New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

vise chops angle

Posts

vise chops angle

#1

vise chops angle

Jerry Gibbs

Not sure of my terminology. With each vise that I have, the instructions say to angle the outer wood liner about 2 degrees so that the top engages first. My liners are red oak. The tops touch first, but the rest of the vise does not close on the wood being held, giving me little holding power if the held wood is pushed from the side for example. Is the entire vise face supposed to close and touch on the object in the vise? Jerry

Re: vise chops angle

#2

Re: vise chops angle

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Jerry,

My understanding is that you want the vise faces to close parallel with each other, when loaded. The vertical tapering is to take up the mechanical play in the vise, so the faces will close parallel, even on thin sticks at the top of the vise. This will be a function of the vise design and machining, and jaw depth. For example, in my LV twin screw vises, with 7" deep jaws, 1/8" taper from top to bottom brings them out to where the top engages along with the rest of the vise face. That's a little less than 2 degrees, which I believe is what LV quotes in the instructions.

But whatever it takes to make yours close flush, with the top slightly leading, is what you want.

How much taper did you use, if I might ask?

Wiley

Re: vise chops angle

#3

Re: vise chops angle

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

If you have a metal vise, you might try taking a couple of pieces of stock that aren't tapered - parallel faces, in other words - and installing them in the vise, after removing your existing vise chops. Try the vise that way. Some vises (the old Record vises are one example) build this taper into the vise itself, so you can use parallel-faced wood chops.

If you find that your vise has play at the top of the jaw when the bottom is closed firmly, take pieces of card stock (by which I mean, say, 3x5 cards) and slip them between wood and metal jaw at the top and retightening the screws. Continue this until you get good grip up and down the jaw when the vise is closed on a piece of stock with parallel faces (your test piece should be carefully selected, for obvious reasons). The card stock can serve as a feeler gauge, too: if you can easily pull a length of it out top or bottom when your test piece is clamped, you know you're not there yet.

On a wood-jawed vise, metal or wood hardware, you would use a similar approach, by taping pieces of card stock so they're hanging over the jaw.

Re: vise chops angle

#4

taper

Jerry Gibbs

I have a Record 52 1/2 and a Veritas Twin-Screw. The front chop on the Record is 4 3/8" deep and a has an approximate 1/8 gap at the bottom when closed. The instructions say the toe-in is built in. The wooden front chop is not tapered.

The chops for the Veritas are 7" and have an approximate 1/8" gap at the bottom. The Veritas instructions say to place a 7/32" spacer under the chop which should be a least 6" deep. The gap would be greater if I had a 6" chop.

I am concerned that with either vise I will dent softer wood ( and yes, the vises are worth more than the bench). Thanks, Jerry

Re: vise chops angle

#5

another question

Jerry Gibbs

Does it make sense to make the front chop out of a soft wood so that it doesn't dent the held wood?

Re: vise chops angle

#6

Some people use leather liners


Re: vise chops angle

#7

Jack Guzman from Maine

no

Jack Guzman from Maine

Softer jaws will round over on the top edges and you'll lose holding surfaces.Like Bill said,leather on your vise faces works good.---Jack

Re: vise chops angle

#8

Details on the LV twin screws

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hello Jerry,

I went and double-checked the jaw height and taper on my 3 LV twin-screws. Two of them have 8" high jaws, and one is 7". I tapered them all at 3/32", using the method suggested by LV, which was to glue a 3/32" strip of wood the length of the jaw along the lower outside edge of the moving jaw--then run the jaw through a lunchbox planer. Then plane off the strip.

3/32" taper is perfect for both the 8" and 7". The top closes ever so slightly ahead of the jaws coming flush with each other. I selected this taper years ago, when I bought the first two vises, and I don't think LV was recommending 7/32" at that time. I tried to go back on the Wayback Machine and find out, but could not dig out the instructions from eight or ten years ago. But I would bet it wasn't 7/32" at that time (I will admit to having lost such bets before, though :) ).

