Re: Back Polishing Problem
wilbur
I don't worry too much about achieving a mirror finish. What's more important is the consistency of your scratch patterns. The fact that your scratch patterns instantly change when you switch direction with your 6000 grit waterstone tells me that you've gotten all the benefit from that stone that you can get. If there was a deeper scratch left over from your 1000 grit waterstone, it would still remain, or at least it wouldn't be "almost instantly replaced" by scratches going in another direction.
You often hear that a mirror finish is the goal when flattening the back of a chisel or plane blade. What we are doing is using a mirror finish as a surrogate for an even covering of the back with a scratch pattern that is only due to the last step in your sharpening process.
The problem is, what causes a mirror finish does not directly correlate with what causes a sharp edge. A sharp edge is achieved when you have very small scratches on the back and bevel side that intersect at the cutting edge. A mirror finish is achieved when you have a very even scratch pattern, without much variation in the size of the scratches.
If you can wrap your brain around this idea, it should become apparent that you can have an even pattern of relatively deep scratches that provide a mirror appearance, and an uneven pattern of shallower scratches that will look hazy.
It's easier to understand this if we put some numbers on this. I know that my 5000 grit waterstone will leave a mirror finish on a chisel back. What the manufacturer's information tells me is that this waterstone has abrasive particles that are about 4 microns in diameter, and when I look at the chisel with a magnifying glass, the scratch pattern is very even. What this tells me is that the particle size in this waterstone is very uniform.
If I followup with my 8000 grit waterstone, the back becomes hazy. This waterstone has particles that are about 1.5 microns in diameter. When I look at the back, the scratch pattern is definitely finer than the 5000 grit waterstone, but is not as even. My guess is that even though this waterstone has particles that are nominally 1.5 microns, the particles vary more in size around that 1.5 micron mark than the particles in the 5000 grit waterstone, which leads to a more uneven scratch pattern that is still finer than the previous step.
In use, the chisel feels sharper after finishing with the 8000 grit waterstone than if I stop with the 5000 grit waterstone, which is the real world evidence to support the idea that a mirror finish is not necessarily the best test for sharpness. I think Warren is right on when he says to use the chisel and see how it works.