New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Why hide glue?

Posts

Why hide glue?

#1

Why hide glue?

Chuck Bjorgen

There have been several discussion recently about the best ways to use hide glue but I don't believe I've read any reasons about why hide glue is chosen over the relatively easier- to-use modern yellow glues. I can understand someone wanting to work in what he might consider a more traditional method. Any reasons for hide glue beyond that?

Re: Why hide glue?

#2

Re: Why hide glue?

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Chuck, I can't answer your question with any real expertise, but...

I like using hide glue because:

1. I find it easy to work with

2. I build things thinking someday down the road, somebody may have to do a repair and will be happy that I used hide glue if something has to be taken apart

3. Maybe I am lucky, but I never seem to see glue lines with hide glue - I work mostly with Cherry and Walnut

4. On a current project, I had hide glue seep out and didn't notice it until I was applying stain and it disappeared - they say it takes stain/finish well, I guess it does

5. I seem to make less mess with hide glue compared to yellow

6. I like the working time with it; yellow sets too fast for slow Joe

7. I am weird and kinda like the smell of it. I also like farm smells and skunks

I don't know, I don't have any good technical reasons for using it, I just like to. There are times of course, when I use yellow, but I use hide glue when I can.

Good question and I'll be interested to see what the experts have to say as to why you would or wouldn't want to use hide glue.

Re: Why hide glue?

#3

Agree except for the skunks


Re: Why hide glue?

#4

Re: Why hide glue?

Bill Spievak

Hide glue doesn't creep, it sands easily, can be had in various gel times, and with urea can be made to have longer open times.

Re: Why hide glue?

#5

Re: Why hide glue?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Chuck,

It's not a religious matter with me. I use yellow glue on table top glue-ups and the like, where I want something water-resistant, and where I can isolate the thing that's being glued and clean it up easily in the course of planing it flat.

On the other hand, there are lots of situations where it's difficult to isolate the mating parts--you're gluing them in place or creating nooks and crannies where glue can accumulate and be tough to get out. Joinery for example--dovetails and M&T--where there is going to be squeeze out (in my hands) to be cleaned up. Hide is an easy clean and doesn't have to be removed to the last atom to not discolor finish.

So cleanup is a big consideration with me. Another one is that hide glue will stick to itself, whereas PVA won't stick to anything other than bare wood. Why does this matter? Well, if I'm gluing sawn veneer say, there will be situations where I am doing sizing and then sequential gluing: the substrate gets sized, then veneer sheets go down either all at once, or more likely with me, sequentially, on top of the sizing and up against the adjacent veneer sheet. All this end grain has to remain sized until it receives final cover, so it's unavoidable to be doing a certain amount of gluing over glue. Hide glue, or hide glue sizing reactivates immediately to heat and/or water. I really don't know how I would do this with yellow glue. I think there is a luthier's white (Tom has written about it) that would do in this situation, but since I'm comfortable with hide, I like it for this purpose. All cross-banding with sawn veneer is in my hands going to be sequential gluing over sizing.

Another thing about sawn veneer is that it curls, if you only apply glue one side. So you apply glue both sides, or glue one side and multiple sizings on the outer side while the glue sets. This is not only true for intended veneer applications, but also applications where your project has gotten dinged in handling, and you need to make a repair--the part that's getting glued down has got to be wet both sides, and sometimes is going down over remnants of prior glue. If you're using yellow glue, just don't make any mistakes and you'll be fine, or else hope that the situations you get into are favorable--neither of which works for me :) .

Well, if you have to apply glue or size both sides, that means you've got a cleanup on the appearance face, and it's an easy cleanup with hide, but a horrible situation with yellow. Especially if there is any ebony stringing involved, where you don't want to sand into difficult-to-plane areas, because ebony dust will get anywhere and everywhere and stay there. It will be a nightmare scraping job. If you don't use sawn veneer, no problem, but if you do, hide is friendly.

In short, yellow PVA for isolatable glue-ups where removal/cleanup will happen in the course of things, but hot or liquid hide for all joinery, sawn veneer, or sequential glue ups involving sizing.

Wiley

Re: Why hide glue?

#6

Lots of reasons...

