New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Rabbet plane recommendation

Posts

Rabbet plane recommendation

#1

Rabbet plane recommendation

Jason Gangl

Hello, I'm new here and was referred to this site by a member of another forum of which I belong. I am considering a small 3/8" bullnose rabbet plane for some fine tuning on a project. I am looking at a Clifton and a veritas from lee valley. I own a few veritas planes and blades and am happy with their quality and performance. I don't own any Clifton planes and have never used any either. I have heard that the fit and finish may leave something to be desired, although their plane looks easier to adjust than the veritas. Any opinions would be appreciated.



Re: Rabbet plane recommendation

#2

Re: Rabbet plane recommendation

Christopher Fitch Memphis

Greetings,

I don't have any of the Veritas planes you list though I do have a number of their other shoulder planes and other planes. I do have the Clifton 400 (actually I have a complete set of Clifton Bench/Shoulder planes except for the 77).

The only other plane I have similar to the Clifton 400 is Lie Nielsen Bronze 1/2 inch shoulder plane.

Here's some answers and thoughts on your post:

- I've heard of Clifton fit/finish issues but I've just not seen them and I have 11 of their planes. The only thing I ever saw was an issue with the casting on my #6. One side wall was slightly thicker than the other but the thinner side wall was still very thick and that plane was listed on sale as having a defect. I don't think you will have any issues on that front.

- I can't imagine the Veritas planes are difficult to use or adjust. Veritas works hard on performance including ease of use.

- I'd not buy the Clifton 400 - my issue: the mouth is too small. On my copy, to get any projection on the blade basically requires that the blade is fills the mouth. In contrast, the Lie Nielsen does not have this issue. The mouth is sufficiently open enough to allow for plenty of blade projection. Now this just might be my copy and I could take a thin file and open the mouth some. I doubt the Veritas has this issue.

My advice: buy the 3/8" Veritas - if you are not satisfied, return it within 3 months.

Hope this helps...

Re: Rabbet plane recommendation

#3

Re: Rabbet plane recommendation

Jason Gangl

Thanks christopher for your input. I was leaning toward the Clifton just because the instructions on the veritas say to use a small flat screwdriver to pry on the side of the blade to advance it, which seems like a pain.

Re: Rabbet plane recommendation

#5

Re: Rabbet plane recommendation

Jason Gangl

I've got a few high spots on some drawer fronts. They overlay the carcass about 3/16" all the way around and the drawers don't sit flush because of the high spots.

Re: Rabbet plane recommendation

#6

Re: Rabbet plane recommendation

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I've got a few high spots on some drawer fronts. They overlay the carcass about 3/16" all the way around and the drawers don't sit flush because of the high spots.

Hi Jason

Are you referring to a lipped front drawer, that is, one that is rebated all the way around at the rear of the drawer face?

If so, then my choice would be a shoulder plane, not a bullnose plane. The shoulder plane has the nose area for registration. Consider the Veritas Small Shoulder plane (1/2" wide blade) or the LN small bronze infill (also 1/2" wide blade).

Here is the LN (front left) and Veritas (front right) ...


... with a review of the Veritas: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/VeritasSmallShoulderPlane.html

On the other hand, assuming that you are describing the outer face of the drawer and not a rebated drawer front ...

I would use a smoothing plane or a block plane with a higher cutting angle (which will act as a small smoother).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Rabbet plane recommendation

#7

Re: Rabbet plane recommendation

Patrick Gibbons

I agree with Derek's recommendation. I have a Veritas and have had a Stanley. A good shoulder plane will handle your situation and many others. I had a Veritas bull nose and used it very infrequently. A shoulder will work in most situations, providing better registration to the surface.

Re: Rabbet plane recommendation

#8

Re: Rabbet plane?

William Duffield

The planes on which you are seeking recommendations are not rabbit planes; they are shoulder planes. Rabbet plane blades are bevel down, while shoulder planes are bevel up and usually have a much lower cutting angle, optimized specifically for trimming end grain. Rabbet planes are generally optimized to be used with the grain. Rabbet planes are often equipped with additional "bells and whistles," including fences, depth stops, nickers and skewed blades. The only useful "whistle" I've found on a shoulder plane is a removable nose on the Veritas bull nose shoulder plane. Yes, I know you can remove the nose of other bull nose shoulder planes, but this doesn't make them useful, IMHO. I also understand you are not considering this plane, probably because of the width of the blade.

Let's consider some attributes that are not so obvious from the advertising copy. First, the Clifton's body is cast iron, which is brittle. If you have a concrete shop floor, and any tendency towards the "dropsies," you would be much better off with the Veritas, which is ductile iron, and will not break on collision with concrete, or granite or tile. Also, the Veritas brass lever cap is much more durable than the wooden Clifton. I have more confidence in the steel in the Veritas blades, and in the precision of Veritas casting, machining, hardening and quality control, but since the Clifton planes are still made in Sheffield, that opinion is subjective, to say the least.

