New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

The improved quality of "modern" KD lumber

Posts

The improved quality of "modern" KD lumber

#1

The improved quality of "modern" KD lumber

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I live in the midst of the world's production of hardwood lumber, with numerous 25,0000 to 125,000 bdft per day capacity mills is the area. The following is a discussion of what I have seen in the past 40 years of hardwood lumber production.

Years ago mills and kilns were smaller and less sophisticated. Many years ago I provided help at a 30,000 bdft capacity kiln where the operator had a middle school education and couldn't do simple math calculations to calculate a kiln schedule and moisture content. Now days 1,000,000 bd ft of kiln capacity is managed by someone with a forestry degree and the kiln is under computer control.

Back then lumber was sawed, often on small relatively crude mills, put up on sticks, set out in the sun for XX days to air dry as mother nature wished and then put in the kiln to further dry. The stacks going into the kiln would vary in initial moisture content, some lumber would be miscut and might be 1/4" thicker than average, air circulation in the kiln might not be optimumly designed, stacking in the kiln ( a critical factor in air circulation) was under the control of a minimum wage fork lift operator. The product going in was variable and the drying conditions were variable. Some lumber dried too fast and the result was drying defects and stress. Many small kilns had no provision for post drying steaming and conditioning to relieve stress and uniform the product.

The result was lumber discolored from the outside air drying, and a product were at best some boards suffered the ill effects of improper drying- case hardening, honey comb and splits . Occasionally, the whole charge would be screwed up. I believe that much of the folklore of KD lumber traces to lumber produced under these historical conditions.

Modern lumber is produced under conditions I have described in the Articles Section on hardwood lumber production. The modern lumber is not discolored from weathering, it is end trimmed, and dried under carefully controlled conditions to yield a uniform stress free product. (Conditions at Boutique facilities may vary)

That said, if you buy enough lumber you may encounter the result of some screw up in manufacture or grading. Don't claim this exception is the rule.

Re: The improved quality of "modern" KD lumber

#2

depends what you're buying

Chris Friesen

While larger sizes (2x10 and bigger) are generally pretty good, I haven't had much luck with 2x4 and smaller, and 2x6 is often marginal.

Maybe I'm just picky, but if I'm building a wall I want my studs to be straight, not crooked or bowed by half an inch or more. Warped studs lead to messed-up drywall and make everything else more complicated.

Re: The improved quality of "modern" KD lumber

#3

Hardwood...

John in NM

Bill doesn't seem to be discussing dimension lumber for framing here - ie 2x4's and the like. The hardwood business has different standards and expectations and there is simply little comparison between the two.

The construction industry does not demand dry so much as cheap, so that is what the mills serving up dimension lumber provide.

Re: The improved quality of "modern" KD lumber

#4

additionally.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

while the quality of drying for hardwood lumber, and probably any lumber, has improved, this is just one factor determining the quality of the dry product. Log quality, sawing and grading standards are three others. Log quality has most definitely gotten worse. The high productivity of modern mills enables them to economically saw smaller logs and smaller logs yield less clear, wide lumber. The saws at large mills are more accurate than what was found in the smaller mills some decades ago and they yield more uniform lumber. I can usually clean up band mill and gang saw milled lumber with a 1/16" planer pass if there is little cup.

In the past there was but one standard for grading, National Hardwood Lumber Association rules. The mill I recently visited sorted oak into more than 4 dozen grade categories, none of which had any bearing on NHLA rules! No more or less than in the past you will probably get the grade you are paying for, but you will probably have no clue what that grade is at the retail level. However, when lumber supplies are tight more lumber on the low end of the grade range will be included.

Re: The improved quality of "modern" KD lumber

#5

Re: Very interesting

Tom

Does walnut still come out with the sapwood darkened? Presumably it could if they wanted to run it that way?

