New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Favorite hammer for mortising

Posts

Favorite hammer for mortising

#1

Favorite hammer for mortising

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi All,

What do you use to hit the mortise chisel? I like something pretty heavy, where the blows are fairly slow speed--let the hammer do the work :) . This hammer was made by a Japanese smith for his own purposes, but the weight is real good for mortises IMO/IME. Maybe 1-1/2lb. I'm guessing. 2 lb would be OK also, but this hammer is what it is.

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/9582304987/in/photostream/lightbox/

What combination of hammer speed and weight do you like?

Wiley

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

#2

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

William Duffield

Hammers? I don't have to show you any stinking hammers! :D


These are my favorite tools for bashing mortise chisels. Whether I choose the larger (hard maple, 11-1/2" x 4", 24 oz.) or the smaller (hophornbeam, 11-1/4" x 2-7/8", 18 oz.) depends on the size of the mortise and what kind of wood I'm bashing it through. Usually, I choose the smaller one, because it's lighter, it doesn't ding as easily on striking rings and I like the control I get with it. It's also what I use with my L-N bench chisels and my carving gouges, but with these, I use only light taps.

I never think about striking in terms of velocity on impact, it's more about energy transferred to the wood, but I've never measured that either. If the chisel doesn't penetrate deeply enough, I just hit it harder on the next blow. Very rarely do I follow Frank Klaus' advise and "Get a bigger hammer". If I were to need a stinkin' hammer, however, I use a Plumb 22 oz. fiberglass rip claw hammer, total weight 32 oz.

The maple mallet was the first thing turned in the Loxahatchee Toolworks. In many subsequent mallets I've turned, I've varied the size, the materials and some details, but always use the same basic pattern.

If I'm building something for the shop, or if it's not a reproduction and it's not going to be seen, then I prefer to use the beast poking its nose in on the left, or it's smaller sibling. They are much faster and more accurate, they're always sharp, they don't leave chips all over the bench and floor, I can choose from seven different mortise widths, and the tenons always fit snugly.

If you are interested it what I use with my froe, I'll need to go back out to the shop and take photos and measurements of my beetle.

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

#3

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

Steve Elliott

For 30 years I've been using an 18-oz dead blow mallet for striking chisels and by now I'm so used to it that I probably wouldn't recognize a "better" tool, I'd just think it didn't feel quite right.

A couple of years ago I tried a carvers mallet with a round urethane head and found it had almost the same feel. I sold the urethane mallet because I didn't need another tool that was no better.

Most of my mortises are done with power equipment so the 18-oz mallet gets used mostly for smaller tasks.

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

#4

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I believe in wood-to-wood and steel-to-steel. This means that unhooped chisels use a wooden mallet, while hooped Japanese bench and dovetail chisels get a gennou.

For the past few years I have used one of those pretty Blue Spruce acrylic-infused mallets with oval bolstered mortice chisels.


More recently I have been using a Veritas Cabinetmaker's Mallet. This has a more focussed blow.

Sometimes I will use a Thor if I have to keep the sound down.


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

#5

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I use a 30 ounce dogwood mallet. The handle is 8 inches long. I use very different motion from what I use with a hammer. With a hammer I use a lot more wrist motion, with this mallet there is more arm motion, less wrist.

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

#6

Mallets, handles, beetle...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Sir Wm. and all,

No wonder you didn't change the pattern on the mallets--it's perfect to these eyes. So are the handles on the chisels--just killer.

There's hammers and hammers...my hammer is used kinda like a steel mallet. I have a real good vera wood mallet, but these steel hooped chisels chew on it a little too much, so I save it for hitting wood.

The Loxahatchee Toolworks has got some really great stuff! Thanks for showing us. I do think we need to see the beetle when you have a moment.

It looks like those chisels have fairly steep bevels on them, 35 or more, is that about right? Is that for levering chips primarily or just blasting them out?

Wiley

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

#7

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Steve,

Is the dead blow mallet loaded with shot, or what? Is the point that it delivers all its energy to the chisel, not wasting any of it on a rebound? Is it a rubber mallet, or wood?

Wiley

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

#8

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Derek,

By the way, I've been getting good use of your marking knife--it's just the thing.

You've shifted now to the Veritas mallet (the brass-headed one) to get the more focussed lick in. 18oz I read at the LV site. I'm curious, do you use the handle length, or choke up on it?

Wiley

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

#9

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

Larry Barrett

I use a turned hickory mallet, similar to, but not as elegant, as William's. 24oz. I like a round mallet because I can focus on the mortising chisel and the mortise and do not need to pay any attention to how I pick up the mallet (although picking up a hammer is also rather mindless after 70+ years).

For bashing the froe I use a chunk of red oak with several knots, about 6lbs.

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

#10

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Warren,

Thanks for the ergonomic details! That is very interesting--almost 2 lb and you shorten up on it and use arm motion (not wrist). I'm visualizing you're kinda letting the weight of the mallet do the work, and everything is pretty relaxed.

I hadn't thought about those things until you mentioned them, so went to see what I'm doing. Lo and behold--I shorten up on the hammer also, hold it in a fairly loose grip, sometimes with a forefinger pointing, and stay very relaxed myself--chisel hand and hammer hand and wrist relaxed.

