New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Beginning prototyping

Posts

Beginning prototyping

#1

Beginning prototyping

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi All,

It's kinda slow these days, so thought I'd post some work-in-progress photos.

Project: Satinwood desk, elevation and a couple details. These are working concepts, and I'm prototyping now to decide on what paterae to put in the leg posts, whether to string the legs and sides, whether to use a black/white string for the leg posts and lower legs, or black, or white; whether to cross-band the drawer periphery, and so on.

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/8244326147/in/set-72157632172323442

What's Done So Far: The top is made, and requires only finally detailing and finishing:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/9276142351/in/set-72157632172323442

What's Next: The legs. I'm thinking leg posts 1-5/8" square, tapering below the drawer section, probably with stringing and cuffs. I don't think the final dimension will vary more than a 1/16" from 1-5/8"--but I can't really judge until the first fit-up. I've cut the leg blanks, but before doing anything else, I want to decide on what paterae to use on the upper leg posts, and what string color and pattern to use.

Possible paterae: I like the middle two shown below--the sprout and the single flower and pendant:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/9320429229/in/set-72157632172323442

Prototype in progress: Do either 'the sprout' or 'flower and pendant' appeal to you? Which is best? Any other suggestions--they're welcome. I'm going to start with the flower-and-pendant and see how that looks when inlaid on satinwood, using holly for the flower, and ebony for the pendant pieces. I have a feeling that some toning or sand-shading or graining will be needed for the flower, because the holly just comes out flat, blinding white. Well, we'll see. For right now, my best guess is to use a black/white string for the surround, and also for the lower legs if it looks right. There are two different construction methods for the paterae themselves: you can saw the parts and inlay them into a rectangle of veneer, and then inlay the whole rectangle into the leg post; or you can use gouges and stab the design directly into the leg posts, using similar stab methods to cut out the inlay pieces--this second method of direct inlay is what I've done before, and will start with on this one. What it means is that the design has to be entirely built up from gouge shapes--it will take four different gouges to make the flower, for example.

Anyway, I just glued down some prototype black/white stringing on a piece of satinwood. Visualize that this is the upper leg post. Once the glue dries, I'll plane it flush, then start laying in the first try at the paterae:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/9323271808/in/set-72157632172323442

Any and all suggestions are welcome--am at an early stage, and it's easy to consider changes at this point. Will report back on the first attempt at paterae inlay, and show what the black/white string looks like. The corners look a little sloppy in the glue-up--we'll see--they should be good enough to make a decision.

Wiley

Re: Beginning prototyping

#2

Re: Beginning prototyping

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Do either 'the sprout' or 'flower and pendant' appeal to you? Which is best?

Hi Wiley

The table is going to be grand. I look forward to seeing more. I also have a selfish interest as I am due to complete two demilune end tables (only delayed this about 5 years. Tables built but inlay still to do ...).

The sprout or the flower and pendant?

I would use the flower and pendant on table legs. It is a balanced, symmetrical shape that works within a narrow setting. The flower seems best to suit a wider expanse, such as a raised panel in a door.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Beginning prototyping

#3

Re: Beginning prototyping

Sgian Dubh

With a top at 30" high, and the bottom edge of the drawer box at 25" you've got a couple of challenges to work on. If your chair is 18" to the top of the seat you only have 7" for thigh room, which is too little in my experience. To increase thigh room you would obviously need to use a lower seat height. Now you might face a problem of incompatibility between seat height and writing surface height. I have always reckoned a 10" difference between seat and writing surface is the maximum for comfortable writing.

Currently I'm sitting at a desk 28-1/2" high on a chair with a seat 19-1/2" high-- I like a tall seat because I have long legs. That 9" difference is borderline for me regarding comfort and writing, sketching, etc. An inch or two more difference in heights between the two surfaces (seat to desk top) would make the two incompatible.

Overriding all the comments I've just made, I think that desk tops generally are better if no higher than about 28- 29", and an inch or two lower is better still-- this assumes the writing surface is truly intended for writing upon, not for holding a monitor, where the configuration allowing for comfortable computer, keyboard, printer, memory sticks use, etc can be somewhat different. Slainte.