It appears to me that the method of blade adjustment on the Veritas vs. the Clifton are equivalent. Neither should be any easier or more difficult to adjust than the other. (This simplification is not applicable to the larger Veritas shoulder planes, whose adjustment mechanisms are unsurpassed in the industry.)

Do you really need a bullnose plane? You still need a paring chisel to get into the corner of your joint, and the very short nose makes it much more difficult to start your cut and to keep the bottom of the joint flat.

Obviously, price is the easiest comparison to make. The Veritas plane you are considering indisputably wins this point.

OTOH, Have you considered this one?

http://www.leevalley.com/us/wood/page.aspx?p=64300&cat=1,41182,68490

The blade is only 1/4" wide, and it is not a bull nose, but you have not described your specific applications, so it is difficult to judge whether it would suit your needs. I have one of these, and I can assure you it is completely functional. I also have several other shoulder planes, including Veritas, Lie-Nielsen and Record. IMHO, the Veritas are the highest quality and the best value for their applications.

Re: Rabbet plane recommendation

#9

Rabbet (rebate) planes

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Jason and all,

First of all, welcome to the forum! We hope to see more of you.

I agree with Wm. If you have a shoulder plane already, use it. If you don't have one, this is a good excuse to get one. They are very useful, and for many more things than shaving tenon shoulders (see below on this point).

Part of the equation here is how much money you're comfortable spending at this point. Small shoulder planes cost from $165 for the Lie Nielsen model here,

http://www.lie-nielsen.com/catalog.php?grp=1406

to $179 for the Lee Valley Veritas model here,

http://www.leevalley.com/US/Wood/page.aspx?p=63847&cat=1,41182,41192&ap=1

The medium shoulder planes run from $189 for the LV Veritas, to $195 for the Lie Nielsen.

If you are trying to get out pretty much unscathed financially at this point, Wm. Duffield's suggestion of the LV miniature might be the way to go, since LV is essentially giving that plane away. I wonder if they are covering direct production cost on it.

However. A substantial advantage of a small or medium shoulder plane over either the Clifton 400 or the LV miniature is length. Patrick cited longer registration. A further point related to registration is that the shoulder plane has enough registration in front of the mouth that you will maintain squareness at the corner in case you are starting your cut there. A plane like the bullnose Clifton or bullnose Veritas gives you virtually zero registration ahead of the blade, so that you're feeling for registration as you start the cut, and it is a high-risk operation to start a pass at a corner, a bet one is likely to lose. Yes, you can arrange to make all cuts exit at the corner, but that has it's own issues, chiefly the chance of splintering at the exit point on the cross-grain passes (translate: stop work, glue the splinter back, cleanup--takes an hour and half to fix, if you can find the splinter and it's intact.)

For most hobbyist woodworkers, meaning most of us here, a shoulder plane can double as a rebate plane. It will get into the same corners, and with a lot of precision. The shoulder plane is not designed like the higher-angle rebate for shaving clearance or wood removal--it's forte is taking precision fine cuts. But most of the time, it'll do just fine for the task at hand. And there are fitting situations where you do need a trimming plane, such as making cabinet doors fit, where you do want the longer registration, including registration ahead of the blade. For example, a two-door cabinet, like this one,

http://wwworkbench.com/cms/index.php?name=coppermine&file=displayimage&meta=lastalb&cat=10007&pos=2

where the double doors close on each other, with a rebate on each door edge. As a second example, some cabinet doors require rebates on the hinge side or all-round--another close-fitting situation. Shoulder plane is good for these situations.

All in all, if you don't have a shoulder plane, it would be a sensible thing to have for your current project and future ones, provided the wallet is willing. If money is tight, Wm. Duffield's suggestion of the LV miniature is there for you, and if things are really tight, there are lower-tech solutions for the current problem that we haven't talked about yet.

Wiley

Re: Rabbet plane recommendation

#10

Re: Rabbet plane?

Jason Gangl

Thanks for all the info. I think I've talked myself into a LN small shoulder plane. Of course that's the easy part, selling the SWMBO on the idea will prove much more challenging.

Re: Rabbet plane recommendation

#11

Do you have a birthday coming up?


Re: Rabbet plane recommendation

#12

my wife says I am 14 birthdays ahead


Re: Rabbet plane recommendation

#13

Aren't planes the in gifts FOR wives this year 


Re: Rabbet plane recommendation

#14

Re: Aren't planes the in gifts FOR wives this year

Steve Voigt

Honey, I got you a plow plane for your birthday, but I'll just leave it in the garage where we can both use it. :D

Re: Rabbet plane recommendation

#15

Re: Aren't planes the in gifts FOR wives this year

Patrick Gibbons

Of course then it's like that episode of The Simpsons where Homer gets Marge a bowling ball and she takes lessons from a bowling instructor who tries to seduce her. I will refrain from making plow plane jokes...

Re: Rabbet plane recommendation

#16

Re: Rabbet plane recommendation

Tony - Memphis

I have the Clifton 410. I have been using it for several years now and I really like it. I've had no issues with it at all.

Tony