New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Will Bald Cypress damage iron, like Cedar?

Posts

Will Bald Cypress damage iron, like Cedar?

#1

Will Bald Cypress damage iron, like Cedar?

Bruce McCrory

The title says it. We are advised to avoid cedar when building tool boxes (to reduce weight) since is adversely reacts to the iron. But I can't remember or find information regarding the same for Cypress. This is Taxodium distichum.

Re: Will Bald Cypress damage iron, like Cedar?

#2

Re: Will Bald Cypress damage iron, like Cedar?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bruce and all,

Are you speaking of woods that pick up iron stains? If so, any wood with much tannin in it will stain in the presence of iron (and moisture). Here's a reference, which includes oak, redwood, cedar, and cypress as examples. It's the tannin content:

http://www.fpl.fs.fed.us/documnts/finlines/finishline_mknaebe_2013_006.pdf

Wiley

Re: Will Bald Cypress damage iron, like Cedar?

#3

If corrosion is the point, caused by the wood

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

generating acetic acid in the presence of moisture, here is a reference:

http://www.vam.ac.uk/content/journals/conservation-journal/issue-04/corrosion-of-metals-associated-with-wood/

Quote: "Oak, sweet chestnut, Western red cedar and Douglas fir are the woods most commonly associated with corrosion of metals in contact with them under damp conditions." [Cypress not listed.]

There's almost got to be a US Forest Products Lab article on this subject, but I didn't find it.

Wiley

Re: Will Bald Cypress damage iron, like Cedar?

#4

Re: If corrosion is the point, caused by the wood

Bruce McCrory

Thanks, Wiley. Yes, your second point was my interest, in this case. Now, I see why Western Cedar is so caustic to metals. I forgot, and used steel wool on my cedar chairs last year. Oh, boy! Black freckles all over the place. And, hardly a day after doing the deed!

Doug Fir is problematic--so common here on the West Coast, USA. I don't think it is so troublesome, however. Rusting is not more significant in it than other wood species that I have exposed. In my recent repair/remodel, I recycled several studs that were used over 25 years ago. The biggest culprit seems to be moisture.

I am going to use some cypress for one of my tool box projects. I don't know how, or why it got here, but it showed up in fencing pickets I salvaged a few years ago. The stuff has been off-gassing for 20-odd years.

Re: Will Bald Cypress damage iron, like Cedar?

#5

Re: If corrosion is the point, caused by the wood

William Duffield

On the Cohansey, you don't even need the steel wool. The tap water has enough iron to leave spots in oak if you use it for raising grain. That's why I have a jug of demineralized water in the shop.

If you do get iron stains, oxalic acid works very well, and is cheap and readily available at the grocery store. It's one of the two active ingredients (along with talc) in Bar Keeper's Friend. A damp paste and a grey scotchbrite (or Norton equivalent) pad and a little elbow grease will chemically deactivate the stain. I've been using it for years on oak, and many other stained items around our house, and had the chance this week to prove it also works very well on old growth southern yellow pine, but that's another, long, involved story.

Re: Will Bald Cypress damage iron, like Cedar?

#6

Re: Looking for wood safe for tool storage

Bruce McCrory

Sorry, William. I am trying to identify woods that can be used for tool boxes. Trying to get one that is light. And, common.

Twenty pounds, before a single tool is placed, is a lot of weight to me. My tool working, or wood working, depends on moving tools to various locales. So weight is a critical element in the box construction.

Of course, I could use steel; or, plastic. But, wood can acquire a certain ... ah, ... fragrance over time; so it isn't always the best material either.

Re: Will Bald Cypress damage iron, like Cedar?

#7

Re: Looking for wood safe for tool storage

William Duffield

I understand there are two different, and diametrically opposed questions here: Will the iron damage the wood? (Not your question), or will the wood damage the tools?