Re: Beginning prototyping

#4

Re: Beginning prototyping

Steve Elliott

The desktop looks wonderful, Wiley. The proportions look right and the design brings out the richness of the figure in the satinwood.

With regard to the sprout vs. the flower-and-pendant, I find the sprout more appealing as a stand-alone composition because it has a sort of naïve freshness. That's not what I'd want on so refined a piece, so I would save the sprout for another piece (a desk for a child?) and use the flower and pendant.

Richard's point about comfortable thigh clearance is a good one. That said, I'm sitting at an old Sears and Roebuck sewing table from c. 1900 that works well for me as a computer desk and it has only 24-1/2" to the underside of the work surface. I'm average size (5" 10") and have enough clearance when sitting on a desk chair adjusted to a 17-1/2" height.

The proportions of your desk look very good in the elevation drawing. They might also look good if the drawer were reduced a little to provide more clearance. Before deciding I'd want to look at pictures of desks in that style and see what the collective judgment of previous makers had to say.

There are two issues that bother me just a little about your sketch. The legs taper enough to make me think they look too delicate, not structurally but just as a matter of appearance. Maybe another 1/8" of thickness at the bottom?

The knee brackets are the other thing that bother me. Their design is good but I think I might like the desk better without them. This is mostly a matter of personal taste, but I dislike many Victorian pieces because there's too much ornamentation. One definition of elegance is "simple but effective." For me your desk would be more effective and more elegant without the brackets.

Take my comments with a grain of salt. I'm not very knowledgeable about historical styles of furniture so I'm just looking at your design with a modern eye and a bunch of personal likes and dislikes. Overall I like the design very much.

Re: Beginning prototyping

#5

Re: Beginning prototyping--request of the group

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

I have carefully pored over your thoughts, Derek, Richard, and Steve. First off, thank you very much!! You are seeing things I would not see, as I have gotten into cyclical thinking on this project--more eyes are better!

I will go with the flower and pendant. That was my take too, but you never know what others will see that you may be missing.

Richard brought up sizing problems which go to the very purpose of the desk. The time is ripe to reconsider all these basics. I'm going to re-draw the project with a narrower drawer box, and perhaps a half-inch lower. The odd thing is that 30" height and 25" knee clearance and 18" chair is exactly what both my wife and I are used to! And like.

Request of the group: Could we do this please, this might help us all. Could you go to a desk you like to actually sit at and use (like Richard did), then measure the seat height, measure the distance from floor to bottom of drawer box (your knee clearance in other words), and measure from floor to desk top? And then report those three numbers--seat height, knee clearance, desk top height. That would be very helpful if you're willing. For myself, I'm sitting at a desk that I like which has desktop at 30", knee clearance at 25" (actual clearance of my knees is 1-1/2"), chair height 18", and I'm 5'11". Maybe I'm just putting up with it though; I can see how my elbows are higher than they need to be when I'm writing checks to pay bills. But then the writing is closer to my eyes, which is a benefit these days!

In any event, I think my desk top/drawer box height is too much for the size of the piece and won't even look right--so will redraw with an eye to making a change.

Steve brought up the skinny-leg issue. Partly that's an artifact of my sloppy drawing in the sketch I showed. Still, what are typical tapers on legs for desks that are 36-37" wide? I'm thinking of two numbers: the width at the drawer-box section, and the width at the floor. For this desk, I'm pretty sure I will like 1-5/8" at the drawer box, but am uncertain about the width at the floor--maybe somewhere in the 3/4" to 7/8" region. Visually that's a wide region, though only 1/8" differential, since the whole taper is affected. I may start with 7/8" at the first fit-up, and plane down from there by eye. But would welcome your experience, because it would be nice to only do the legs once, if anyone is pretty sure what is standard for the purpose.

Steve also brought up the fussy-knee-bracket issue. I've been puzzling over that as well. First, it kinda seemed to me that the desk could use the brackets. But weighing against that is the busyness. Cause once you put on knee brackets, there are 6 of them (I would omit the ones in the back face). And they're not insubstantial. The ones I showed copy a Seymour design, but the Seymour desks are larger with an upper tambour section, and altogether more elaborate and heavily ornamented. I'll make up one bracket and see how it looks at first fit-up, and make a final decision then. But for now, I'm leaning against doing it, for the reasons Steve gave.

