New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Equipping my self to saw sharpen

Posts

Equipping my self to saw sharpen

#1

Equipping my self to saw sharpen

Tony Wilkins

I've finally watched enough videos and read enough books and articles to give it a go sharpening my dull Disston D8 thumbhole rip saw. I've got the clamp/saw holding figured out but I don't have any files. I know I need a mill file to joint and a saw file to sharpen - the question is where's the best place to get them.

Also, it seems that when it comes down to reading about the quality of files made today, there just doesn't seem to be any quality available. Before I worked up the courage I was going to see about sending it up to techno primitives to have him sharpen it. After reading the latest file test over on SMC, I'm back to wondering if that isn't the best option.

Re: Equipping my self to saw sharpen

#2

Re: Equipping my self to saw sharpen

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Tony,

One thing about letting a professional do the first sharpening, is that you will then know what a sharp saw feels like, and cuts like.

That sharpening should last a long time. You will have the opportunity to know what the saw cuts like freshly sharpened, and how that changes over time with use.

When you want to sharpen a rip saw yourself, that saw will give you something to compare to.

Wiley

Re: Equipping my self to saw sharpen

#3

Re: Equipping my self to saw sharpen

Kevin French

To follow up on the last post, you can buy a cheap rip saw, practice on that until you can make it cut as well as the pro sharpened one. Then you'll be ready to sharpen your good one.

Re: Equipping my self to saw sharpen

#4

Re: Equipping my self to saw sharpen

Patrick Gibbons

I like the new sharpening guide that Veritas makes. Lee Valley and Tools for Working Wood are both good places to get files and handles. What others said above is great advice. Don't learn how on your good saw.

Re: Equipping my self to saw sharpen

#5

Re: Picture of the teeth..

david weaver

Hi tony, can you show us a picture of the teeth, perhaps with a ruler along the toothline.

We can get an idea of how much there is to do with the sharpening, if it's very little then it's a do it yourself job. If it's more, then you have a decision to make.

I can't disagree with wiley, but if money is tight, I would spend the money on a professional with a crosscut saw as that's likely to cause you more trouble than a rip saw.

Re: Equipping my self to saw sharpen

#6

Actually, I've

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

changed my mind. I like David's answer better than the one I gave. Because doing things and hands-on learning is more important (in certain situations like this one) than being cautious and sensible. And your sharpening will likely improve the saw compared to the way it likely is now. I agree with David.

Wiley

Re: Equipping my self to saw sharpen

#7

Re: Actually, I've

david weaver

Wiley, I didn't mean to mangle your suggestion! It's perfectly reasonable, and well thought along the same lines as buying a LN or LV as a first plane.

First saw I ever sharpened was a rip saw. I remember thinking "what's the big deal?", and then the second saw that I sharpened was crosscut and the teeth weren't exactly perfect to start. Not quite so easy!

George Wilson mentioned to me (as I had said that it should be impossible for someone to not be able to sharpen a saw with a little experience) that they did have craftsmen at Wmsbg who were capable of dead copying very fine work, and at the same time, being unable to sharpen a saw without ruining the teeth.

At any rate, based on my experience sharpening saws, better to start with a rip saw with not so many teeth than a 28" miter box saw.

Re: Equipping my self to saw sharpen

#8

How long should a sharpening last?


Re: Equipping my self to saw sharpen

#9

Re: How long should a sharpening last?

david weaver

It depends on a lot of things. You could build a lot of small projects on a single sharpening or a couple of large ones, but if you do go the route of building all solid wood and ripping by hand, you will have the urge to touch up the saw fairly often because of how physical ripping is and how satisfying it is when a rip saw is cutting slivers and chunks instead of rasping off dust.

That frequent touch up is one of the best reasons to sharpen your own saws. You'll see tutorials or commentary about needing to joint a saw every single time you sharpen, but that is just not necessary once you've got some experience.

Touching up should be quick, like 5-10 minutes in a rip saw like you've got. Jointing makes the process take a lot longer unless you joint very very lightly.

Re: Equipping my self to saw sharpen

#10

Re: Actually, I've

Peter Evans

If the D8 is a good saw with pretty reasonable teeth, should not be too much trouble to sharpen. If you need to shape the teeth, another story. In that case, buy a cheap saw at the flea and practice on that.

Files are another matter, I have a pretty good stock of NOS, so can put off the evil day. I have been part of some file testing recently, and suggest you get hold of a Bahco; depending on the ppi, a 6" Slim should work well on a rip. At the hardware store, insist on examining each file with a magnifier, particularly the corners. QC is a lost art it seems in file manufacture, and the corners are the key to a good saw file. An indicator of file quality is the standard of the grinding, which can easily be observed on the uncut part of the file near the handle - if the grinding is poor, the teeth cannot be ok.

Bahco are the only saw files made in Europe (Portugal), the rest are mostly made in India - irrespective of brand. They may even come from the same factory. Check out the websites of the file "makers" - they do not actually say where the files are made (Nicholson do state on the packaging, if you look hard enough, the files are made in Mexico or Brazil). You will note that the brand and other text is printed on the file, not struck as in the old days.

Having said that, you can get a fair result, even from a crook file - of course the crook files will not last long.

Re: Equipping my self to saw sharpen

#11

Re: Actually, I've

david weaver

Yes, bahco. Autotoolworld.com (just drop ships from williams tool for anyone in the US - no affiliation on my part, of course).

The "emergency" that's been declared lately is a bit overstated given our ability to get the bahco files inexpensively here, and the last 40 that I received are beautifully made - really surprisingly good for anything made these days for so cheap. The only thing I could see as an issue with them is those preferring narrow gullets could criticize them. That, to me is not a real problem. Or perhaps that they don't seem to have xx slim forging dies (we can limp around that pretty easily).

It will be more of a problem if bahco backs out, but perhaps we should be writing williams tool to thank them for making good files.

I once tried to email cooper tools in support of good tools, but that was a completely fruitless effort.

At any rate, bahcos, excellent files. Too bad they're not in the local hardware stores here, but neither was anything of coopers other than 7 and 6" files, anyway.