New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Rough first impressions LN #5 versus LV #4 1/2

Posts

Rough first impressions LN #5 versus LV #4 1/2

#1

Rough first impressions LN #5 versus LV #4 1/2

Tony Wilkins

Got my LN #5 yesterday afternoon and got my LV #4 1/2 (BD) on Friday afternoon. This morning was my first chance to set them up and use them in anger on wood. I was quite surprised by what I found. First, the difference in the 'prettiness' of the tool was not as large as what the online pictures would have me believe. The LV ain't a bad lookin' tool.

I'll say it just flat out. I much prefer the LV to the LN. The controls and feel in my hand is much better to me in the LV. So much so that I regret getting the LN. The LN might be a bit better when I open the mouth a bit but even the relative ease in that operation is a selling point for the veritas. I'm seeing where I could do a lot with a couple of extra blades on the 4 1/2.

BTW, also used my Old Street jack in the mix some. It is a lot lighter but I do like the lower hold and overall ergonomics of the metal planes better (especially the LV).

Thoughts on my thoughts and comments welcome.

Bonus question: would it be untoward to see about sending the LN back if I don't bond with it soon and exchanging it for more of their chisels (which I do like)?

Re: Rough first impressions LN #5 versus LV #4 1/2

#2

Re: Rough first impressions LN #5 versus LV #4 1/2

Bruce McCrory

You can't play with these tools at the store--there is no store, in a physical sense. So, the "store" shouldn't expect you to keep tools if they don't work for you.

Others on the forum may think differently, but those people are super rich and can afford to try to impress those of us who have more sense.

I almost ordered a LN hand plane, after trying everything I could get my hands onto; including one shipped from LV. But I realized most of the problems with them were not things the best makers could overcome. The LN would simply fix the quality flaws of a cheaper tool it cloned.

I guess, discretion is a caveat in this buy and return situation. I would have not felt good about sending back something I knew was not going to meet my needs when it was ordered.

Re: Rough first impressions LN #5 versus LV #4 1/2

#3

Outcome

Tony Wilkins

I decided to call and visit with LN. I laid all my cards on the table and they said they were certainly take it back. I plan to send it back and exchange it for a set of five chisels from them.

Re: Rough first impressions LN #5 versus LV #4 1/2

#4

Re: Rough first impressions LN #5 versus LV #4 1/2

cstanford

I followed the thread you posted in duplicate over on Sawmill Creek. From what I gathered over there, you seem to still be very much in the tool accumulation phase of the craft rather than the mature, discerning craftsman phase. Make note that there is a point at which you really want need any more tools other than to replace the odd chisel here or there that you've used beyond the point the manufacturer heat treated the steel. That implies a whole lot of woodworking under one's belt. Get busy.

Otherwise, nobody will be surprised at all to learn that Lie-Nielsen cheerfully refunded your money.

Re: Rough first impressions LN #5 versus LV #4 1/2

#5

Re: Rough first impressions LN #5 versus LV #4 1/2

cstanford

want should be won't....

Re: Rough first impressions LN #5 versus LV #4 1/2

#6

Re: Rough first impressions LN #5 versus LV #4 1/2

Tony Wilkins

I now feel as if I have the minimum kit pretty well settled (and probably plus some). I'm comfortable with the tools I have and am learning on using them. Thanks to all who took my somewhat random ride in finding my tool kit. On to the table and getting it finished.