To all: any further opinions are most welcome and useful.

Thanks again,

Wiley

Re: Beginning prototyping

#6

Re: Beginning prototyping--request of the group

Sgian Dubh

To add to your considerations Wiley, and to raise a point I decided to not pursue yesterday, I always think that a drawer in a writing desk directly in front of the sitter is less than convenient. If you're writing and you need something out of the drawer you will probably have to move your chair back to open it. In your case you have two drawers directly in front of the sitter, so potentially you have double the inconvenience. If you're using an office chair with wheels on the base, it's likely not too inconvenient, but if your chair has no wheels it's a bit of a pain at least.

So a solution might be to not have drawers in front of the sitter. You could, for instance, have two drawers one above the other to one side leaving the other side open under the writing surface. Or you could have two drawers, one either side with a gap between. Both these configurations give you the chance to lower the writing surface to something like 28" which would give you 10" above an 18" high chair seat, and therefore less of a need to scrunch up your shoulder uncomfortably when writing, and more thigh room.

Of course, these considerations set up a new design challenge which you may not want to undertake. But, I'll be honest, and say I am critical of the less than satisfactory ergonomics and functionality in your original design work. The decorations you're seeking to incorporate are really of only passing interest until the ergonomic challenge is resolved satisfactorily. The piece is intended to be functional if I understand your posts correctly so I think you need to find working solutions to identified necessary functions, and then finalise your preferred decoration and style. You can work on both of the functional and decorative elements together of course, but you'll have to decide what the balance between function and aesthetics needs to be. Slainte.

Re: Beginning prototyping

#7

Re: Beginning prototyping--request of the group

Steve Elliott

My usual writing surface is my dining table, which is at a 29-1/2" height. I'm so accustomed to it I can't really say whether it would be better if lower. Higher I wouldn't want.

On the issue Richard raised of a drawer in the front, I like a shallow drawer that can hold pens, pencils, erasers, paper clips, and all the other things that come in handy at a desk. A larger drawer to the side, or one on each side, would change the design considerably and make the desk a much heavier piece of furniture.

Using a shallower drawer would allow the writing surface to be at a lower height without compromising knee room. I like the original design too much to favor anything more than a few adjustments to the dimensions.

Re: Beginning prototyping

#8

Re: Beginning prototyping--request of the group

Larry Barrett

Wiley - I use a desk that was my Father's. It was store-bought, so likely common dimensions. Writing surface is 29". It has a shallow center drawer, the bottom of which is at 24". Chair height is 18", which leaves just a little clearance above my knees, maybe 1/2" or so. Center drawer holds pen/pencils and some paper pads. I seem to rarely need to open it once I am sitting at the desk, so it has not been an inconvenience. The top for your desk looks great, and I like your approach to the overall design.

Re: Beginning prototyping

#9

Re: Beginning prototyping--request of the group

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi All,

Using Richard's, Steve's, and Larry's comments--big thanks to them all!--I took another look at the tradeoff between drawer box size, writing height, and leg clearance.

Looking around the house, there is a desk I particularly like, that's been in the family for a while. Kneehole desk, with three leather insets on the writing surface. It's top is at 29-1/4", which is a little better than the 30" I'm using right now. It's kneehole height is 23-1/4" (yes, twenty three and change). With a 17" chair, it's OK; with an 18" chair, the clearance is a half-inch shy or so. But I like that 29-1/4" writing height.

Now Larry's desk is at 29" height with 24" clearance and 5" top + drawer box--all of which I like. I'm going with 29-1/4" top and 24" clearance, with 5-1/4" top + drawer box. And use 5/8" rails in front to get a 3-1/4" total drawer height.

Net effect: lower the top and the knee clearance, while maintaining drawer box.

