, my shop, and in the upper shop, or attic, so normally I can find some place for the parts to rest.

Obviously with drawers, even hand finished fancy ones, there are many different ways to build in order to take into account these kinds of problem. The box in a box method leaves the least room for movement.

Re: Climate differences affecting drawer fit

#4

Re: Climate differences affecting drawer fit

Steve Elliott

There's information in Bruce Hoadley's book Understanding Wood that can help you calculate the clearance needed. At the beginning of chapter 5 a couple of maps of the US show the moisture content of interior woodwork in January and July. For San Francisco it looks like the MC reaches about 12% in July. You can measure the current MC of the furniture at your location. In chapter 4 there's a formula for estimating dimensional change based on the wood species, grain orientation, and change in moisture content.

That's a geeky answer but it might be better than guessing, which is the only alternative I can think of.

Re: Climate differences affecting drawer fit

#5

Nickel and dime

Bob Lang

Here in Ohio we have a pretty good swing in humidity, so I leave different gaps in summer (our most humid season) and winter (our dryest). I was taught to use a nickel or a dime and that works pretty well.

Bob Lang

Re: Climate differences affecting drawer fit

#6

Re: Climate differences affecting drawer fit

Bruce McCrory

I am in the Puget Sound area of WA. Even in the drought cycle of summer we are looking at 40% humidity, plus. It's always mystifying to see the gauges posting 98% and higher during sunny weather. After a week of rain, and 7-inches in three days, our humidity should be at the high end; as should be wood expansion.

I have a rock maple desk that was locked into glue and screws nearly 30 years ago, after it was dragged home in a hundred warped pieces. Dust panels and drawer floors were all glued. So movement affects everything.

The center guide rails for the drawers currently have about .065 to 3/32 slop. However, a lot of this slop can be due to the conditions present during the rebuild. For fit, I did sand and scrape these guides at the time.

The case sides are 9.5" clear--solid glued boards--and the drawer walls are approximately 9.25" wide. These are fitted drawers. The face reveals have been trimmed periodically to a snug fit at present.

The guide rails control the gross drawer movement and the lipped face edges conceal the horizontal slop to about 1/16th (minus) gap exposure. I notice that one of the dovetail joints is loose.

The wood bottom-center guides are really the best way to handle extreme movement. Sliding drawer boxes on the dust/case rails can be real sloppy. Some of the drawers are missing guides, and were no fun to deal with during the break-in, tune, period. They hold less used items.

San Francisco is most likely drier than here but I would adjust drawer design and action to accommodate looser fit.

One of the frustrating things about SF Bay area is its variability in climate, based on elevation above the bay. Hoadley, as noted by Steve, is your better bet for calculating clearances. But add a bit of looseness. AND, be sure to factor it between your two varying locales.

You may be used to snug fits in drawers and cabinet doors, but us "duck people" are adjusted to loose, and snug, conditions.

Re: Climate differences affecting drawer fit

#7

Ellis Walentine

Lots of operators here

Ellis Walentine

Hi Wiley,

I try to find out the highest and lowest MC of typical furniture in the destination household over a typical year. Local outdoor climate isn't the only factor, either, as some households are climate controlled. And, occasionally there is variation in typical average high and low MC.

Anyhow, armed with decent estimates of high and low expected MC, and the MC of the wood right now as you're making the piece, and shrinkage coefficients of the parts of the piece that will affect drawer fit, you can predict the finish dimension of those pieces at the extremes of their annual MC swings. If your wood is drier than it will be in SF in summer, you'll need to size your pieces so they will give you the desired clearances when they are at that maximum annual MC. Individual pieces of wood and the way they are cut (flatsawn, quartersawn, etc.) may also move differently in the course of a year.

Compounding (or confounding) the calculation further, shrinkage is not only related to humidity and species, but also to how the parts are finished, as any finish that retards moisture transfer acts as a buffer to the timeline of moisture exchange. Heavily finished wood may not get a chance to acclimate to maximum humidity before the humidity has begun its backward progression toward minimum MC.

There's also a diminishing of the annual dimensional variation over the first couple years after you make the piece. In other words, the annual swings are greater in year 1, lesser in year 2 and 3, and tend to even out after that.

Sorry for the longwinded reply. The upshot for me would be to try to use quartersawn wood for the drawer if possible, of a species that isn't known to have wild dimensional swings within the range of expected annual MC change, and build for the wettest part of the year.

Ellis

Re: Climate differences affecting drawer fit

#8

Re: Climate differences affecting drawer fit

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think the most important variable is the height of the drawer. The width of the drawer changes little with humidity swings, but expansion across the grain is what makes drawers stick. A drawer that is 2 inches high will change in height only about a third as much as one that is 6 inches high. 1/64 might be fine for a little drawer that is one inch high; 1/16 might be needed for a 5 or 6 inch drawer. I also think that esthetically a larger drawer does not look bad with a gap that would look awkward on a very small drawer.

Re: Climate differences affecting drawer fit

#9

Re: Climate differences affecting drawer fit

don stephan

It might be geeky but Bruce Hoadley's presentation on seasonal moisture content and how to calculate corresponding wood movement is a great resource for every woodworker. Careers, plans, and sometimes inheritances relocate furniture in ways never intended. I remember an article by Chris Becksvoort that applied Hoadley's data to a theoretical drawer made in Maine in the humid season and shipped to the driest part of Arizona.

Re: Climate differences affecting drawer fit

#10

Re: Climate differences affecting drawer fit

Robin Corell in Atascadero,CA

the weather where I live is similar to the inland empire, maybe even a bit less humid. Several years ago I made an eight drawer jewelry box that I took to a show in Bellevue, WA. It was fine for the duration of the show but a week after I returned home several of the drawers were a bit sticky. I re-fit the drawers and a week later I took it to San Francisco for a three day show where I sold it. I had to bring it home so I could crate it and ship it to Hawaii. Again after a week in my ship the same drawers became sticky. I fixed it and sent it to it's new home with a very detailed explanation of what happened and a plea to be notified of they ever had any problems. I saw the clients two years later and the has never been another problem.

The carcass was made out of camphor, the drawer fronts were claro walnut and the secondary wood was red alder.

Robin

Re: Climate differences affecting drawer fit

#11

Re: Climate differences affecting drawer fit

Bruce McCrory

From experience, it is a lot easier to shave the top/bottom of a drawer than the sides.

You can always use sheet metal drawers... 8) :) :D ;)

Re: Climate differences affecting drawer fit

#12

Agree...

John in NM

The one time I had trouble with a drawer swelling in it was the height that did it. Drawer sides were white pine too :D

I recently made a part out of maple burl and sent it to the customer in Washington state, on the coast. Fit was fairly precise over a 9" part, and by the time it got there it was too large. But the swell was only 1/16" maybe a bit more, over a 9" length....