How much clearance does your vise have between the drive screws and bench top? All three of my vises are fitted with zero-clearance shims between the main drive screws and the bottom of the bench top--like this:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/sets/72157634584295586/

That shimming restricts play in the screws, and could conceivably reduce the amount of taper the front jaw needs.

On balance, though, I think 7/32" is way too much. Which means the 2 degrees is too much, because 7/32" is about what 2 degrees works out to for typical jaw heights. It's twice what is needed. What would be right for you? Since you have 1/8" gap at the bottom, then take the 7/32" taper, subtract the 1/8" gap, and that leaves you with 3/32", which is the taper that would leave you zero gap at the bottom. 3/32" worked for me three times, and it sounds like it would work for you!

Leather would definitely improve things for you, but if you need to pull the jaw off to install the leather, it would be tempting to take off the rest of the hardware, glue on a 3/32" strip, and re-run the jaw through the planer to get it right. Then put the leather on. 2 cents.

Wiley

Re: vise chops angle

#9

Correction for those interested in LV twin

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

I wrote too quickly. My taper is not 1/8"--I double checked and it's 3/32" on three different twin-screws, with jaw heights 8", 8", and 7". 3/32" is about 1 degree for these jaw heights.

Sorry to use the bandwidth for this nit, but it's material to what we're talking about.

Wiley

Re: vise chops angle

#10

Re: vise chops angle

William Duffield

Once you've got the optimum chop angles, you will still find that the vise grips more strongly at the top. I was taught, when applying pressure parallel to the jaw opening (e.g., when trimming the ends of tenon shoulders) to place the stock against the far side of the far guide bar. That way, when the stock tries to rotate around the pressure point at the top of the jaws, it is immediately stopped by the guide bar, and does not rotate away from you.

Anther thing to take away from this is to adjust the angles of the chops so that a bit more pressure is applied (to stock with parallel faces, of course) at the top of the jaw.

My Record 52-1/2 has very little play in the guide bars, even after several years of use. However, there is some slop in both chops, and in their screw attachment to the iron jaws. The higher above the top of the jaws you make the chops, the more stress is applied to the screws. While I like to cover the top of the jaws with the chops so I don't ding my stock on metal, the height of this cover should be kept to a minimum. Also, while it is easy to get at the front chop's attachments points if you need to adjust or tighten them, the rear chop is a horse of a different feather, and you will need to completely remove the vise from the bench to adjust the rear chop.

Re: vise chops angle

#11

LV instructions

Jerry Gibbs

The LV Twin-Screw instructions call for a minimum jaw width of 6" and setting a 2 degree taper using a 7/32" shim. The 7/32 dimension is repeated 3 times, so it is not a misprint. I am going to reduce the taper on both my vises. I don't see how the screw shim on the twin-screw meant to keep the outer jaw from dropping affects the jaw taper when they are closed. Compared to my early years using a Workmate, adjusting these jaws is a high class problem. Jerry

Re: vise chops angle

#12

Re: LV instructions

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Jerry,

I agree that LV's current instructions say and mean 7/32", and it does correspond to 2 degrees. I just think they have it wrong, which is rare for LV.

Please let us know how you make out with the re-taper!

Wiley

Re: vise chops angle

#13

Re: Some people use leather liners

Patrick Gibbons

I lined my patternmaker's vise with very thick leather using contact cement. The leather is directly attached to the metal. I have never had a problem with any wood being marked.

Re: vise chops angle

#14

Re: Some people use leather liners

William Duffield

There are several reasons sticking leather directly to the jaws of a patternmaker's vise are a disadvantage.

- The metal holding jaws won't close all the way for holding sheet metal (e.g., scraper stock), small gauge wire, etc.

- If you use your patternmaker's vise for working metal (e.g., with a file, hacksaw, tap, die, etc.), the metal filings get stuck in the leather, and transferred to the next piece of wood you grip with the vise.

- It makes it more difficult to mount auxiliary jaws for holding tapered stock, round stock, table legs, etc.

- The leather gets in the way of the auxiliary tilting jaw's mechanisms, and makes it more difficult to install it and remove it.

I think it's a better idea to build a simple pair of auxiliary jaws that slide over the metal jaws, or attach with screws to the keyholes, and to attach the leather to their surface.