Two drawers vs. three drawers. Richard offered critique and suggestions about drawer placement, and about how sitting at the desk would lock in both drawers. [Let me be frank and say I personally don't consider this an issue, as I have been sitting in front of desk drawers all my life.] But Richard makes a telling point which can't be denied, so I drew up a possible alternative, using three drawers. I would appreciate any comments the group might have to offer on the two-drawer vs. three-drawer approach. Or anything else for that matter!:

Two drawers:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/9345819500/in/set-72157632172323442

Three drawers:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/9345821922/in/set-72157632172323442

With the three-drawer model, the center drawer is still locked in, but the two side drawers could be opened without too much mayhem. The gross width of the drawer box (between the legs) is 32" even. The two drawers are each 15-5/8" wide; the three drawers are 14", 8-5/8", 8-5/8", with thinner vertical dividers. I kinda like the three drawer version.

Thanks again for your continuing help. All follow-on comments appreciated!

Wiley

Re: Beginning prototyping

#10

Re: Beginning prototyping--request of the group

Alex Y

Chair height 18.75

Knee clearance (bottom of keyboard tray) 25.75

Desktop 31.5 --works well for monitor, reading materials, etc. But high for writing--would feel better at about my keyboard height (28.8)

I'm 6'1"

Re: Beginning prototyping

#11

Re: Beginning prototyping--request of the group

Tom Colligan

Wiley,

Seat Height: 19.5"

Knee Height: 25"

Desk Height: 29"

Re: Beginning prototyping

#12

Thank you very much, Alex and Tom,

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

and certainly Richard for raising this issue of writing height. My favorite desk in the house (for writing height) is at 29-1/4", so will go with that.

Does anyone have a preference for the two-drawer vs. three-drawer model shown in my post just above? Or objections to either. Just based on what it looks like. Any and all opinions appreciated.

Wiley

Re: Beginning prototyping

#13

I prefer the 3-drawer version

Steve Elliott

I strongly prefer the one with three drawers -- it just seems like a more subtle design somehow. Seeing the two versions side by side made me think that just dividing something down the middle (the drawer case in this instance) is less interesting. Three drawers are more convenient (Richard's point) and they look better to my eye, too.

Re: Beginning prototyping

#14

Re: Thank you very much, Alex and Tom,

Larry Barrett

I agree with Steve - 3 drawer is much more interesting, and probably more convenient.

Re: Beginning prototyping

#15

Re: Thank you Richard, Steve and Larry!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

It's so helpful to get an outside view! It overcomes sclerotic thinking (hardening of the brain cells :) ). I will make the 3-drawer version.

I want to thank Richard, who certainly shook me out of my comfort zone. The changes made to desk height and drawer arrangement still do not meet his requirements, but his professionally-informed comments have had a big and continuing effect on how I and other forumites think about function and design.

Thanks again!

Wiley

Re: Beginning prototyping

#16

Re: A Design Detail

William Duffield

This consideration is beyond the size and shape of the drawers, but harkens back to Richard's comment on the interaction between the central drawer and the office chair (and the optional beer belly). The things that you want to keep in the central drawer are accessed often, but are usually very small, e.g., pens and pencils, erasers, letter openers, stamps, paper clips, dongles, data sticks, USB cables, etc.. Since most of these items are not large enough to need the full depth of the drawer, you might consider building a compartmentalized sliding till in the top front of the drawer, to give you two layers of small items. Behind the till and the compartmentalized space below it, you could leave a full depth space for storage of things you don't access so often, for which you would need to roll your chair back. Since the upper till would need to be slid back to access the contents of the compartments below it, the covered space below and behind could accommodate a secret compartment, or the till could be lifted out to access that space, or you could access it by sliding the till forward.

Re: Beginning prototyping

#17

Re: A Design Detail

Doug Trembath

As usual, from Mr. Duffield, a very good idea. The utility of the tills in the center drawer would make life much more pleasant when working at the desk, at least for this oldster. In following this thread, it never occurred to me to add drawers to mine due to the design. Now I have to revisit the slab desk that I currently use which is "Oh too tall" and contemplate adding some drawers with tills. I already struggle with finding an office chair which will adjust high enough to feel comfortable, and I'm only 6" tall. Just goes to show that some folks on this forum that contribute actually think before they post. Thanks, William !

