Rabbet (rebate) planes
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Jason and all,
First of all, welcome to the forum! We hope to see more of you.
I agree with Wm. If you have a shoulder plane already, use it. If you don't have one, this is a good excuse to get one. They are very useful, and for many more things than shaving tenon shoulders (see below on this point).
Part of the equation here is how much money you're comfortable spending at this point. Small shoulder planes cost from $165 for the Lie Nielsen model here,
http://www.lie-nielsen.com/catalog.php?grp=1406
to $179 for the Lee Valley Veritas model here,
http://www.leevalley.com/US/Wood/page.aspx?p=63847&cat=1,41182,41192&ap=1
The medium shoulder planes run from $189 for the LV Veritas, to $195 for the Lie Nielsen.
If you are trying to get out pretty much unscathed financially at this point, Wm. Duffield's suggestion of the LV miniature might be the way to go, since LV is essentially giving that plane away. I wonder if they are covering direct production cost on it.
However. A substantial advantage of a small or medium shoulder plane over either the Clifton 400 or the LV miniature is length. Patrick cited longer registration. A further point related to registration is that the shoulder plane has enough registration in front of the mouth that you will maintain squareness at the corner in case you are starting your cut there. A plane like the bullnose Clifton or bullnose Veritas gives you virtually zero registration ahead of the blade, so that you're feeling for registration as you start the cut, and it is a high-risk operation to start a pass at a corner, a bet one is likely to lose. Yes, you can arrange to make all cuts exit at the corner, but that has it's own issues, chiefly the chance of splintering at the exit point on the cross-grain passes (translate: stop work, glue the splinter back, cleanup--takes an hour and half to fix, if you can find the splinter and it's intact.)
For most hobbyist woodworkers, meaning most of us here, a shoulder plane can double as a rebate plane. It will get into the same corners, and with a lot of precision. The shoulder plane is not designed like the higher-angle rebate for shaving clearance or wood removal--it's forte is taking precision fine cuts. But most of the time, it'll do just fine for the task at hand. And there are fitting situations where you do need a trimming plane, such as making cabinet doors fit, where you do want the longer registration, including registration ahead of the blade. For example, a two-door cabinet, like this one,
http://wwworkbench.com/cms/index.php?name=coppermine&file=displayimage&meta=lastalb&cat=10007&pos=2
where the double doors close on each other, with a rebate on each door edge. As a second example, some cabinet doors require rebates on the hinge side or all-round--another close-fitting situation. Shoulder plane is good for these situations.
All in all, if you don't have a shoulder plane, it would be a sensible thing to have for your current project and future ones, provided the wallet is willing. If money is tight, Wm. Duffield's suggestion of the LV miniature is there for you, and if things are really tight, there are lower-tech solutions for the current problem that we haven't talked about yet.
Wiley