New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Carpel tunnel problem fixed!

Posts

Carpel tunnel problem fixed!

#1

Carpel tunnel problem fixed!

Hank Knight

Last January my Kid spent a week with me in my shop building there-legged Chinese stools. We had seen them in an Ai Weiwei sculpture at the Hirshorn Museum in DC last Fall and Katherine commented that she could use one in her studio. We decided to build two, one for her studio and one for my shop.

We had a wonderful week together in the shop. She was pressed for time and had to get back to DC, so we concentrated on her stool and finished it.

[URL=http://s50.photobucket.com/user/hankknight/media/Katherine/image_zps5f193718.jpg.html][/URL]

Mine got put on hold because the week of intense hand work in oak aggravated my carpel tunnel problem and just about did me in. I went to my Orthopaedist who scheduled surgery for mid-May. Meanwhile I spent three weeks in China ( nothing to do with the stool) and returned in time for the surgery. A month later, the surgery has proved to be a complete success and I'm back in the shop. I picked up where I left off with my stool and finished it last night. It's fun when it doesn't hurt!

[URL=http://s50.photobucket.com/user/hankknight/media/Katherine/image_zps20aa11d5.jpg.html][/URL]

Re: Carpel tunnel problem fixed!

#2

Great several ways

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Glad to hear your hand/wrist problem is resolved.

Nice stools.

What fun it must have been getting time in the shop with your daughter. Adult children can be such a delight, in ways that are like and unlike the years when they're young. I appreciate when I learn something from my sons, and, well, yes, there are times that I know something they don't, and that's nice too (although increasingly rare); but the banter and play is great fun.

Re: Carpel tunnel problem fixed!

#3

Re: Great several ways

Hank Knight

Thanks, Bill. I agree on all counts, grown kids are great!

Re: Carpel tunnel problem fixed!

#4

Re: Great several ways

Patrick Gibbons

Sounds like I have something to look forward to. The stool looks great. How long a build was it for you? Any advantage to three legs over four?

Re: Carpel tunnel problem fixed!

#5

Re: Carpel tunnel problem fixed!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Hank,

That's a striking stool! So solid and direct.

About the angles....I see that the simple angles where the three brace pieces come together, all have to be 60 degrees. Did you obtain the leg angles by just laying out sticks until you got it the way it looked best? And to make the angled cuts through the seat, did you drill at the known angle, and then chisel from both sides?

Also, did you make all the parts at once, and then drive them together, little by little? Or go sequentially--legs, then seat, then bracing?

And can you share any China impressions?

Glad the carpal tunnel problem is no more!

Wiley

Re: Carpel tunnel problem fixed!

#6

I'll try an answer

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Uneven floors - three legs will always find a place to settle on an uneven floor; four legs will want to rock. This is why orchard ladders have three legs.

Re: Carpel tunnel problem fixed!

#7

Re: Carpel tunnel problem fixed!

Bob Lang

Nice work Hank! Glad to hear the surgery worked, and you have a kid to be proud of.

I wrote the article on building the stool for the final issue of "Woodworking Magazine". You can download the article for a couple of bucks from Popular Woodworking and a search on "Chinese Stool" on the PW editor's blog might be interesting. This is one of the most popular magazine projects I've made, judging by the pictures I've been sent and examples I've seen online.

My dad was an engineer who was fond of triangles because they don't wrack the way rectangles can. These stools when put together are incredibly strong due to the triangular arrangement. The joints need to be a bit loose to assemble, then wedges driven in from outside lock it all together.

Making one involves a couple leaps of faith as the main reference point doesn't actually exist except at the seat and the floor. The stretchers are assembled around an equilateral triangle, with the legs left long. Everything revolves around a vertical centerline, so draw full size circles for the inner diameter of the spread of the legs at the floor, and where the top of the legs hit the seat. Project those points up and down to the overall height and you have the angle of the mortises through the seat and the angle for the mortises through the legs. I assemble the stretchers as a unit and the three legs and seat as another unit.

Set both subassemblies on the full size drawing and you can figure out the angle of the tenons that go through the legs. With a square, you can determine the height of the stretcher to leg joints, and that point projected back down gives you the shoulder location on the stretchers.

I can't speak officially yet, but there is a pretty good chance that we will be filming a video of building the stool in our shop along with several "students/guests" who will be building along in the near future.

Bob Lang

Re: Carpel tunnel problem fixed!

#8

Re: Carpel tunnel problem fixed!

Hank Knight

Hi, Wiley,

The stool is based on Bob Lang's article in the Winter '09 issue of Woodworking Magazine. His post below may answer some of your questions.

I thought the legs on his stool were splayed too much so I reduced his angle a little. I drew out the legs and the angles on a piece of 1/8" plywood to use as a template. I knew the height I wanted for the stool so I calculated the radius of the circle the legs would define at the floor (Pythagoras is your friend here). I drew two concentric circles on my plywood template, one was the circumference of the seat, the other the circle the legs define at the floor. Then I drew the 60 degree brace structure centered in the circles. I could then draw the brace tenons that fit into the legs (they don't contact the legs at 90 degrees) by erecting a tangent at the point on the seat circle where the braces would touch and registering 90 degrees off this tangent line for the tenons. The top of the brace mortises are at the intersection of the leg and a perpendicular line from the edge of the seat to the floor. I marked the location for the brace mortises by assembling the legs and the seat and placing the assembly on the template and marking the location where the seat circumference intersects the legs by placing a square on the template at the seat circumference and marking where the square touched the legs. Actually, I only marked one leg in this manner and marked the other two from this one.

