Plough planes--my thoughts (Long, Opinionated)
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Steve and all,
Not OT at all, and I hope to hear from others on this question!
It's hard for me to pick an absolute favorite plough, because they all work and do their job. I see numerous tradeoffs among the different styles; to get one thing, you give up another.
Metal vs. wood. Metal ploughs are compact and dense. I doubt they're heavier than some wooden models, but their weight is concentrated in line behind the iron, and they give a sense of power because of that. But wood gives me a warm, fuzzy feeling, so I prefer wood.
Iron width, nominal sizes. A new metal plough, or any new plough, will have irons with accurate nominal sizing. They'll start at 1/8", because the skate will be about 1/16", and the iron has to have room for the V-shaped locating groove, plus clear the skate on the sides with a little to spare. A new No. 3 plough iron will be 1/4" to a close tolerance. Now vintage irons are marked numbers 1 through 8, and vaguely follow a progression 1/8 to 1/2 in sixteenths, and then a 5/8". However, vintage irons will vary, and you will rarely get a vintage iron that mic's to a nominal value. A group of No. 3 vintage irons will tend to vary +/- 1/32" on either side of 1/4".
I don't find that a problem. It's like mortise chisels. You plough the groove or chop the mortise to a likely size for the situation--doesn't matter what it measures--and then plane the tongue or saw the tenon to match. Yes, there is the argument that chisels and plough irons need to match, so that you can line up the groove with the mortise (or even use the groove sidewalls to frame the mortise) when making a frame for a panel. But that is an unnecessary restriction and sometimes unwanted: You may at times want the M&T centered in the frame, but the panel groove or rebate offset from the M&T, in order to get a particular look. Krenov, for example, talked about setting glass closer to the frame face to get a sense of lightness. Or you may want a molding whose depth doesn't line up with the M&T. Hayward says to cut the mortise first: if you do that, you can locate the groove or the rebate where you want it to achieve a certain look. Of course, if it doesn't matter, then it's an easier marking situation to line up the M&T with the groove or rebate, but I don't think it's a good dependency to build because it restricts what you can do.
[NB: I'd rather have more sizes and a closer gradation than exact nominal sizes. I've recently been in the process of tenoning case sides and back and front rails into 1-5/8" leg posts (for a light desk). When you do that, you become acutely aware that you're taking a lot of meat out of the leg post to make mortises and dovetail sockets. It makes you think hard about mortise widths. I happen to have a 0.205" mortise chisel (made by mistake by the Japanese smith trying to correlate his bu measure with what I was asking for). Well, no matter. That chisel was perfect for the slightly narrow mortises I wanted to make for the multiple tenons on the side and back plates. I preferred it to the 1/4" one.]
Iron taper. If you make a plough and plan to use vintage irons, get the irons first. And get them in a true set, not a 'harlequin set', where every iron potentially has a different taper. You want them to all have the same taper, so that you can make one wedge that fits them all.
Wedge-arm, screw-arm, Yankee type--handled, unhandled. There are tradeoffs. Weight and size is one. That Clark & Williams/Old Street plough is wonderfully light and nimble--nothing there that doesn't have to be there. One of the arm wedges also wedges the depth stop in the same motion as locking up the arm. A screw-arm plough will always be heavier and bulkier than a wedge-arm plough--I think that can be flatly said without much qualification. Particularly the American screw-arms--British ones tend to have shorter arms (which is a better feature IMO). The nuts and washers add to the bulk, and then sometimes they are handled, and you can have quite a big, bulky plane. I personally don't like handled models (though they cost more originally, and have a lot more work in them), because the handle is too far away from the cutting--it feels to me like remote control. I'd rather have my hands right over the cutting, and have my hands surrounding the plane and controlling it, rather than having the feeling the plane is beyond my control, or too big and bulky to really get hold of.
One other thing about the screw arms: I've seen a number of them that restrict how close you can place your groove to the edge. Maybe the threading didn't get cut close enough to the arm hangers, or the inboard nuts are too fat, but you put in the No. 1 iron and maybe you can't get closer than 1/4" to the edge of what you want to groove. That's a problem. Yeah, you can shim the plane's fence, but that's a hassle you don't want. That problem almost can't happen with a wedge-arm or Yankee type.
Here is one thing about the screw-arms I really like--they're idiot proof in a way. Something I need. Once you lock in a setting, it stays that way until you change it on purpose. You can't knock your setting loose while ham-fistedly removing a blade for sharpening, or inadvertently knocking the arms against something. You can even set that plane aside til the job is finished, so you have that setting 'saved'.
There is a second thing, too. These screw arms represent a phenomenon that I suppose arises in a craftsman's world--the desire to make a thing better and more beautiful than it needs to be. America used to have that. As I said in a recent post, I enjoy that historical connection with an American past, and for that reason, I often reach for the screw-arm plough rather than the C&W, even though the C&W is technically unequalled and I place a very high value on having a plane made by Larry Williams or Don McConnell, both legends in their own time.
I had a really good example of a Union Factory 'Yankee' type plane. I put it up for Benefit Auction a year and a half ago, but not because I didn't really like it. I let it go because I could offer it to the group without apologies. It is a superb plane. Here is that plane:
Plough Plane with Irons
This type can be made light if you want. This particular model was a bit heavy, because Union Factory plated the fence with steel. If you make one of these, you'll want to either put load-spreading pads under the fence-locking screws, or else inlay the upper surface of the arms with something hard--brass, rosewood, persimmon, lignum vitae for example.
Wiley