John in NM

Like Joe, I like the smell :D

But, it's as strong as yellow glue, and way easier to fix - hide glue will stick to itself in a failed joint, yellow glue will not. Though I always hear about how we don't need to spring long butt joints, it seems like my sprung ones never fail and I see a lot of straight ones that have. Great time to have used hide glue rather than yellow, a quick re-glue and you're good for another 20 years until it fails again.

It also doesn't seem to resist finishes as badly as PVA glues. Also it's as slick as snot when first applied, so glue up goes easier than with PVA - though that also may be because I hurry a bit more when using hot hide glue.

When you just mix as much as you need and keep the rest as granules in a jar, it seems to last forever. I've never tried the pre-mixed hide glue.

Re: Why hide glue?

#7

Re: Why hide glue?

wilbur

All the relevant points have already been made, but here's my two cents anyway.

When the term "hide glue" is used, it's not always clear that there's a distinction between using hot hide glue with a pot and a brush, and liquid hide glue from a bottle. To use liquid hide glue, I open the cap, tip the bottle, and squeeze. There is no difference in ease of use between liquid hide glue and PVA glue.

As Wiley and others already have mentioned, liquid hide glue has an advantage in that it's not as fussy in regards to clean up as PVA glue in terms of applying finish later on down the line. And I think that has to be considered when it comes to "ease of use". Having to be really careful about squeeze out and cleanup with a scraper after the glue dries doesn't really say "easy to use" to me.

PVA glue does have more water resistance than hide glue. I think this advantage is overstated in most situations. After all, it's not like dining tables and end tables that have had drinks placed on them over the years fall apart more than other types of furniture.

So given the disadvantages that PVA glue has over hide glue in terms of finish application, and the relatively minor advantage of water resistance, I usually like to turn the question around: why PVA glue, if your project isn't going to go outdoors?

Re: Why hide glue?

#8

Times when real-fast-tack is good

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Chuck and all,

Something I forgot to mention first time around....

Sometimes you want really fast tack. Faster than PVA. Maybe not superglue fast, but grabs-hard-in-1-minute-fast. This occurs when you're joining surfaces that there's no way--or no practical way--to get fixed clamps on it. Which means you're going to hold it in place with your fingers or with a hand-held caul until the glue grabs. Examples would be (1) most marquetry (some do like superglue for this), (2) sawn cross-banding on table tops (if you don't lay it down all in one sheet), (3) sawn cross-banding on drawer fronts, (4) small repairs in odd places.

In the above, I'm excluding vacuum bag applications. Assumption is you're doing out in the open.

I'm beginning to sound doctrinaire about protein glue. What I'm really saying is that it can be a valuable and occasionally essential tool in the toolbox, as soon as you get beyond that row of Bessey clamps with three-boards-to-become-tabletop laying on them. It's not just tradition--there is a practical point to it in a number of situations. Cleanup, sticks to itself in a sequential glue-up, second chance if you want to preserve that option, flexible grab-time if you want to preserve that option....

Finally, your question implied something about doing it because it's traditional. That may be true for some, just like choice of other tools can be influenced by perceptions of what's traditional, and it appeals to hobbyists who wish to reenact traditional methods. But I think the 'tradition' concept of hide glue is a bit dismissive of those who have developed great skill and control, like Warren and Stephen Shepherd. As Warren pointed out once, in a single sentence, the use of protein glue is an art. For him it is; I'm just a hacker, a paint by the numbers guy; but the people who use protein glue for a living, such as Warren, Stephen, or Patrick Edwards, develop tremendous facility and touch, to which the flexibility-in-use of the glue does become essential. This is probably not a big point for most of us--we won't get that good--but I think we should remember the lifetime practitioners, to keep the big picture in mind.

Wiley

Re: Why hide glue?

#9

Re: Times when real-fast-tack is good

Tom

"Finally, your question implied something about doing it because it's traditional. That may be true for some, just like choice of other tools can be influenced by perceptions of what's traditional, and it appeals to hobbyists who wish to reenact traditional methods. But I think the 'tradition' concept of hide glue is a bit dismissive of those who have developed great skill and control, like Warren and Stephen Shepherd."