Re: The improved quality of "modern" KD lumber

#6

James Pickering

Even coloration of Walnut *LINK*

James Pickering

Following is from an article I wrote relating to MI carbine production during WWII:

There is a great reference book available "THE M-1 CARBINE A Revolution in Gun-Stocking" by Grafton H. Cook, II and Barbara W. Cook that covers in exhaustive detail the story of the S.E. Overton Company (the O in the Inland IO stamping) which produced by far the greatest number of carbine stocks and handguards -- almost three million sets -- as the primary US Government sub-contractor during WW2. Most of their output was used by the Inland Division of General Motors Corporation in fulfilling their carbine contracts -- just about all Inland carbines have Overton stocks and handguards. Overton purchased the walnut blanks from the Hartzell Hardwoods Co. BTW, Hartzell is the only one of the four WW2 manufacturing companies involved here that is still in business -- Inland Division of General Motors, Richardson Tool Co. and the S.E. Overton Co. are all now defunct.

For the past several years I had pondered why I remember newly issued carbines I encountered in military service (Korean conflict) invariably having walnut stocks & handguards that possessed an overall rich brown coloration and yet I had not been able to unearth any information relating to wood staining operations during the manufacturing process. (I am referring to documented primary source data -- not anecdotal remembrances).

The supplier of Walnut for Overton, Hartzell Hardwoods Inc., Piqua, Ohio (link below) used pressurized steam to open the pores of the wood in order to blend the light colored sapwood with the dark brown heart wood thereby producing the even rich brown coloration I reference above throughout the walnut -- a universally standard industry practice pioneered by Hartzell. The process is touched upon on their website.

Any light colored wood areas discovered during manufacture were stain darkened to match by Overton workers using an air-brush (Operation 38). Stocks and handguards were finished by immersing in a vat of Raw Linseed Oil (Operation 37).

The above procedures are documented by Overton for finishing the stocks and handguards they produced. I presume other Manufacturers would have used essentially the same procedures also (taking the lead from Overton) but I cannot find any information on this.

I would appreciate any comments and corrections.

James


Hartzell Hardwoods Inc., Piqua, Ohio

Re: The improved quality of "modern" KD lumber

#7

Re: depends what you're buying

Tom

there was this article in FHB on how to go from framing to rocking. It was a special trade. The guy assessed the wall then did stuff like cut half way through the stud (!!) to bend it out of the way, or apply specially made mesonite strips to bring it up. I actually Have a pretty cool method using foam. which also reduces bridging. But anyway, yeah, the stuff is horrible. And locally the quality fell off a cliff a few years ago.

Re: The improved quality of "modern" KD lumber

#8

Re: Even coloration of Walnut

Tom

That's cool. I am modestly familiar with the M1 as a neighbour had several before the great cut-up, up here. I didn't realize the history. Industry is awesome. Imagine 3 million stocks! I love making stuff one at a time by hand, but wow, I only have that luxury due to the rate at which stuff is being pushed out by others!

Re: The improved quality of "modern" KD lumber

#9

process details

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The process of steaming involves chemical reactions. It works best before the wood is dry and it is typically done just after the wood is sawed. Once the wood hits a temperature of near 100 C with wet steam the sapwood darkens through chemical reactions to almost match the heartwood. Pressure is not essential. One can replicate the process on the stove by suspending walnut above boiling water until the wood temperature gets near 100C. The wood must stay damp from the steam.

See a discussion of walnut steaming and equipment in the WC Articles section under hardwood lumber production by me.

Re: The improved quality of "modern" KD lumber

#10

Re: depends what you're buying

Don Stephan

In my area, framing lumber 2x6 and smaller is spf (spruce-pine-fir) white wood, while 2x8 and larger is yellow pine. I suspect the yellow pine produces a much better board than the spf. And in my area all framing lumber is sold at a higher moisture content, so there can be significant warping as it completes drying.

Re: The improved quality of "modern" KD lumber

#11

Air dried

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have worked both air died and kiln dried lumber my whole career. There are some subtle differences and some of these are specific to a certain species. If you have a nice board to work with, be thankful. The many other considerations when choosing a board far outweigh its drying history.

I think the ideal is to develop a relationship with a talented sawyer. Stack the boards under roof in a shed with plenty of air and let it dry. This is what the most discriminating workers do in our area.

