Re: Why hide glue?
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Chuck,
It's not a religious matter with me. I use yellow glue on table top glue-ups and the like, where I want something water-resistant, and where I can isolate the thing that's being glued and clean it up easily in the course of planing it flat.
On the other hand, there are lots of situations where it's difficult to isolate the mating parts--you're gluing them in place or creating nooks and crannies where glue can accumulate and be tough to get out. Joinery for example--dovetails and M&T--where there is going to be squeeze out (in my hands) to be cleaned up. Hide is an easy clean and doesn't have to be removed to the last atom to not discolor finish.
So cleanup is a big consideration with me. Another one is that hide glue will stick to itself, whereas PVA won't stick to anything other than bare wood. Why does this matter? Well, if I'm gluing sawn veneer say, there will be situations where I am doing sizing and then sequential gluing: the substrate gets sized, then veneer sheets go down either all at once, or more likely with me, sequentially, on top of the sizing and up against the adjacent veneer sheet. All this end grain has to remain sized until it receives final cover, so it's unavoidable to be doing a certain amount of gluing over glue. Hide glue, or hide glue sizing reactivates immediately to heat and/or water. I really don't know how I would do this with yellow glue. I think there is a luthier's white (Tom has written about it) that would do in this situation, but since I'm comfortable with hide, I like it for this purpose. All cross-banding with sawn veneer is in my hands going to be sequential gluing over sizing.
Another thing about sawn veneer is that it curls, if you only apply glue one side. So you apply glue both sides, or glue one side and multiple sizings on the outer side while the glue sets. This is not only true for intended veneer applications, but also applications where your project has gotten dinged in handling, and you need to make a repair--the part that's getting glued down has got to be wet both sides, and sometimes is going down over remnants of prior glue. If you're using yellow glue, just don't make any mistakes and you'll be fine, or else hope that the situations you get into are favorable--neither of which works for me
.
Well, if you have to apply glue or size both sides, that means you've got a cleanup on the appearance face, and it's an easy cleanup with hide, but a horrible situation with yellow. Especially if there is any ebony stringing involved, where you don't want to sand into difficult-to-plane areas, because ebony dust will get anywhere and everywhere and stay there. It will be a nightmare scraping job. If you don't use sawn veneer, no problem, but if you do, hide is friendly.
In short, yellow PVA for isolatable glue-ups where removal/cleanup will happen in the course of things, but hot or liquid hide for all joinery, sawn veneer, or sequential glue ups involving sizing.
Wiley