I agree with that, whether it was in the question or not. I think what happens with me is I am always delighted to learn a new distinction in which an old way is better than a new way, but I don't prefer things just because they are old. We often throw out the old even when it is superior, or when there is one commercially important advantage to the new. I don't make boots but I was thrilled to discover that real veg tan leather, of which there is virtually none these days, dramatically improves the comfort of boot insoles. This was a case in a forum of pros who are not trying to be ye -old, crying when their best supplier dried up and wondering what they would do now. It is interesting just to learn something, even if we will mostly all wear crocs from Walmart, or something.

Re: Why hide glue?

#10

Re: Why hide glue?

Tom

"6. I like the working time with it; yellow sets too fast for slow Joe "

+1 on on the list. As has been suggested elsewhere, this would be a cold/bottle, vs hot hide glue thing. The hot glue can be made to set almost instantly. As it happens one can also use the hot glue out of a bottle. Urea which extends the glue gel time is considered to be a long term problem for hide glue in some quarters.

I would also note, that while for me Hot Glue is the bees knees, that cold glue has a very strong presence in factories. One might think that in all factory settings something knew would be used, but cold glue applied to hot wood is pretty classic for the 20th Century.

In guitars there are those who believe that hot glue is better for tone. I have to call BS on that not merely on the improbability, but from a Positivist perspective, how would one ever test that premise. But it is currently a popular belief, and it is probably the better glue anyway. One major reason is repair-ability. I think few modern furniture makers will ever get their goods repaired by someone who knows the difference. With instruments, guitars are too hard to take apart, to make internal repairs all that practical. Violins, are easily taken apart, comparatively, and so hide glue is critical. Violins also last a lot longer for a variety of reasons. So repair is a possibility.

I should say I can easily believe that the wrong glue would affect tone. But hide glue is probably not the only transparent adhesive out there.

Hide glue allows rubbed joints, which make installation of braces very easy, or veneer work, or some joinery.

I`m a real glue snob, and I buy many adhesives in 5 gal drums. I use dozens of different types and use them in multiple mixes. This isn't as unusual as it might sound. There are lots of people who build furniture, instruments, and boats. That will do it. So I am fussy on glue, but I actually find few times to use hide glue. But it is unique, and has some fabulous characteristics.

Re: Why hide glue?

#11

Re: Why hide glue?

Tom

"I think there is a luthier's white (Tom has written about it)"

LMII makes a white glue that is a lot like any white glue, but it dries a lot harder, which would be considered better at resisting string tension, and more transparent to sound.

One other advantage to hide glue is that it works pretty nicely in very cold conditions. Below 50 degrees white and yellow glue go chalky. This can be dealt by stuff like keeping a bottle in one's pocket. But hot glue is hot to start with.

Re: Why hide glue?

#12

Clint Searl

Re: Why hide glue?

Clint Searl

5 Gal? You must get a little squeeze out.

Re: Why hide glue?

#13

Re: Why hide glue?

don stephan

Repetitious, but I use hot hide glue because the joint can be disassembled, it can be repaired, it takes dyes and stains better, and I think my glue lines are thinner (perhaps because I shoot all edge joints with a #8 plane after the power jointer). I like the glue so much that in winter I use a hot air gun for a few minutes to warm the joints so the glue doesn't gell too quickly. When gluing up a panel with more than 4 boards, I will glue three joints a day until done. but when doing this I put all the boards in the clamps so the boards will all fit tight. Just my 2 cents.

Re: Why hide glue?

#14

Re: Why hide glue?

edward in Vancouver

I was making a coopered top for a toy chest when I decided to give it a try. I didn't have any pinch dogs to clamp the coopered staves (?) together and rigging up some kind of a clamping jig was far beyond my level of patience.

So the coopered top, made of 12 staves, was done with rubbed joints. Three years later and the toybox is still in one piece--didn't say it still looks O.k., but it is in one piece. It's been dropped down then stairs a few times, my nephew climbs on the top several times a day, and otherwise generally abused, but the rubbed joints are tight and strong.

The only negative thing I can say about hide glue is that dogs looove the stuff, and will chew at the wood and joints to get at the glue

Re: Why hide glue?

#15

Re: Why hide glue?

