New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Why panel saws?

Posts

Why panel saws?

#1

Why panel saws?

Tony Wilkins

In reading books and articles by C. Schwarz on saws, he universally says that cabinet makers prefer panel saws. I'm not understanding why exactly. Besides 'fitting in the tool chest', is there another reason? My thinking, which may indeed be faulty, is that if they are to be used at a saw bench (which he also says) then why wouldn't you want the all the length of a saw that you could fit. I've also seen things suggested in sizing a saw that you want it extend as far down as it can without hitting the floor beneath the saw bench.

So what am I missing? What are the reasons for a panel saw that I'm not getting?

Re: Why panel saws?

#2

A couple of thoughts

Ron Harper

First....fitting in the tool box is a big deal for some folks.

Second.. Many of us do not use the full length of our saws

Third....some of us do a lot of sawing on our regular bench.. In vises. Or against stops. The panel saw can be really useful here

Ron

Re: Why panel saws?

#3

Re: Another Thought

Ron in Sterling, CT

I find a panel saw easier to control, especially when cutting smaller pieces, or doing more precision work.

Ron

Re: Why panel saws?

#4

Re: Why panel saws?

Charles Stanford

Much more control, shorter blade is stiffer and doesn't whip in the kerf as readily (with the caveat that nobody here has ever had a saw whip in the kerf but me), more convenient to use when workpiece is in the vise, cuts gentle curves better, easier to bring back on line, easier to start, easier to gauge square to the workpiece, convenient size for large tenons (even in crosscut configuration).

Seems like all of the older British woodworking manuals routinely recommended panel saws and I believe for good reason.

Re: Why panel saws?

#5

Re: Why panel saws?

Ken Martin

I started looking for panel saws after I took a boatbuilding class as the instructor said they were handy for working in a boat where you don't have room.

I was glad to have a 16" panel saw when my niece was small and wanted to saw some wood. A 26" saw would have been too big for her.

Ken

Re: Why panel saws?

#6

Re: Why panel saws?

Tony

Thanks for all the replies. I guess I'm such a sucky sawyer that I haven't noticed a big difference between my 26" and 20" saws as far as control lol

Re: Why panel saws?

#7

Re: Why panel saws? *LINK*

Paul Dzioba

Tony,

No reason that you can’t use a full size saw. Not all of us have a rack full of saws optimized for every situation. Cabinet makers like a shorter panel saw for all the reasons mentioned in the other posts. What was not mentioned is that it would probably be a finer tooth saw around 11 points. That is a lot of teeth to sharpen and maintain on a large saw. The preserved tool chest of Benjamin Seaton, an 18th century cabinet maker, contained only 2 handsaws (but 4 back saws). One was a 5 point rip and the other was an 8 point. There is debate on how the 8 point would be filed, mine would be xcut. Both saws were 26” if I recall.

Paul


Seaton Tool Chest book at TFWW

Re: Why panel saws?

#8

Re: Why panel saws?

Patrick Gibbons

In The Practical Woodworker, which was put together about the time of the First World War, it is mentioned that cross cut saws are usually about 6 teeth to the inch and rip saws are infrequently used because of the use of machine sawing. Panel saws have as many teeth as a tenon saw and can be used as a substitute for the rip, tenon and crosscut saws though it cannot do the jobs as well as the dedicated saw. Most panel saws are 22", it is noted. So the panel saw is a fine-toothed saw that can be utilized in multiple situations that would be encountered in finer work- cabinetmaking, rather than carpentry.