Re: vise chops angle

#15

Re: Some people use leather liners

Winton Applegate

I'm a big fan of soft jaws in vises to prevent marring the work that is held in the vise.

I made the jaws for the rails in the way vise from lime wood or some such soft wood with very little grain. Similar to bass wood and a bit harder and tougher than balsa.

Note the little dowels that engage with the screw holes in the vise jaws from the factory. The jaws are easily removed for said metal work but stay in place just fine when they are deployed.

There is no taper to the "chops". The metal factory jaws on this vise were made accurately enough that the jaws touch at the top edges and have a bit of spring to the works so they can clamp small stuff there with no problem and no tweaking in the soft jaws.

The largish all thread is to keep the jaws from racking when clamping on one side of the rails, because the rails are in the way of clamping in the middle.

A well thought out woodworking vise would not need such a contrivance as this all thread and it wouldn't have rails that are in the way.

Speaking of such fantasies of sanity and grace . . .

behold the Klausz bench / vise (see last photo).

Because I never ever use the Klausz vise to hold metal, not even a scraper, I have glued the leather to these jaws with hide glue.

I used the rails in the way to make the Klausz and don't really use it for much now. Note the cob webs. Like so many things, nice to look at (from a distance) but that is about it.

[URL=http://s801.photobucket.com/user/noydb1/media/IMG_0726_zps69d43df2.jpg.html][/URL]

[URL=http://s801.photobucket.com/user/noydb1/media/IMG_2291_zps0cdf30c6.jpg.html][/URL]

[URL=http://s801.photobucket.com/user/noydb1/media/IMG_2292_zps46171d72.jpg.html][/URL]

[URL=http://s801.photobucket.com/user/noydb1/media/Bigvise_zpse9474d0c.jpg.html][/URL]

Re: vise chops angle

#16

Re: Some people use leather liners

Patrick Gibbons

William, I've attached my leather in such a way that it doesn't interfere with using the auxiliary jaw. I've used it to hold scraper blades to dress them with no problem. Your remarks about metal filings have merit but in my experience so far has not been a problem. I had more of a problem when I used the vise to clamp a project and glue dried on the leather and injured the next piece I clamped in it. For metal, I mostly use a mechanic's vise, saving the patternmaker's for wood only. In the 12 years I've had this vise, I've used the auxiliary jaw once. Part of the problem is that you forget you have it.


img

Re: vise chops angle

#17

Re: Auxiliary Jaw Improvement

William Duffield

You're right about the leather and the auxiliary jaw. It doesn't take a lot of extra work to get it out of the way of the tilt mechanism.

You might use the jaw more often if it was easier to use. For those who aren't familiar with the tilting auxiliary jaw for Emmert design patternmakers vises, here's a picture of it attached to the vise. Note that I've added a maple face (instead of leather) to mine.

Also, you can kinda see one of my sliding jaw inserts lying on top of the bench, just above the vise. I have to remove the rear insert to install the tilt jaw. The end of the other insert is fight in your face in this photo. I made them from red oak.


Here's what I did to make mine easier to attach and detach. Again, for those following along, to install the tilting jaw, you need to unscrew a small machine screw from the pin, install the jaw, and reinstall the screw, behind the vise's rear jaw. This is a royal PITA. I replaced the machine screw with this ball-lock quick release pin, and drilled out the tapped hole in the aux. jaw to fit. You can tie off the pin with a tether if you are prone to losing small bits of hardware. Otherwise, the pins without the bail are even easier to use. I found this one at West Marine or Chesapeake Lightcraft.

This pic also shows the front jaw insert, installed. Both of these jaw inserts just slide down over the tops of the jaws. It's on my to-do list to glue some leather to their faces.


The final pic shows how the pin holds the jaw in place, and allows it to tilt.


You can get one of these patternmaker's vises from Highland Woodworking. They're about $300 plus shipping.

http://www.highlandwoodworking.com/patternmakerswoodworkingvise.aspx

The Workbench Book will tell you how to install it.

Re: vise chops angle

#18

Good thinking