New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Gramercy Holdfasts...a kit?

Posts

Gramercy Holdfasts...a kit?

#1

Gramercy Holdfasts...a kit?

Paul in NJ

We probably all have heard tools are kits and that they can be improved with a little tweaking. I believe this is true more or less depending on the tool. At dinner prior to our Central Jersey Woodworking Association meeting the subject of Gramercy holdfasts came up. My friend William Duffield has convinced me to post here about my modification to the holdfast.

The Gramercy holdfast is a great value and works as advertised. I believe it is a good value because it has a relatively simple manufacturing process. To his credit, Joel from Tools for Working Wood has passed these savings on to his customers. After hearing good reviews I bought a pair. My initial reaction was that they were a little clunky. They need a good solid rap to get them to grab. If you look at a traditional holdfast, they are tapered in thickness from the bend to the holding pad. I believe this allows them to flex a bit and hold a little better with not as much force needed to set them.

I decided to modify one. If I screwed up I still had the other and they were not very expensive. I took my 4-1/2" angle grinder with a 60 grit flap sanding wheel and went at it. In a short while it looked like this:





You can see where I removed material from both the top and bottom. I think I could take some more off too. There is a definite improvement, they set using less force than the stock one.

Regards,

Paul Dzioba

Re: Gramercy Holdfasts...a kit?

#2

Re: Gramercy Holdfasts...a kit?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Interesting Paul.

I can see how the head would become more springy, and that this would reduce the amount of force required to set it in action.

My concern is whether the removal of some of the cross section has affected its structural integrity, that is, will the head bend and not spring back?

Time will tell. Keep us informed.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Gramercy Holdfasts...a kit?

#3

Re: Gramercy Holdfasts...a kit?

Bruce McCrory

I keep checking TFWW to see if they have holdfasts back in stock.

In configuration your modifications match many I have seen . I will keep this in mind when received. Thanks, for the tweak notice.

Re: Gramercy Holdfasts...a kit?

#4

Re: Gramercy Holdfasts...a kit?

AlanWS

That is an interesting modification. Does the springiness make them any more difficult to remove?

Re: Gramercy Holdfasts...a kit?

#5

Re: Gramercy Holdfasts...a kit?

joel moskowitz

We should have plenty more holdfasts in a week or so.

Re: Gramercy Holdfasts...a kit?

#6

Super! Thanks, Joel


Re: Gramercy Holdfasts...a kit?

#7

Re: Gramercy Holdfasts...a kit?

William Duffield

Thanks, Paul.

I had previously made a much more trivial modification, using some solvent, some coarse sandpaper, and a bit of corrosion, to make them set better, but it has made them more difficult to release. If Paul's mod can make the best holdfasts ever invented even more convenient to use, I'm willing to grind on them all day until their set/release hysteresis is perfectly balanced for my benchtop and my deadblow hammer. If I go too far, I can always painlessly buy another pair from Joel and start over.

Re: Gramercy Holdfasts...a kit?

#8

Re: Gramercy Holdfasts...a kit?

Tom

I doubt that will happen. It's like a spar, and taper is normal. When you build in the proper taper it actually spreads the load over a larger part of the structure. what you have in the regular model is a massive stress riser. Obviously it doesn't cause any problems whatsoever which just suggest the section is more than beefy enough.

If I wanted to worry about something I would consider that if it moves when it flexes, and it was locked in to start with, then a geometry change could make it no longer function well. When I made mine, I followed some instructions in a CS article, and what I found was that the lock up was dependant on the geometry of the hole. So a different bench might work better or worse with a particular holdfast. So i probably wouldn't do any thing if I already had one that worked, unless, of course, I could tweak it.

Re: Gramercy Holdfasts...a kit?

#9

Re: Gramercy Holdfasts...a kit?

Paul Dzioba

A tap laterally to the back releases them easily.

Regards,

Paul Dzioba

Re: Gramercy Holdfasts...a kit?

#10

Re: Gramercy Holdfasts...a kit?

Paul Dzioba

Hi Derek,

I have been using this holdfast for quite a while, I think it will be fine.

Regards,

Paul Dzioba

Re: Gramercy Holdfasts...a kit?

#11

Re: Gramercy Holdfasts...a kit?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Paul

Thanks. I have two of my own. They are excellent hold downs, and I have never thought to modify them as mine work just fine in my 3 1/2" thick benchtop. That is not to criticise (the other) Paul's suggestion. Indeed, it could improve them - I can see how a little flex would help reduce the amount of force needed to secure them. My concern is whether the removal of steel might be detrimental to it's structural integrity (causing a permanent bend). I'd like to hear what Joel has to say, since they are his design and he happens to be a structural engineer by training.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Gramercy Holdfasts...a kit?

#12

Re: Gramercy Holdfasts...a kit?

joel moskowitz

A holdfast is basically a giant leaf spring. By grinding away material you get more flex because you have a weaker spring. It holds easier and releases easier because the spring is weaker, but at the same time it is gripping with less force. If the reduced amount of force it is gripping with works well with your applications then there is no reason not to grind away material. If not then there is your reason not to do it. Since the amount of force was determined by what size steel rod fits in a 3/4" hole, I can't tell you if reducing the force is a good idea of a bad one.

I do think the mod looks slick.

Joel

PS - Derek I'm a lapsed mechanical engineer not a lapsed structural engineer

Re: Gramercy Holdfasts...a kit?

#13

Re: Gramercy Holdfasts...a kit?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

PS - Derek I'm a lapsed mechanical engineer not a lapsed structural engineer

You say po-tah-toe and I say po-tay-toe ...

... but we are all pleased you lapsed and started TFWW, Joel :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Gramercy Holdfasts...a kit?

#14

Re: Gramercy Holdfasts...a kit?

William Duffield

I have a big mallet and rather thin, rock maple bench tops, so I have to hit my holdfasts more times and more vigorously to release them than to set them. One tap sets them just about every time. Therefore, I figure decreasing the spring constant a bit should help to balance things out. Of course, everyone's individual situation will differ, so I wouldn't suggest making any modifications if you have difficulty getting yours to hold, but no problem getting them to release.

Disclaimer: My engineering training and experience (being in computers and telecommunications, and also lapsed) is much less pertinent than Joel's, or Zodo's, so take my recommendations with a grain of salt.

Re: Gramercy Holdfasts...a kit?

#15

Re: Gramercy Holdfasts...a kit?

joel moskowitz

William,

try hitting them on the back and pulling the holdfast up with the other hand at the same time.

Re: Gramercy Holdfasts...a kit?

#16

Re: Gramercy Holdfasts...a kit?

William Duffield

Sometimes I do that, but usually, due to lack of planning, the other hand is already full of whatever is needed for the next operation. :D I'll try to be more consistent about using your method.

Another trick to make them release easier, which I think Chuck Bender demonstrated to me, is to strike them below the bench top on the end of the shaft, in the opposite direction as you would normally strike them for release. This trick assumes, of course, that you can get access to the end of the shaft with your mallet.

Re: Gramercy Holdfasts...a kit?

#17

Re: Gramercy Holdfasts...a kit?

ray

They are back in stock. My set arrived a few days ago.