Chuck Bjorgen

Folks, those are some really great answers to my question. Dogs. I wonder if that's why my schnauzer, Willy, is licking a section of carpet in our bedroom. Seems to leave gunk on his beard.

Working time, rubbed joints, repairability, etc. those are pretty good reasons for trying hide glue. I note that bottled hide glue, labeled "brown glue," has a shelf life of only one year. Does that make mixing your own from granules the best way to go?

I must confess that I got most of my info on gluing from watching Norm's TV show many years ago. I suppose in that sense I was referring to hide glue as a traditional or old-fashioned method.

Thanks, all, for your clarifications.

Re: Why hide glue?

#16

Buy the small size of Old Brown Glue.

Chuck Nickerson

Then the one-year shelf life is not a problem. Rightly or wrongly, I attribute the commercial revival of liquid hide glue to Patricj Edwards. So I try to give him the business that I can.

Re: Why hide glue?

#17

Re: Buy the small size of Old Brown Glue.

Chuck Bjorgen

Thanks for the tip. That's exactly the one I saw at TFWW.

Re: Why hide glue?

#18

Re: Buy the small size of Old Brown Glue.

Bruce, a MN Galoot

The Rockler store near Ridgedale carries the small bottles, Chuck. That's where I got my last batch. I don't know about Woodcraft, haven't checked there.

Re: Why hide glue?

#19

Re: Buy the small size of Old Brown Glue.

Chuck Bjorgen

Thanks, Bruce. I have the brand new Rocklers over near Maplewood Mall. I'll try that one first. A good excuse to visit the new store.

Re: Why hide glue?

#20

Re: Buy the small size of Old Brown Glue.

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I didn't know about that one, but I rarely get that far east. It should be about right for young Mr. Donaldson, too!

Re: Why hide glue?

#21

Ease of use

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have read most of the responses here. One thing that has not been mentioned is how much easier hide glue is to use. It is not gooey like the yellow glues or like the "liquid hide glue". It spreads much easier and much faster because it is thinner. It also requires much less clamping time and less drying time. We often work the glued piece an hour later.

There was a discussion below about the glue getting moldy. I have that happen a few times a year and I think it may occur when the glue is too thin. Usually the glue gradually dries out and only needs water added to use again. I have not refrigerated the glue at all in decades of use. I don't think guys were refrigerating a few centuries ago. Nor does the glue go bad if it just sits gelled in the shop for long periods.

Some workers keep the glue hot all day long. In this case the glue gradually weakens so they throw it out and start fresh after a week or so. Part of the reason 145 degrees or so is recommended is because if it is hotter than that it deteriorates faster. I think the traditional procedure was to heat the glue only when they were going to use it, although they might have left it near the fire if they anticipated additional use.

Re: Why hide glue?

#22

Re: Buy the small size of Old Brown Glue.

William Duffield

I've never seen OBG carried by Woodcraft. Woodcraft does carry Titebond (Franklin) Liquid Hide Glue, in several sizes of brown squeeze bottles.

I also haven't seen a review comparing Patrick Edwards' OBG and Titebond hide glues from someone who has used both of them.

Whatever LHG you decide to use, it's a good idea to keep it refrigerated. It's also a really good idea to test it, between fingertips, looking for stringyness, if you haven't used and tested your bottle in the last month (or in the last week, if the weather has been extreme, or if it's getting near its expiration date).

Asking the Bench Dog to test it for you is an exercise in futility. He'll always tell you it's delicious. But it's a great way to recycle it, especially if you think you might have overcooked it, as long as it's not moldy.

Re: Why hide glue?

#23

Re: Mostly in my wallet 


Re: Why hide glue?

#24

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Why hide glue?

Stephen Shepherd

For all of the reasons stated so far and it washes out of your clothing, is made from a renewable natural resource and not some dangerous petro-chemicals. It has a proven history of thousands of years and it is easy to make it waterproof. It is also easy on edge tools, no swarf, and doesn't suffer from creep.

Stephen

Re: Why hide glue?

#25

Re: Why hide glue?

Curt Putnam

Sorry to be so late - but how does one make HG and/or LHG waterproof and what does that do to its other properties?