I haven't heard any reports of Taxodium damaging wood, and it is relatively light. You might also consider white pine, which because it is not rot resistant, doesn't have as many extractives as the woods that are rot resistant. It is also light weight. You will get expert advise from Chris Schwarz, in blog posts and DVDs on the subject of the "Traitor's Tool Chest". Following are all the links I could currently find on this subject, but still it seems that something essential is missing:

http://www.popularwoodworking.com/woodworking-blogs/chris-schwarz-blog/the-traitors-tool-chest-now-available-on-dvd

http://www.popularwoodworking.com/woodworking-blogs/chris-schwarz-blog/rethinking-the-traditional-tool-chest

https://www.lostartpress.com/ProductDetails.asp?ProductCode=DVD_TRAITOR

http://www.popularwoodworking.com/workbenches/schwarz-workbenches/some-upcoming-woodworking-projects-with-popular-woodworking

It seems like any spruce or fir would also fill the bill. Choosing wood that has reached EMC with your shop is very important. The safest strategy would be to seal the inside of the chest and the drawers to keep whatever the wood has in it from ever reaching the tools. For this, you can't beat shellac. OTOH, I think sealing it is probably unnecessary, as I've seen a few centuries worth of tool chests that were not finished on the inside.

Re: Will Bald Cypress damage iron, like Cedar?

#8

Re: Looking for wood safe for tool storage

Robin Corell in Atascadero,CA

Wood choice will largely depend on the style of tool box you plan on making but two of the best woods for tool storage are camphor and powlonia. Both are a bit hard to find but I've seen both on the west coast.

Robin

Re: Will Bald Cypress damage iron, like Cedar?

#9

Re: Looking for wood safe for tool storage

William Duffield

Paulownia tomentosa is not difficult to find here in West Jersey. :D Around here, it is an invasive tree, and comes up in all the forested areas and hedge rows. It seems like it can grow 10' in a year. Of course, what you want for tool boxes is old growth trees, and not these, which are incredibly light because of the fast rate of growth. I think I've seen balsa with more integrity. The Japanese prefer it for its stability, once dried, and its rot resistance, and its traditions. I'm not sure it's funny, but lots of people in these parts falsely think they'll make a fortune when they sell their weed trees to the Japanese. Wikipedia has interesting articles on the genus Paulownia and the species Paulownia tomentosa.

Note also that kiln dried wood has some advantages for tool chests, as the heat will volatilize everything that is volatile (extractives, sap, bugs, etc.) that might attack the tools if it remained in its liquid form, but I'm not naming any species here.

Re: Will Bald Cypress damage iron, like Cedar?

#10

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Looking for wood safe for tool storage

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Why not use poplar? Cheap,relatively light, and pretty much 'inert.'

Re: Will Bald Cypress damage iron, like Cedar?

#11

Yeah, poplar or pine...

John in NM

Or if fancy pants is desirable, some type of mahogany.

I can't recall ever seeing a wood box rust a tool, there's just not enough moisture to see an effect similar to nails in a cedar fence. If it's a real concern, finish the inside and be done with it. Shellac, milk paint + oil, varnish, whatever.

Re: Will Bald Cypress damage iron, like Cedar?

#12

Re: Will Bald Cypress damage iron, like Cedar?

Patrick Gibbons

I am building a portable tool chest out of cypress. The plans and wood choice both came from The Practical Woodworker, edited by Bernard Jones. Also to calm your fears I will bring to your attention a tool chest my brother in law owns that had been his grandfather's. His grandfather had worked for a mill in Dayton, Texas, northeast of Houston. On leaving he was gifted with a chest made of cypress with yellow pine plinths for protection. The chest is over 100 years old and was reportedly made by a craftsman on premises who knew what he was doing. Cypress seems to have been the wood to use here on the bayou. It works like a dream and is very similar to poplar in weight and strength. It also is good around the high moisture and humidity here and remains stable. I'll be using it for my tool chest if and when I finally get to it.

Re: Will Bald Cypress damage iron, like Cedar?

#13

Re: Will Bald Cypress damage iron, like Cedar?

Bruce McCrory

Hey, did Schwarz steal his tool chest design from Bernard Jones? I checked your reference, Mr. Gibbons, and there is a chest the spitting image of Chris'. Only it's over 130 years older than the one Chris claims. 1/2" pine, even 5/8" for cypress, seems light. Maybe, inside tills. But for the sake of portability, maybe...

Cypress and poplar are specialty woods in our area. I may have seen camphor with the turning blocks. Would love to try them. However part of the portable box project is to use what I already have. I might consider Western Cedar in a panel for frame and panel layout, or for drawer floors, but it is very easy to split.

