New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

How was this done?

Posts

How was this done?

#1

How was this done?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi All,

Would appreciate your thoughts and opinions. About how an old bit of ornament was done.

First, take a look at this picture:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/9482999056/in/set-72157635012252891/lightbox/

My question has to do with those inverted 'V' marks inside the flowers. The recess for the flower itself was likely punched directly into the leg posts with gouges (using the same template used to make the flower). I suspect the accents inside the flower would have been made after the flower was installed in its recess--otherwise there would have been a big risk of splitting the flower.

In any event, how do you suppose those inverted V's were struck in the flowers? The first thing that comes to my mind is that he used gouges, about 4-sweep. I tried it, and it's hard to get the thing just right--the gouge strike is deeper and wider at the apex, then tails off to a wispy nothing.

It's like a fine brush stroke, maybe it is painted on, but somehow I doubt it. I think the inverted V's are incised, then filled with something.

The hard thing to do is to get that 'tailing off' brush stroke effect. Reminds me of the way these brush strokes tail off:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/9482947006/lightbox/

All thoughts appreciated!

Wiley

Re: How was this done?

#2

Re: How was this done?

William Duffield

Photo from Montgomery?

It would be easier to figure out if not for the printing (silkscreen) effects.

How would I do it? I'd incise them with a gouge that I'd resharpened with some camber (fingernail shape) instead of straight across. First, I'd seal the flowers with shellac, then incise them, then rub in some filler with ebony dust, then seal with shellac and scrape them clean and recoat with shellac. If you don't seal the lighter color before you work in the ebony, and then seal again before scraping, you get ebony dust distributed throughout the lighter colored wood, which you definitely don't want.

However, I don't think these were done with an incision. They are too irregular. I'd guess they were cut with a scalpel, with two cuts, like you would do with a chip carving.

There's not enough detail in the photo for me to figure out how the spots on the petals might have been done.

If you want a definitive answer, ask Steve Latta or Brock Jobe.

Re: How was this done?

#3

Re: How was this done?

Hank Knight

Wiley,

I would guess a small, sharp V chisel, but that's purely a guess. Mary May will know if anyone does. E-mail her, she'll answer: marymaycarving@yahoo.com.

Hank

Re: How was this done?

#4

Re: How was this done?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Thanks for your thoughts, Sir Wm.!

Agree with you on sealing precautions, and also the ebony dust filling. I have been experimenting with (1) precoating w/shellac, (2) incising with knife or gouge, (3) filling with Behlen's burn-in shellac sticks, (3) lightly planing or scraping that back til clean, (4) recoating w/shellac. I think your ebony dust idea may be better (mixed with Old Brown Glue), because it avoids the Behlen's shellac melting into the base shellac, and requiring a deeper planing or scraping than the ebony dust/glue combination would.

I also think you're right about the original incisions being made by knife. Because of their irregularity. There has to be irregularity or it looks machine-stamped--question is whether I can do that better with a gouge or a knife. So far, my best cuts have been with a 3-sweep 5mm gouge--have ordered a 4-sweep 6mm from Joel, which I think will be the right size.

The spots on the petals look for all the world like they're stabbed in with a big needle--I've been using the little stabber on the butt end of a Starrett square--it's about right. May not include those spots though--still experimenting.

One comment though--thank God for holly, it works so beautifully!

Thanks again!

Wiley

Re: How was this done?

#5

Re: How was this done?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Thank you, Hank!

I've seen Mary May's name here quite a bit--glad to know she is approachable.

It happens I have a small v-tool, from this very useful set*:

http://www.leevalley.com/US/Wood/page.aspx?p=31101&cat=1,130,43332,43337&ap=1

At your suggestion, I tried it and it has possibilities! More skill than just rolling an incision with a straight gouge, but has a bold look.

Thanks for your ideas!

Wiley

*The straight chisel from that set I ground down to 1/32", and it's the perfect thing (along with magnifying glasses!) to detail the corners and ends of stringing channels.

Re: How was this done?

#6

Re: How was this done?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

It is hard to see just how this was done without the original at hand and maybe a loupe to see better. Here is what I would do. Use a shallow gouge like you said. Hold it straight up except that it is leaning to one side and hand press one corner in at the top of the figure. Then roll the gouge with pressure until the other corner just begins to cut. The lower corner of the gouge must not go in far because that will wreck the fine point. Do both outside cuts this way.

For the inside cuts, angle the gouge back on the bevel about 20 degrees and cut again with the one corner lower. The reason for the 20 degree angle is so the cuts meet and a chip comes loose. The excavation will be deepest at the top and coming to nothing at the bottom. In trying it last night, I did it all without a mallet and did not roll the interior cuts. The rolling of the gouge makes the outside radius a little irregular; a good carver can vary the radius cut by a single gouge by rolling like this. I was making an inverted V in about 10 seconds.

Re: How was this done?

#7

Much thanks Warren!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Yes, that works! It never occurred to me to make inside and outside cuts, but the main effect is a strong apex at the top of the V. It may be that ending the second cut just a hair shy and a hair light is the way to keep the V tailing off. Still working on that point.

At this point, I am rolling the gouge just because the 3 sweep isn't quite enough curve, and the 5mm isn't quite enough length. With the 4 sweep that's coming, a straight cut may work best.

I grind long bevels on these gouges, for acute cutting angles, like around 20 degrees. Not that I'm a carver, or even competent--just what seems like it works best. Do you have a preference on the cutting angle of gouges?

Thanks again,

Wiley