New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Help Identify Tree

Posts

Help Identify Tree

#1

Help Identify Tree

Paul in NJ

I could use some help identifying this tree/wood. First here is a shot of the leaves.They are a simple alternating leaf pattern on the branch.



Here is a shot that shows the end bud and alternating leaf pattern:



Here is a shot of the bark:



A picture of the end and radial grain:



Note the darker heartwood.

And finally of the face grain:


The green wood works like butter with a knife, I am hoping it will make nice spoons. Thanks for your help.

Regards,

Paul Dzioba

Re: Help Identify Tree

#2

Re: Help Identify Tree

Larry Barrett

Leaves and bark look like American elm. Any elms in your area? I haven't seen an elm in the wild for a long time in my neck of the woods (Maryland), so don't know what the green wood looks like.

Re: Help Identify Tree

#3

I'm going to guess

Al Goldstein

that its persimmon. I tried to identify its leaves using TREE FINDER by May Theilgaard Watts. This little booklet uses a series of questions concerning leaves to narrow down to the correct answer. Unfortunately, I had to guess at some answers because I didn't have the leaves in front of me.

(This is a great booklet for working backwards from the leaves to the tree. She also has a booklet WINTER TREE FINDER that also identifies trees from clues from twigs and bark. I got my booklets from Amazon.com.)

IDENTIFYING WOOD by R. Bruce Hoadley discusses persimmon on page 115 and he gave the final clue. Persimmon has a very dark heartwood and a creamy white sapwood.

In THE WOODWRIGHT'S SHOP by Roy Underhill (page 16) he says that persimmon is a difficult wood to work with and shrinks considerably during seasoning.

Hope all this helps.

Re: Help Identify Tree

#4

Re: Help Identify Tree

William Duffield

It's American elm, Ulmus americana.

Note that it can't be common persimmon, Diospyros virginiana, because persimmon leaf margins are entire, while elm leaf margins are serrated. If you google images for american elm or ulmus americana you will find very closely matching images for bark, wood and leaves.

An advantage for making spoons from elm is that the wood has interlocked grain, so it is much less likely to split when exposed to soup, tomato sauce and dishwashers. However, if you don't work it green, the interlocked grain also makes it very difficult to cut. Note that the ring porous structure is often considered a disadvantage for cooking and eating utensils, because of it's potential to trap food. This can be worked around with a good initial oiling (and curing) with a hardening oil, e.g., BLO.

Re: Help Identify Tree

#5

Dale Lenz

Re: Help Identify Tree

Dale Lenz

Definately an elm...can't be sure to which species of elm, but an elm.

Have fun.

Re: Help Identify Tree

#7

Re: Help Identify Tree

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Paul, it looks like an elm to me also. One feature that elms have is wavy lines in the late wood. If you look at cleanly cut end grain in the rings, the early wood has coarse pores. The late wood, between the rings, is more dense and has faint wavy lines of tiny pores. I can see these wavy lines if I blow up your end grain picture.

A feature that American elm has that the other elms do not shows up in the bark. There are layers of dark bark and creamy layers a little less than 1/16 thick. We used to call them ice cream sandwiches when I was in school. If it has ice cream sandwiches, it is American elm. Otherwise it is probably slippery elm

Re: Help Identify Tree

#8

Thanks everyone!

Paul in NJ

American Elm it is.

Warren, it has the "ice cream sandwich bark" you described.

I am going to make a few spoons and use a drying type oil as William has suggested. I think I will use walnut oil.

Regards,

Paul Dzioba

Re: Help Identify Tree

#9

Dale Lenz

Good call Warren

Dale Lenz

I learned the dark and light bark as: Oreo cookie, the American cookie.

Re: Help Identify Tree

#10

Re: Help Identify Tree

don stephan

The wavy lines Warren mentioned are I think stunning. If you know a turner, offer some of the wood to a bowl maker, where those wavy lines will be exposed. Few will see this small detail, but those who look closely will be richly rewarded. When young I hated to see so many magnificient mature spreading American elm trees felled by the Dutch Elm disease.

Re: Help Identify Tree

#11

Re: Help Identify Tree

Patrick Gibbons

Looks just like the elms in my front and back yards. They grow slowly.

Re: Help Identify Tree

#12

An excellent lesson against monoculture

Bruce McCrory

I have a memory of many city blocks, as far as I could see, in Des Moines, Iowa, where every street tree was leafless, in summer.

Of course, memories are short and wisdom shorter.

Re: Help Identify Tree

#13

Re: Help Identify Tree

jim Hoeller

My guess is chinquapin oak.

Re: Help Identify Tree

#14

Re: I'm going to guess

Lars Parrington

Ha! I tried the same book and ended up with American Beech. Going back I can see where I went wrong. I chose teeth of all the same size, instead of doubly-toothed. Choosing doubly toothed quickly gets me to Elm.

I think you must have made your mistake on p28, choosing that the leaf has neither teeth nor lobes.

I just picked up these books over the weekend. Am looking forward to taking a very slow hike and seeing what I can identify. I have the winter tree finder too, so maybe I can use it to confirm my identifications.