I'm curious--do you pay attention to the bevel angle? What would you estimate? I ask because there seem to be two theories of bevel angle--one is to get to the bottom of the mortise ASAP, and the other emphasizes levering and otherwise busting loose chips from the side wall.

Shortened-up grip:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/9593244656/in/set-72157632172323442/lightbox/

Wiley

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

#11

P. S. Dogwood

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

How big does the dogwood tree grow in the mid-Atlantic states? When I was growing up in the NC Piedmont, the trees stayed quite small--going on memory, but a mature tree might have been 5" trunk diameter. Also, the trees had to pick their own place to spring up--whatever you planted in your favorite spot in the yard would pretty much wither, no matter the amount of soil preparation.

Anyway, a 30oz lump of dogwood sounds big to me!

Wiley

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

#12

Re: P. S. Dogwood

Bruce McCrory

Caveat: I am on west side of Cascade Mountains, so things grow most of the year.

I lost a dogwood main branch in a winter storm--about 1/3 of a 25-year-old tree, and probably, 3 to 4-inches of wood under the bark. I might turn it this winter for a mallet. The stump is well over 6-inches.

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

#13

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have an old angle gauge that shows angles in 5 degree increments; I would guess that my mortise chisels are slightly over 30 degrees, like 31, not near 35 degrees. I sharpen a flat bevel, no micro bevel or anything. In the style of mortising I do the chisel rides on the bevel and a secondary bevel would interfere with the action.

The trunk I got my dogwood from had the pith quite a bit off-center. I used the wider part plus about 1/4 inch beyond the pith. There is a heart check from the pith to the side, but the check has not interfered with decades of use.

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

#14

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

Steve Elliott

The dead blow mallet is plastic filled with lead shot, I believe. It doesn't bounce and delivers a softer blow than the wooden mallets I've tried. It's also fairly quiet.

By "softer blow" I mean that the impact is delivered over a slightly longer period of time. Instead of a very short burst of high force it transfers energy with less force over a longer period. I think that's better for both the blade and the handle.

I like just the opposite type of blow for adjusting a plane blade by tapping. To advance a blade I want a sharp blow that will exceed the minimum impact needed to get the blade to move while still not delivering a large amount of energy that would push the blade too far. I tap the blade with metal to deepen the cut and tap the plane body with something that won't harm it to lessen the cut. My Ulmia smoother has a strike button that lets me tap with metal and not dent the plane body.

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

#15

Re: P. S. Dogwood

William Duffield

I turned two mallets from dogwood, but never used them. They were similar in size and shape to the one in hophornbeam I showed in this thread. I gave them away, and I don't think either of them has ever been used. I think the recipients thought they were too beautiful to allow them to get dinged up, so they both use something else for driving chisels.

IIRC, the trunk was about 7" in diameter, very large for a dogwood, especially with the anthracnose fungus that is wiping them out here in the Mid-Atlantic. It grew on the banks of the Rivanna River in Charlottesville, VA. Under the best of conditions, they don't grow very fast. I have two at the end of my back yard. Both are 6" in diameter–pith, heartwood, sapwood, and bark. We have a wedding photo with my bride holding a flowering branch from one of them. When they bloom next May, the photo will be forty years old.

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

#16

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Wiley

I'm so pleased you still get use out of the knife. It has been a few years.

You've shifted now to the Veritas mallet (the brass-headed one) to get the more focussed lick in. 18oz I read at the LV site. I'm curious, do you use the handle length, or choke up on it?

The Vertas mallet is on the lighter side for mortice chisel hammers. However the wooden head focusses the force well and there is good control. Generally, as it is light, I hold the handle near the end to get maximum force.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

#17

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Warren,

Again, very interesting comments:

"In the style of mortising I do the chisel rides on the bevel and a secondary bevel would interfere with the action."

Do you mind elaborating your approach, esp. the part about the chisel riding on the bevel?

Thank you for a good discussion,

Wiley

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

#18

Re: Mallets, handles, beetle...

William Duffield

I found the pattern in an early issue of Shop Notes.

For light, controlled blows, the scotia just below the head allows me to "choke up" on the mallet, with the thumb and either the index, middle, or ring finger wrapped around the scotia.

For heavier blows, I grip the main handle. It is sized to fit my hand. When I grip it strongly, the tips of my fingers can't quite close up and touch the pad of my thumb. Much smaller and the fingers against the thumb would stop the closure before I could apply maximum grip strength; Much larger, and my fingers would not curl enough to apply maximum pressure.

Since the diameter of the handle is larger than my grip, it is easy to not notice if the mallet begins to slide out of my hand. The knob on the end, as it slides through my grip triggers a reflex action, and I grab the mallet before it totally escapes me. I can also use the knob for tapping on whatever.

Make sure you turn the end of the mallet slightly concave, so you can set it down on end without it falling over and rolling onto your toe.

The taper of the head is kinda like the hang of a saw. You want it to strike squarely, and the geometry of that depends on the pivot point and radius of your swing: at your shoulder, your elbow, or your wrist, or somewhere in between due to a combination of rotation points.

