New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Inlay Question

Posts

Inlay Question

#1

Inlay Question

Tony - Memphis

The birthday fairy brought me a straight line and radius cutter from LN (Steve Latta design). Something I've noticed playing around with them is that the sawtooth cutter leaves a ridge in the center of the groove. Has anybody used this type of cutter? What did you do about that? Going deep enough for the peak of the ridge to be deeper than the inlay is quite a bit of effort as is cleaning it out. I noticed that Steve does some cleaning in his videos. Any tips would be appreciated. These things aren't as simple to use as one would think! I've been a little surprised. One has to be very careful. It is easy for the cutter to skip out of the cut.

Tony

Re: Inlay Question

#2

Re: Inlay Question

William Duffield

If it were easy, everyone would be doing it, instead of jumping on the Shaker bandwagon. :O

I have the L-N/Latta radius cutter, but made my own straight line cutter. Just about everyone I know who does Federal stringing or Line and Berry uses one of them.

It is easy for the cutter to skip out of the cut.

I've talked to Chuck Bender about his techniques, and he agrees with you about the radiusing tool. He finds that a homemade tool, ground from a compass, works better, because it is much easier to control, because it is much less likely to roll over on its side. Of course, it has its own set of disadvantages, and isn't nearly as pretty as the L-N tool. I provided photos of Chuck's tool and details of the cutter grind in a post a few months ago.

http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/handtools.pl/pro/search/pmd/sread/srchid/198483OYqPIoAx4tft9k1374679421/spage/1/sanc/463940/sbid/3000/md/read/id/463940/sbj/on-the-merits-of-the-divider/

The cleaning up that Steve does is only to remove the dust and to get the intersections of the ends of the grooves even. There is no need for the bottoms of the grooves to be flat. They'll be filled with hide glue, and the sides of the stringing and grooves provides plenty of glue surface.

Once you've got the technique and the tools "down", a few more passes to cut the groove a little deeper doesn't take much time at all, and makes cleaning out the grooves easier, because the support provided by the higher sides keeps your cleanup tools from blowing out the sides of the grooves, leaving you with defects that show on the surface.

For clean out tools, I've used small chisels that I ground into the ends of worn out triangular saw files. They're easy to make. Putting a comfortable handle on them is easier than handling dental picks and the other shop made tools that Steve shows.

Re: Inlay Question

#3

Re: Inlay Question

Tony - Memphis

Thanks. I did some samples and didn't worry about the bottom - just made sure the inlay was just above the surface. Those actually turned out ok. Tried to do a 90° the other day and it turned out fair. Practice....

Tony

Re: Inlay Question

#4

Re: Inlay Question

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Tony and all,

Tony, I have the Latta sawtooth straight line stringing tool. Let me say to begin with that I have the greatest respect for Steve Latta and Lie-Nielsen Toolworks. There's no question in my mind that this tool works for Steve Latta and others (perhaps Bill Tindall could comment, since he took Steve's class).

That said, I make the same observations you do. That it's very easy for the tool to skip out of the cut. You can't feel it doing it, so it requires constant attention. The cutter is a section of crosscut saw: as such, it makes a cleaner cut cross grain than long-grain. Long-grain, it will try to follow grain and works best when you're scoring in the direction where the grain is pulling the cutter into the work, rather than pushing it away--this is important IME.

Overall though, I get the most reliable results from a plough type cutter--a single tooth. And this is both cross grain and long grain. I really like these two:

1. Home Made Tool...This was a gift from Konrad Sauer, after he returned from a Garrett Hack class. This tool is so simple, you don't at first understand its advantages, or I didn't at any rate:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/8063422865/in/set-72157631713450111

It's compact and it registers square against the work edge. This obviates any tendency to let the tool wiggle left to right as you're scoring, which will wallow out the channel. This tool makes an incomparably clean channel. Konrad made this one with threaded inserts and thumbscrews, which is typical of everything he does--highly professional. A piece of sawsteel, or scraper steel, or 35-thousandths 1095 (hardened) from McMaster Carr for the cutter. Grind a tooth on the steel stock.

2. Preston Stringing Router. I bought this years ago from Tony Murland, along with some hardened blanks to grind teeth onto. It's a great tool:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/9372393160/in/set-72157631713450111

Tooth Preparation. The key to these plough type (single tooth) stringing cutters is how you prepare the tooth. It has to be dead square and sharp on all 5 faces (don't forget the bottom face, it's critical). I can provide more detail if anyone is interested.