I built two drilling jigs, one with the leg angle, the other with the 60 degree brace assembly angle. I used these to drill all mortises. Then I chiseled them and fit each tenon individually. I hand cut the tenon shoulders and cut the cheeks on the bandsaw. As Bob mentioned in his post, the joinery needs to be loose initially so you can get all the joints to go together simultaneously for glue up. Then you drive wedges into the gaps to tighten everything up.

I wish I could claim credit for figuring all this out; but, in truth, Bob explains it all in his article. I just followed his instructions. Still, it's a tricky little project, and a lot of fun.

Hank

Re: Carpel tunnel problem fixed!

#9

Re: Carpel tunnel problem fixed!

Hank Knight

Hi, Bob,

Your article was the jumping off point for a great adventure with my Kid. I was intrigued by it when I first read it in '09, but I didn't commit to the project for a couple of years. Ai Wei Wei, the Chinese artist/dissident, had an exhibit at the Hirshorn Museum in D.C. that featured one of his conceptual sculptures made from many three legged stools joined together:

[URL=http://s50.photobucket.com/user/hankknight/media/Katherine/image_zpsbcf62635.jpg.html][/URL]

When my daughter saw the sculpture and commented that she could use one of the stools in her studio, I remembered your article. The rest is in my original post.

Thank you. Your article opened a wonderful opportunity for me. It was a fun project, one that I probably wouldn't have undertaken but for you and my my Kid.

Hank

Re: Carpel tunnel problem fixed!

#10

Re: Carpel tunnel problem fixed!

Steve Kirincich

I think this would be a great project to video. When I made this stool, I needed to re-read the article more times than I wish to remember. A picture can definitely be worth a thousand words!

Steve

Re: Carpel tunnel problem fixed!

#11

More Answers

Hank Knight

Wiley, I didn't answer all of your questions, so I'll take another shot at it.

We dimensioned and cut all the parts to rough size first. Then we cut the seat-leg joinery and fit each joint individually. As I mentioned above, we drilled the mortises using an angle jig and chiseled them. Tenon shoulders were hand sawn and cheeks cut on the band saw. Next we made the stretcher assembly using the same techniques. Finally, after figuring out and drawing the seat-stretcher joinery, we cut and fit each joint the same way. The stretcher assembly can be glued up separately, but everything else has to be assembled and glued at one time. It's a little hairy and Katherine's extra set of hands were welcome. One important tip: be careful to mark each part clearly while you cut the joinery to make sure you cut the angles correctly and to facilitate the piece going together properly when it's all on the line!

As for China, I could spend a lot of ink telling you my impressions, but I'll try to restrain myself. Like many Americans of my era, my mental images of China were formed in the Mao years. I thought of China as a vast country, struggling under fairly primitive conditions and densely populated by unhappy people who trudged off to their daily tasks under the watchful eye of an oppressive government. What I found couldn't be farther from that picture.

China's enormous population is young. You have to look to find people over 40. The country has come very far in the last 20 or 30 years. The infrastructure is new, high tech and efficient. Wealth is evident everywhere, at least in the big cities (I'm sure the hinterlands are not as advanced or as wealthy). Cars are plentiful, new and expensive European and American models. The place is clean as a pin, no trash or graffiti anywhere. On the 5 hour bullet train ride from Tianjin to Shanghai, I saw at least five nuclear power plants from my train car. Construction is booming everywhere. I counted 32 construction cranes from my Hotel window in Shanghai. The people feel engaged in and responsible for all this progress. They are enthusiastic, busy and happy; and they are very proud of their country. Keep your eye on China. They are the coming thing.

Hank

Re: Carpel tunnel problem fixed!

#12

Re: Great several ways

Hank Knight

Hi, Patrick,

Bill answered your question about three legs vs. four. The whole project took my daughter and I four days. But we were building two stools and she didn't have time to put any kind of finish on her stool before she left to go home. As I said in my post, I didn't complete mine until later. My guess is that you could probably do the whole build including the finish in five days, starting from rough stock. Maybe four if you're better at this stuff than I am.

Hank

Re: Carpel tunnel problem fixed!

#13

Re: More Answers

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hank,

Thanks for the lucid explanation (as always!). I know what you mean about that moment when everything has to go together before the glue skins over. And then something hangs up. Where's that mallet. Good tip about fitting a little loose, and then wedging after.

That's very interesting about China. Most of the stuff I read every day is China-bears bemoaning China's economy--shadow lending, bad debts, and omigod, the growth rate is down to 6-1/2% a year. But then, those who go there say it's humming.

Wiley

Re: Carpel tunnel problem fixed!

#14

Re: Chinese Stools as Art

William Duffield

For an interesting interpretation of this type of stool, search Google Images for "Ai Weiwei stools". Weiwei was the artistic consultant for the Beijing National Olympic Stadium (also known as the "Birds Nest").

Re: Carpel tunnel problem fixed!

#15

Chinese Stool Class *LINK*

Bob Lang

Now it's official. I'll be hosting a class on building the Chinese stool mentioned in this thread at the Popular Woodworking Magazine shop in Cincinnati, Aug 17 & 18

Bob Lang


Info on Chinese Stool Class