I don't know the bevel angle. I just sharpen them until they start working. The easiest clue that they are designed for levering out chips is the lack of an arris between the bevel and the front face of the chisel. A smooth, curved transition, like these implies they were intended to be used for prying. Was the smooth transition original, or ground in later? I don't know.

A lot of prying isn't necessary, except to clean out the bottom. I've watched Roy Underhill and Frank Klausz do the demonstration with the plate glass clamped to the front of the mortise. A methodical chopping approach keeps the forces mostly equalized on both faces of the edge, and keeps the edges sharp longer.

The tanged and bolstered chisel is a Butcher. I put a purpleheart handle on it. I should probably put a larger taper on it and more clearly define the octagonal facets. I'lll fix it when I break this handle. The socket chisels are a James Swan and the other is labeled COLM. Their handles are Poncirus trifoliata, a close relative of Citrus.

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

#19

Re: Mallets, handles, beetle... *LINK*

William Duffield

As St. Roy says, "with mallets aforethought", I provide the description of my beetle, or maul.


At the bottom, for scale, I have included the hophornbeam mallet previously described and a couple of others.

The next one up is Hardy Orange, Poncirus trifoliata. It has been ebonized. The wood is usually much lighter in color, similar to Osage Orange. I don't use this one very much, because I don't like the shape of the handle. It's a little too short. It's 16 oz. It is a relatively tough, hard, dense wood, and merits use in mallets and chisel handles that will take a lot of blows, if you can find it and can get someone else to cut it down, limb it and saw it up for you.

http://www.landscapedia.info/images/plant_images/Poncirus_trifoliata__Flying_Dragon_Flying_Dragon_Hardy_Orange.jpg

The next is purpleheart. It is 12" long and 2-5/8" in diameter, and weighs 16-1/2 oz. I don't use this one on chisels with striking rings, because the purpleheart has a splintery tendency.

The top one, obviously, is my maul. It is black locust, 19" long and 3" in diameter, 50 oz. I understand why most people just use a section of a log, or at most just turn the handle and leave the rest rough, because a froe is really hard on a maul. Turning the head is an exercise in futility.


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malice_aforethought

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

#20

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Wiley, if you face the bevel of the chisel away from previous cuts and hit straight down, the chisel rides on the bevel face.

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

#21

Re: P. S. Dogwood

Hank Knight

10" to 12" dogwood trunks are not uncommon in South Carolina. But, as William pointed out, the anthracnose fungus is decimating our dogwoods, and the big, old trees are going fast. A second point: the lower section of a dogwood trunk with the root ball trimmed close is supposed to make an excellent maul for whacking froes and such. The wood is tough to start with and the twisted grain in the root ball makes the maul almost impossible to split. I have turned several dogwood mallets but find them too light weight for any serious pounding. I'm thinking about drilling the head of the one I have now and adding some lead weight to it.

Hank

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

#22

Re: Mallets, handles, beetle...

Patrick Gibbons

Trifoliata was used as a hedge in the South. I seem to remember my sister telling me our grandmother made a summer drink from the fruit. I never knew the wood was useful. It's one of those heirloom plants that's not found in commerce anymore.

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

#23

Re: Mallets, handles, beetle...

William Duffield

There is a variety that is still found commercially, var. tomentosa "Flying Dragon", but it is sold for decorative purposes only, mostly as a bonsai, and it would be useless for timber because it is as far from "straight grained" as you could imagine. The wood also has lots of voids. My next door neighbor had a small tree growing in his back yard. When it fell down, he was more than happy for me to clean it up in exchange for the wood. He called it "Hedge", and not knowing any better, I thought it was Osage Orange. So I experimented with it. He definitely got the better end of the bargain, because cleaning it up was definitely a hazardous operation.

http://ediblelandscaping.com/products/tropicals/Citrus/FlyingDragonTrifoliateOrange.php

It is hardy as far north as Zone 6, and grows here in southern NJ.

To get an idea of why it makes a good hedge, browse some of these Google images.

http://www.google.com/search?q=trifoliata+flying+dragon&newwindow=1&client=safari&rls=en&tbm=isch&tbo=u&source=univ&sa=X&ei=A6gcUt-XFKizsATioIGIAg&ved=0CC8QsAQ&biw=1806&bih=936

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

#24

Dale Lenz

Wiley...

Dale Lenz

I'm a forester and often make house calls for sick yard trees. Dogwoods grow in nature in the shade of other trees. Might try a shady spot in your yard.

Re: Favorite hammer for mortising

#25

Re: Mallets, handles, beetle...

Patrick Gibbons

I'm very familiar with its hedge-making qualities. My sister got a cutting from my aunt who got it from my grandmother. She gave it to my other sister. My other sister ended up having to get rid of it. The thorns were too much for her. It grows big and fast, from what I remember. Here in Texas you're more apt to see bois d'arc, or horse apple as we called it. In Mississippi, where my mother was from, it was this plant. I'll have to call my sister and see if she still has it. Once again, I really am glad you posted. It's nice to know about the wood. It's my understanding that orange wood has good qualities for handles and other uses.