The trouble with buying kiln dried wood from a big supplier is that the boards from a tree get split up. The board you should have for the top drawer front is in Peoria and the board you should have for the left side of the chest is in Tokyo.

Re: The improved quality of "modern" KD lumber

#12

Re: Air dried

CStanford

Good point. Air-dried and in-the-boule is the gold standard. Everything else is just a varying theme of the same running joke on the serious furnituremaker.

Re: The improved quality of "modern" KD lumber

#13

Re: Air dried

CStanford

George Nakashima:

Sawing

The proper way to treat fine timber is to cut for the boule, starting from one side of the log and cutting through it without slabbing or squaring the log. This method of sawing is also known as "sawing through and through." If the log is a proper shape with no unusual branching, and the equipment appropriate, this can readily be done.

Some trees in particular should be cut at the precise moment of maturity. Then the curing and drying should begin.

Re: The improved quality of "modern" KD lumber

#14

Re: depends what you're buying

Chuck Kettler

Find a lumber yard that carries finger jointed studs. They are made from pieces and parts, cost a little more, but are straight and stay straight. The additional cost is a small price to pay for the resulting quality.

Re: The improved quality of "modern" KD lumber

#15

Talk to woodturners

Bob Hackett

Many of the woodturning folks have developed an understanding of wood from tree to finished product and how to successfully convert a tree to a useful and beautiful bit of work.

When I say an understanding I mean how to assess a standing tree, how and where to cut/rive for the best grain direction and flow and then how the wood will move while it dries as well as how to season wood with the least mount of loss due to splitting, cracking, rot and severe wood movement/warping.

Bill`s excellent article is very useful for the folks who want a predictable raw material to begin a project, folks who want to focus on the making of the piece rather than having to invest their limited time and effort into better understanding the material their work is made from.

I have to agree with Warren on this his point about patiently and carefully converting wood. The folks up here in Maine who have produced and still do produce the most beautiful and enduring work usually enjoy a working relationship with several lumberjacks and small sawmills both locally and beyond the state ( the "beyond" gained thru networking with other visiting WWers). While the folks Bill talks about produce the bulk of what we see in lumberyards and wood dealers the really unique and beautiful wood that is custom cut with the intended work in mind can only be had by building this understanding and relationship with like minded individuals who share a love of wood and fine work, a love and understanding that holds priority over love of profit. That kind of relationship most often begins in the forest, long before any wood is laid on a rack or a bench.

The folks who turn wood usually begin with the cast offs from the folks Bill talks about in his well written and informative lumber article. Turners take the wood that others find too difficult to convert, in much larger large pieces and successfully make unique projects of incredible beauty and utility out of what would many times be burned, ground up for biomass or left to rot. If you want to better understand wood and gain access to unique material that will set your work apart from the rest these are the kind of folks you want to talk to. This is the kind of knowledge that is capable of opening doors and taking your work to the next level and beyond.

Re: The improved quality of "modern" KD lumber

#16

Few have that luxury

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

While what Warren says is a desirable goal and makes matching parts easy it is impractical for most woodworkers. They don't live where the lumber they love grows, or it isn't practical for them to buy and dry from a saw mill. It may work in rural VA, but not so well in a Seattle suburb.

Next best is to settle on a wood you like and buy a 500 bd ft pack of it, if you have the space and money. Lumber of identical grade from a log will largely stay together through the manufacturing process until the pack gets sold. That said, logs are so poor now days that when buying the top grade there might only be 4 boards from a log in the pack and they will be sawed from 4 different faces of the log and hence not adjacent matching cuts.

There are approaches to deal with this reality. One is to buy 8/4 lumber and saw veneer from it for matching drawer fronts, for example. Or, as I described previously, make cabinetry sides from a singe wide board by cutting it and folding it back on itself like a knife hinge. Or, use rift cut lumber which is relatively easy to match. Or, when it can be done, sort through a large stack or your or a suppliers lumber to find pieces that attractively match. Use plywood which is laid up from a veneer flitch. All these approaches are used to produce attractive furniture, in Idaho for example.

