We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
In an earlier post by Bill Tindall (Subject: Desk- dovetailing the legs to rails) I notice several different markings.... 1)which leg this is, 2)where is the front of the leg, 3) the socket for the mating dovetail. I use the triangle marking system which is common in Europe and I believe it to be a simple, foolproof marking system. Do others here use it? What do you think of it? Would a write-up article be of value?
The triangle marking method is simple but it can convey a lot of important information. If I draw a triangle on the front edge of a pair of carcase sides I can tell immediately that each piece is part of a pair, which edges are the face, top and bottom, and which side will be on the case interior. I can tell all of that even if I am looking at the part upside down.
On doors I use a single triangle on the face of two doors that are a left/right pair and a triangle in the middle of a door that's not part of a pair. On the left/right pair the half-triangle on each tells me which is the hinge side.
I learned the method in the first shop I worked at, which was run by a Norwegian who had apprenticed in Norway after World War II. I believe Krenov also used it but I haven't looked at his books for many years.
As I get ever more labor into a part, for example a leg, I take ever more precautions to prevent screw ups and that involves redundancy, at times, manifested as excessive marking of what goes where, what goes up, what faces front, as well as marks I made by mistake or got partially obliterated.
But to answer your question, yes write it up and both post and send to me as a MS Word file and I will get it into the Articles.
Personally I have not found the triangle as easy or fool proof as my "personalize" system. But your article may convince me to try it again.
I use the triangle for gluing panels. I learned it from Roubo about 40 years ago.
I use other markings for face side, face edge, grain direction and joints. I haven't seen a whole lot of marking on American period furniture, but I have seen some in chalk, so maybe others have worn away or were washed away from a show surface. I am hoping the Roubo text will have some remarks about marking. Here are some other marks from Roubo.
I think I saw a mark on the top of one of your legs that matches the way shown in this sketch. In addition to these marks I sometimes add letters A, B, C, D on both parts of a joint to make sure I put the parts together right during glue-up.
I have no idea how I got to this point, probably a result of one or more screw ups, but I put geometric marks on the parts as I make them to size and then number the joints while fitting them, for example M&T. So, I wind up with a redundancy of codes.
I use chalk where a surface will show (chalk disappears with finish, and maker or pen where it doesn't. Black pen shows up better than pencil on all woods.
For panels I've used a system I assume was British. I copied it from the Bernard Jones book. If the panel is three boards, I draw one line from board one to board two, two lines from board two to board three. I use the cursive F for designating squared boards and a, b, c, d for M&T and dovetails. The triangle system looks like a simple and unambiguous way to mark.
for flat panels, table tops, etc. But for frames or legs I use a simple number system: #1 & #3 for the 'right' hand side [the word 'right' has an odd number of letters] and #2 & #4 for the 'left' hand side [the word 'left' has an even number of letters]. I don't use the hash mark just the numbers. Sometimes I substitute dots [made with an awl] for the same purpose.
Fine Woodworking #8, Adrian von Draanen. The definitive article. Gary Blum at Blum Tools used to have an article on his blog as well that refers to the FW article.
Timber framers identify beams and joints with Roman numerals. All the characters used in the numerals applicable to buildings consist only of straight line segments, and each segment can thus be incised with two chops of a straight chisel. I've done the same thing when marking drawers in chests and slip seats in dining room chair sets, so the customer would not get them mixed up when moving them later. The marks go in on the outside, back of the drawers, on the inside surface of the rear rail, and the bottom of the slip seat.
This particular example is Moravian. They use a different code, but the method of marking is the same. This is the Single Brothers Workshop in Old Salem, NC.