Re: Beginning prototyping

#18

Re: A Design Detail

William Duffield

You're welcome. Another possibility, which I didn't mention, because I figured it might be too obvious, and it is very technology-dependent, is a pull-out keyboard shelf. In this case, for esthetics, it would need a rather tricky mechanism (no, I don't have plans) to drop the drawer front and fold it back underneath when you pul it out.

Re: Beginning prototyping

#19

Re: A Design Detail

Sgian Dubh

He could simply make the usable drawer space quite shallow front to back so that it only has to be pulled out 8 - 10" inches to gain access to whatever small objects tend to be stored there, and would lead to less need for the sitter to move when the drawer is opened. This could be accomplished with extended sides that go deeper under the top which would prevent the drawer tilting down or coming out of the opening completely if opened too far. If the drawer sides are extended that leaves a lot of unused space at the back that could be used for storage of less commonly used items, so another suggestion would be to make a drawer that extends full depth and put a left to right divider across some 7-1/4 - 9-1/4" behind the drawer front. Whatever choices are made I'm still not particularly enamoured with drawers directly in front of the sitter at a writing desk, but I appreciate that different designers and users have alternative priorities to mine. Slainte.

Re: Beginning prototyping

#20

Re: A Design Detail

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Thanks William and Richard and Doug,

I really like the sliding till idea. Maybe 2-1/2" rearward width, and slides 2-1/2" to uncover the bottom fixed till. Permanently housed runners, so the till won't get lost over time.

Since there are to be three drawers, I want to minimize wasted space. I'll use 1/4" drawer side thickness, and will make the sliding tray with thin parts, maybe 5/32" if I can dovetail it together. Seems to me Derek had a "thin dovetailing" contest with himself or others, and got down that thin, or even more.

Again, big thanks for your ideas!

Wiley

Re: Beginning prototyping

#21

Re: Beginning prototyping--request of the group

Bruce McCrory

Late, but a reply to measurements. I am at a rock-maple desk my wife brought home from Goodwill in about 30 pieces. Oh, about 30 years ago. It was rebuilt without clamps (only twisted rope.) There is no belly drawer.

Stand 5-7; Desk height: 28.5".

Chair: castered, cushioned, adjusted to 17" at load, but buttocks lower (at load). Note: legs are nearly horizontal at 21" and feet placed flat on carpeted floor.

I agree with Singh (Richard). Spent a fun part of my career at a drafting table. The belly drawers held instruments and paper/mylar. People were always toppling out of high drafting chairs. I developed back problems, due to half standing-sitting.

Presently, I like my desk, keyboard location, level-to-monitor-view, and chair. I have back problems--two oh hum surgeries. Fingers are always icy numb--pinched nerves at spine. I need new shoulders. I can stand about 15 to 20 minutes and then, must sit. Spend more time here than I want.

Enough for this post....

Re: Beginning prototyping

#22

Re: Beginning prototyping

Bruce McCrory

Proportions: These always get me into trouble, so I fall back to the standards, and feel better. My work looks better, too. The desk is very impressive at this level of evolution.

1. I always associate small, tight table top overhangs with chunky design. Yours are 3/8, a half? Maybe, push to 3/4, an inch each side? Your squared edges enhance the chunkiness. Don't change the squared design, though!

2. Back to the drawers. Yes, there needs to be drawers. But you also need at least 21 inches width for your belly, knees, and chair, if not arms. For a 38" top (39"?) minus 3.375" for legs, minus 1" for top overhang, minus my 21" body demand ... there are roughly 13.5" of clear drawer space.

What about side drawers that swing on a pin pivot? Or, drawers out the sides?

3. The perennial skinny-fat legs. I saw a Krenov-type do-dad hall table big enough to hold car keys on the cover of a recent wood working magazine. Fat legs. Big Fat Legs! Proportionally. On such a tiny piece of furniture. You can taper yours as a design-build change? I like 1-5/8 to 3/4. Maybe, stretch the 1-5/8 down a little farther? More stringing for the Paterae.

4. This is the last. The brackets don't fit. I am losing memory details but is there fretwork wrapping the legs, below the artwork, like beading? That could define the transition to leg taper, and fill the need for a "bracket".