Re: The improved quality of "modern" KD lumber

#17

Good for George, not for most woodworkers

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

For the style of furniture he makes this way of sawing a log can be"proper". It isn't proper, or desirable, for making more typical cabinetry. Through sawing as described is practical on a Woodmiser but impossible on a circle saw. The dogs can't hold the log on the carriage. And, even a large circle mill is limited to a 22" deep cut.

Through sawing will yield the widest possible boards and lumber that is the least defect-free. Typical sawing isolates clear lumber and concentrates defects in the remaining lumber which will include the typically worthless lumber from the tree center (see description of typical sawing in my article in the Articles section of WC). The widest boards from through sawing will have the heart of the tree incorporated in the board and it will split, if not shatter, upon drying.

For the style of furniture George's shop makes knots, splits, wane, which will be a prominent part of through sawed lumber, are all part of the plan to yield his trendy designs. They don't look so good on Period pieces, as one example. So to state that through sawing is "proper" is misleading.

Re: The improved quality of "modern" KD lumber

#18

Re: Good for George, not for most woodworkers

CStanford

Good for all furnituremakers who can then choose what parts they care to use given the style they care to build.

Any furnituremaker whose juices don't get flowing at this sort of stock have something rattling around loose somewhere:

http://www.irionlumber.com/index.php?page=slab-live-edge

If you don't like the live edge then saw it off in your shop.

Re: The improved quality of "modern" KD lumber

#19

Re: Good for George, not for most woodworkers

CStanford

Or maybe this (click on a species):

http://www.irionlumber.com/index.php?page=matched-sets-home

Re: The improved quality of "modern" KD lumber

#20

Re: the woodmizer guys..

david weaver

..the guys with the woodmizers tend to be far and away the best way to get lumber around here. When I go to a millwork and hardwood supplier, they have subpar stuff that was all flatsawn on a modern mill, none of the boards are very nice and it's obvious that the process was set up to give uniform flatsawn lumber and maxmimize the profits from the milling by selling to easy-to-satisfy end users.

Compare that with the guys who will deliver kiln dried plain sawn through and through lumber from the same tree here for half as much.

The irion prices charlie linked are unreal, but if the customer is willing to pay, no problem. Goodness, it looks so much better it's ridiculous.

The last load of lumber I got was from a local sawyer here and it was KD cherry all from the same tree for $3 a foot. I don't think there is any reason to encourage anyone remotely close to here to do anything other than look for the small operations like that. There is enough defect material in the lumber, even if it's $4 a board foot, to make it worth using the very underwhelming commercial lumber.

Unfortunately, my source just retired. So I have to go down to the woodworking club and make buddies with a new supplier sometime soon. Even at that, there is GOBS of lumber that shows up on CL everywhere in the northeast and parts of the midwest close to it...lumber that wasn't commercially milled and lumber you can use tastefully without thinking "ghee...this would look good if I stained it and completely covered it all up".

Re: The improved quality of "modern" KD lumber

#21

Re: depends what you're buying

R Payne

Don't rely on finger jointed studs to be straight. They are usually straighter than regular studs, but no guarantees any stud will be straight. Then there is the question of strength.

Re: The improved quality of "modern" KD lumber

#22

Re: Good for George, not for most woodworkers

Tom

"The widest boards from through sawing will have the heart of the tree incorporated in the board and it will split, if not shatter, upon drying."

Normally the pith is where they split, and if one simply saws through the pith of the boards, they largely won't split. What I sometimes do with the chainsaw mill is saw right through the pith, to the extent possible. So for starters the saw takes out about .4" of the pith. The adjacent piece are at least going to warp along what remains of the pith, the main advantage is just less trim.

Other times I will saw so I center the pith in the widest board. Then trim it out. The get there is a lot of edge grain wood. in traditional cabinetmaking you don't mostly want to display that pith centered board, even if you could, it is edge grain, and it is not usually the most attractive wood. But it is perfect to frame the other flat sawn wood.