Also, this project is semi-prototypical. Of course, everything I do is a first. Boredom and forever tweaking are my bad habits. For me, a plan is just a concept that could work.

Ding! A light bulb moment. I will park some steel/iron on cedar and cypress. Maybe bag them up. And, see what happens. Do it to pine and Doug fir, too.

Re: Will Bald Cypress damage iron, like Cedar?

#14

Re: Schwartz didn't steal, but...

Patrick Gibbons

Tool chests are amazingly similar. I have three different plans and all have dimensions within an inch or so of each other. The one my brother in law has is smaller in height and width, but I've seen others on the Internet that measure about the same, such as the one Roy Underhill had published in Pop Wood. To what extent they need to be portable is the obvious factor. Contrary to what many think, a full-sized-chest is not intended to be moved. It's meant to be compact.

Re: Will Bald Cypress damage iron, like Cedar?

#15

Re: Looking for wood safe for tool storage

Bruce McCrory

Famous last words ... I said earlier that poplar was not common and definitely not inexpensive in the Puget Sound region. Today, I grabbed 40 feet on sale at HD for less than #2 pine demands.

Re: Will Bald Cypress damage iron, like Cedar?

#16

Surprising...

John in NM

Have you tried Rugby Architectural Building Products in Kent? Rugby bought out Lumber Products in 2012, and the yard in Albuquerque is the place I go for most hardwood lumber. I'd be very surprised if yellow poplar was more than $3/bdft there, and they often stock rough and hit or miss planed (15/16") material in Albuquerque. Being able to get thicker stuff is a big plus for me.

They sell to anyone who pays, don't mind a little board choosing, and charge me wholesale regardless of how small the sale is. Guys in the office are friendly and have mostly been there as long as I've been going there.

Of course I've never been to the yard in Kent, so it might be worth a quick call before you try them out.

Re: Will Bald Cypress damage iron, like Cedar?

#17

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: Looking for wood safe for tool storage

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Puget Sound? If I were back up there (Lived there in the 1970s), I'd use Alder for my toolbox. Oughtta be cheap and plentiful there.

About ten years ago, it was cheaper than Poplar in Southern California, so I'd guess it was even cheaper yet in WA, where it's so plentiful.

As a side note: Back in the 70s, we thought it was only good for firewood. I burned about three cords of Alder a year. The loggers just bulldozed it aside to get at the maple and Doug fir.

Re: Will Bald Cypress damage iron, like Cedar?

#18

Re: Surprising...

Bruce McCrory

They sell to you because you are nice. :) The poplar from HD is the first I will try. I associate it with newsprint, so walked past it at the yards. Would have considered the species had it been cheaper than pine shelving.

I must check out Rugby. I worked nearby for years but did not know about the lumber yard. After Ikea moved in, just west, I avoided that whole section of roads due to traffic. Saturday and Sunday, the freeway there was a parking lot.

I am cheap. Really cheap. Used to scrap hunt and dumpster dive at a custom cabinet shop near there too. They tossed all kinds of exotics, besides the maple and cherry.

Re: Will Bald Cypress damage iron, like Cedar?

#19

Re: Looking for wood safe for tool storage

Bruce McCrory

Alder is found in many vintage furniture offerings that were made in this region. I do have alder shelves made in Oregon. It was called the "Great Imposter", because it could be finished to look like maple and cherry. I only see it at one of our region's specialty lumber stores. Along with the rare madrone board. These you should recognize as the premium of Pac. N.W. firewoods.

That said I have some half-inch and 5/8 Alder I salvaged from an old chest of drawers I got for a song. (And, I don't sing.) I was going to incorporate some of the wood in the box build. For drawers.

In a recent trip to said yard, Alder was pushing $3.50, and Madrone competing with endangered exotics--which it is, endangered. Typical Eastern USA lumber runs $4, and up. Of course, these numbers are from a couple months ago; and, they probably doubled since. >(

Re: Will Bald Cypress damage iron, like Cedar?

#20

Alder

Steve Elliott

I like alder better than poplar although it doesn't show up in wide planks like poplar. Alder planes well leaving a smooth, lustrous surface. I don't know for sure that it doesn't interact badly with steel tools but I'm not aware of a problem there. It dents easily because it's soft but has good resistance to splitting.