This is fun. I hope same for you too..

Re: Beginning prototyping

#23

Re: Beginning prototyping--request of the group

Hank Knight

Hi, Wiley,

I like your three-drawer design a lot. I would point out, however, that the inside

Dimension of the two side drawers will likely be too narrow to accommodate an 8-1/2 X 11 sheet of paper. This may be of no concern, but it occurred to me that storage of standard-sized paper may be an important design consideration in a writing desk.

Hank

Re: Beginning prototyping

#24

Re: Beginning prototyping--request of the group

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Thank you, Hank. That's an excellent point. And yet the outer drawers are fairly close to the 8-1/2" inner dimension. I'm going to have to make up a full-size mock up to see what it looks like to take those outer drawers up a half-inch each.

Wiley

Re: Beginning prototyping

#25

Re: Beginning prototyping

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bruce,

I'll interline with your post:

Proportions: These always get me into trouble, so I fall back to the standards, and feel better. My work looks better, too. The desk is very impressive at this level of evolution.

1. I always associate small, tight table top overhangs with chunky design. Yours are 3/8, a half? Maybe, push to 3/4, an inch each side? Your squared edges enhance the chunkiness. Don't change the squared design, though!

I hear you. Here's the thing: every bit added to the overhang comes out of the drawer widths. Right now, I'm trying to favor the drawers. I need to prepare a full-scale mockup of the front to make these decisions.

2. Back to the drawers. Yes, there needs to be drawers. But you also need at least 21 inches width for your belly, knees, and chair, if not arms. For a 38" top (39"?) minus 3.375" for legs, minus 1" for top overhang, minus my 21" body demand ... there are roughly 13.5" of clear drawer space.

What about side drawers that swing on a pin pivot? Or, drawers out the side?

Bruce, I'm going to favor what it looks like to me. Yes, there are ways to move the drawers to one side, or opening out the sides, or pivoting around, or even placed up on top. But then I wouldn't have my project any more >( . My thinking is also influenced by the fact that every desk I ever sat at (except for a steel office desk once or twice) had a center drawer--so even though center drawers may not be ergonomically preferred, I'm used to them, and in fact for me they define in part what a desk looks like :\ . So I'm going to live with my center drawer, as I have all my life. There, that's my manifesto ;) .

3. The perennial skinny-fat legs. I saw a Krenov-type do-dad hall table big enough to hold car keys on the cover of a recent wood working magazine. Fat legs. Big Fat Legs! Proportionally. On such a tiny piece of furniture. You can taper yours as a design-build change? I like 1-5/8 to 3/4. Maybe, stretch the 1-5/8 down a little farther? More stringing for the Paterae.

These are key points you're making! Right now, I'm on 1-5/8" tapering to 7/8". Once I get the leg blanks to these dimensions, I need to see whether they're about right, or whether they're still heavy for the purpose. Maybe they need to be 1-11/16" tapering to 3/4" or 13/16"--need to make them first, and see.

My thinking on the height of the upper leg post--and you can check me on this!--is that the total paterae enclosure should match the total drawer height--so that the upper and lower paterae string should line up with the drawer cock-beading (1/16" to 3/32" thickness). Then the whole drawer box will be wrapped at the bottom by a slightly larger bead, maybe 1/8" to 5/32" thick (will have to test this at first fit up).

That lower bead will mark the beginning of the taper.

I'm very open to peoples' thoughts on these details, the decisions are yet to be finalized.

4. This is the last. The brackets don't fit. I am losing memory details but is there fretwork wrapping the legs, below the artwork, like beading? That could define the transition to leg taper, and fill the need for a "bracket".

You and others have said that the brackets don't work well. I think you're right. The original reason for including them was for actual functional purpose--to provide additional stiffening beyond that provided by the two front rails. Well, most desks/tables of this size don't have them, so they're probably not needed. And I don't look forward to making 6 or 8 of them either. The transition to the leg taper will be marked by a 1/8" to 5/32" bead, affixed to the bottom of the drawer box, which wraps the entire project.

Bruce, thank you very much for the time and thought you put into this post.

Wiley