What I find is that the single tooth cutter is the perfect thing for long grain cuts--it will pull up a plane shaving for you. It will even work cross-grain, provided that you shellac the surface you're working, so that the surface fibers are 'glued' together and resist tearing. Start all cuts, long and cross, making light cuts with the cutter at an angle--this is intuitive and I imagine everyone will automatically do it. Visualize that you're trying to ease your way through the surface fibers, and get a little depth, say 1/32" deep, before you really start ploughing for speed. If you're aggressive early (and this is true with the sawtooth cutter as well) it's easy to tear the surface, depending on the lay of the grain.

Later edition: Something I forgot...with the single-tooth cutters, you grind the cutter to the width you need, based on what looks right on your project. You're not locked into the width of the sawtooth. Of course, one can make ones own sawtooth in the stock width that's needed, but it's way simpler to grind the tooth to size.

Wiley

Re: Inlay Question

#5

Re: Inlay Question

William Duffield

Here's another photo of Wiley's Preston Stringing Cutter, showing the scraper blades and the depth adjusting mechanism. Note that the fence is reversible: one end is flat, the other end is convex, for following curves.


I have a different quirk router by Preston. I bought it from Tony Murland, as well.


It is supplied with three fences, one flat, and two convex, with different radii. This one has some very unusual cutters. Here are three cutters, clamped business end up in a face vise. The blade holding mechanism on this one is more complicated than the one Wiley has, because it needs to hold blades of different thicknesses.


And here is an extreme close-up. They kind of remind me of pirañas.


They kind of work like a dado plane, with the front edge of the blade acting as two nickers, and the back edge chipping out the wood between the kerfs cut by the nickers. In these photos, the blades would cut up and to the right. The disadvantages are that they can't turn a really tight radius, and the blades are really tricky to sharpen. Also, you have to remove a lot of steel if you want to use stringing that's thinner than one of the blades you have for the tool. Its advantage is that it works well on soft and/or stringy woods that are not amenable to a scraper (for example, Sitka spruce, Picea sitchensis, or Engelmann spruce, Picea engelmannii, for a guitar top). Also, you can bamboozle your dilettante woodworking friends by simply pulling one of the blades out of your pocket.

Re: Inlay Question

#6

Which do you prefer?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi William and all,

Excellent photos, esp. those showing the cutters. I'm curious--if you yourself were making a straight 1/32" channel, which tool would you grab? Or would it all depend? Please consider this an open-ended question--I'm just trying to get at what folks actually do, especially the professionals like yourself.

Wiley

Re: Inlay Question

#7

Re: Which do you prefer?

William Duffield

Who me? A professional? Well, I guess I used to be, kinda.

Right now, I use this homemade gizmo, which I posted back in March. The thread has three posts with pictures and explanations and warnings.

http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/handtools.pl/pro/search/pmd/sread/srchid/1175q9BcM2zFr2FIUuC1374948947/spage/1/sanc/465781/sbid/3000/md/read/id/465767/sbj/made-a-tool/

The reason for making it instead of just buying the L-N straight line stringing cutter is because with it I'm assured of getting the same width grooves for both straight and curved stringing. However, as with most of what I build, it came out a bit larger and heavier than it needs to be. I'm using the two tooth L-N cutters, but I would like to cut three teeth into the other end of the cutters, which, like the L-N would be optimized for straight lines instead of curved lines.

Note that I haven't gotten back to making any of the improvements we discussed in the original post, because I've been overwhelmed for the last few months with a chimney and fireplace project which is going to continue to consume all my time and shop space for another couple months at least. So, take everything I said with a grain of salt.

Maybe Bill Tindall will offer some better advise than I have for you. Since he's gotten one-on-one instruction from Steve Latta and used it, he would be able to offer some really professional advise, or even better, some really serious, dedicated amateur advise. I've seen lots of work by serious amateurs that is far superior to much of the work done by "get-it-done-and-get-paid" professionals. I'm not saying that professionals don't do professional quality work, because many of them do, but often their customers are not willing to pay the price for museum quality work, and they know the "Joneses" next door don't know any better.